Emmerdale - Current Episode Discussion - III

[Son of Cain]

Liv, Mandy and Vinny need to go. I am fed up with all 3 of them.

I would add Aaron, Ben and MacKenzie to that list.

[Dennis tanner]

I would add Aaron, Ben and MacKenzie to that list.

Agreed. Plus Meena !!!!

[Son of Cain]

Agreed. Plus Meena !!!!

I would keep Meena, as I think she brings an element of comedy to the show, altho' I don't think it is meant to be comedy. I enjoy her scheming, plotting and manipulations. But I would add "Depressing Tracey" and "Robotic Nate".
Did Nate not live on the farm at one time, is there a farmhouse at Wylie's, if so why don't him and Tracey move there and save some money?

[Son of Cain]

Is Ethan charging Victoria and Diane for looking into Robert's case. At the rate solicitors charge I am wondering if either of them could afford it. Whatever happened to Victoria's food van, does she still have?

[Ruffed_lemur]

I would keep Meena, as I think she brings an element of comedy to the show, altho' I don't think it is meant to be comedy. I enjoy her scheming, plotting and manipulations. But I would add "Depressing Tracey" and "Robotic Nate".
Did Nate not live on the farm at one time, is there a farmhouse at Wylie's, if so why don't him and Tracey move there and save some money?

Nate lived in a caravan on the farm. Moira used to spend a lot of her time there. ;)
As for Meena, she's getting a bit too dark for me. She went too far trying to kill the dog.

[Dennis tanner]

I would keep Meena, as I think she brings an element of comedy to the show, altho' I don't think it is meant to be comedy. I enjoy her scheming, plotting and manipulations. But I would add "Depressing Tracey" and "Robotic Nate".
Did Nate not live on the farm at one time, is there a farmhouse at Wylie's, if so why don't him and Tracey move there and save some money?
I agree with the additions. Tracey would not be able to live away from the village. She might want a coffee.

[lizann]

Is Ethan charging Victoria and Diane for looking into Robert's case. At the rate solicitors charge I am wondering if either of them could afford it. Whatever happened to Victoria's food van, does she still have?

the food van was used when the pub was closed for refurbishment repairs not sure where it is now

[Son of Cain]

Nate lived in a caravan on the farm. Moira used to spend a lot of her time there. ;)
As for Meena, she's getting a bit too dark for me. She went too far trying to kill the dog.

Was the caravan not on Moira's farm? When he first took over Wylie's I think he was working with Pete Barton and I am sure they stayed on the farm.

[Ruffed_lemur]

Was the caravan not on Moira's farm? When he first took over Wylie's I think he was working with Pete Barton and I am sure they stayed on the farm.

It could have been, not sure. I know he lived in a caravan anyway.

[lizann]

Was the caravan not on Moira's farm? When he first took over Wylie's I think he was working with Pete Barton and I am sure they stayed on the farm.

yes they lived together on the farm but pete couldn't bear it as it was where his mother kept his dad hostage

[Dennis tanner]

Nate, an experienced farm labourer, was totally unsuitable to run a farm.

[lizann]

kim and will off to hide

[Snagglepus]

Surely Dawn will go to the police station enquiring after her dad.

[lizann]

Surely Dawn will go to the police station enquiring after her dad.

or harriet ask a contact in the force

jamie will want a body released for burial

[Dennis tanner]

or harriet ask a contact in the force

jamie will want a body released for burial

I knew it was false when Will was told it might be time for him to leave rather than be marched off in handcuffs.

Would you really spend time alone with someone who you have just told that they have been poisoned and have an hour to live???

I am sick and tired of Livesy, Tracey and Liv.

[Son of Cain]

If the Kim and Jamie poison story was an attempt at "Drama and Suspense" it failed miserably. If was obvious Kim was not dead and equally obvious that she did not put poison in Jamie's drink. Why is it that characters wanting to leave somewhere, in times of danger, just give up when they find the front door locked, instead of trying the back door or try to climb out a window. I would have thought that Jamie living there would have a key. I thought they would drag it out a bit more, that Kim would disappear for a while before confronting Jamie. Not sure whether I am glad or sad that they didn't. It's hard to say where Emmerdale sits now it's not dramatic enough to be drama and not funny enough to be comedy. I really cannot think of any characters that I like, certainly think of those I don't.

[Dennis tanner]

If the Kim and Jamie poison story was an attempt at "Drama and Suspense" it failed miserably. If was obvious Kim was not dead and equally obvious that she did not put poison in Jamie's drink. Why is it that characters wanting to leave somewhere, in times of danger, just give up when they find the front door locked, instead of trying the back door or try to climb out a window. I would have thought that Jamie living there would have a key. I thought they would drag it out a bit more, that Kim would disappear for a while before confronting Jamie. Not sure whether I am glad or sad that they didn't. It's hard to say where Emmerdale sits now it's not dramatic enough to be drama and not funny enough to be comedy. I really cannot think of any characters that I like, certainly think of those I don't.

There are so many unlikeable characters but Charity Dingle is not one of them

[lizann]

There are so many unlikeable characters but Charity Dingle is not one of them

i agree

[flappinfanny]

I don't know how the cast kept a straight face, filming that poisoning storyline.

[lizann]

meena ever work as a nurse

no vaccines given out by manpreet and liam, zak pearl and faith should be in contention

[Dennis tanner]

meena ever work as a nurse

no vaccines given out by manpreet and liam, zak pearl and faith should be in contention

Vaccines are not given out. They are injected.

[Son of Cain]

Why do characters in Soaps never tell anyone when they are ill?

Is that guy Ben's dad?

[lizann]

where did chas get that wad of cash

[Dennis tanner]

Why do characters in Soaps never tell anyone when they are ill?

Is that guy Ben's dad?

I reckon so

Why do soap characters never give people the chance to explain. ?

[Son of Cain]

where did chas get that wad of cash

From Cain, I think, but if so, where did he get it?

[flappinfanny]

I don't know who is more miserable and whinny, Liv or Aaron? why would Ben what to be with Aaron?

[Dennis tanner]

I don't know who is more miserable and whinny, Liv or Aaron? why would Ben what to be with Aaron?

It gives Ben a chance to be on the tele

[Son of Cain]

I don't know who is more miserable and whinny, Liv or Aaron? why would Ben what to be with Aaron?

Liv keeps talking about having "fun" but I see little evidence of this.

[Snagglepus]

Can't believe Manpreet didn't feel things rattling around in the rucksack.
Can't believe Liam didn't notice the first aid box in the rucksack when he was putting the presents in.
Billy is in the frame, witnessed by Dan.
Jacob is going to be in the frame as Leyla told him to go and see her.
Or Maybe Meena gets caught red handed so we don't have another long drawn out who done it saga.

Why does Noah always snort before he speaks, does he have a sinus problem?

[Dennis tanner]

Can't believe Manpreet didn't feel things rattling around in the rucksack.
Can't believe Liam didn't notice the first aid box in the rucksack when he was putting the presents in.
Billy is in the frame, witnessed by Dan.
Jacob is going to be in the frame as Leyla told him to go and see her.
Or Maybe Meena gets caught red handed so we don't have another long drawn out who done it saga.

Why does Noah always snort before he speaks, does he have a sinus problem?

I can't believe that she didn't keep the money and get rid of the rest.
I also can't believe that it wasn't found.
I can't believe that Jacob didn't question the fact that he shop door was locked.
Liam didn't want his 18 year old daughter to go round the world on her own but he was happy to pay for it
Jacob was supposed to sell the ring to pay for some of his debts but he chose to give it away.
Will Meena's frantic behaviour go unnoticed ? Probably.
That MacKenzie continues to irritate.

[tammyy2j]

Leanna runs to the graveyard and to a bridge away from the village instead of running into the village or the opened pub

[Snagglepus]

What a pathetic hour of drivel that was. It was torture watching Meena trying to act.

[Dennis tanner]

Leanna runs to the graveyard and to a bridge away from the village instead of running into the village or the opened pub

How on earth did she intend to survive on her travels ?

She discovered the truth about Meena and instead of walking away saying that she believed her, she poked the tiger and acted all smug.

Meena shouldn't have taken that ring.

Poor Noah.

[Son of Cain]

Leanna runs to the graveyard and to a bridge away from the village instead of running into the village or the opened pub

Same logic as people being chased by police or bad guys, who run up stairs onto a roof without any thought of how they will get down (usually head first). Leanne should have kept her grip on Meena's hair and pulled her over with her, with a bit of luck Leanne would have landed on top of Meena and survived.

[lizann]

leanna should have put up a fight, knocked meena out in the room, leanna was a mean girl bitch what happened her and taking the ring it will be spotted by david or jacob or too dumb so maybe not

[Snagglepus]

leanna should have put up a fight, knocked meena out in the room, leanna was a mean girl bitch what happened her and taking the ring it will be spotted by david or jacob or too dumb so maybe not
She may try to plant the ring on Jacob.
I suppose those at the party will be too dumb to remember Meena was looking for the rucksack and they told her it was at the house.
I hope it doesn't drag out, the stupidity of it all is doing my head in.
I wish Doug would come back.

[Ruffed_lemur]

Same logic as people being chased by police or bad guys, who run up stairs onto a roof without any thought of how they will get down (usually head first). Leanne should have kept her grip on Meena's hair and pulled her over with her, with a bit of luck Leanne would have landed on top of Meena and survived.

I agree, I doubt people think where they're going in these situations.

[Son of Cain]

She may try to plant the ring on Jacob.
I suppose those at the party will be too dumb to remember Meena was looking for the rucksack and they told her it was at the house.
I hope it doesn't drag out, the stupidity of it all is doing my head in.
I wish Doug would come back.

I have a feeling Jacob will end up as chief suspect before this matter is over, you are right she could plant the ring on him. She does not like him and this could be a way of getting even.

Ah, Doug, "Mr Sensible" I had forgotten about him, he is far too bright and practical to want to come back and live with this bunch of thickos

Where did this David and Victoria thing come from, is it because she is the only woman in the village he has not had a relationship with, apart from Dawn, so is she next on the list, at least David would be a better bet than MacKenzie.

[lizann]

She may try to plant the ring on Jacob.
I suppose those at the party will be too dumb to remember Meena was looking for the rucksack and they told her it was at the house.
I hope it doesn't drag out, the stupidity of it all is doing my head in.
I wish Doug would come back.

think she will go on a killing spree, 2 already so expect a long drawn out reveal

[Son of Cain]

think she will go on a killing spree, 2 already so expect a long drawn out reveal

I would be quite happy for her to go on a killing spree as long it includes, Aaron, Liv, Ben, Mandy, Vinny, MacKenzie, Kim, Will, Al, Amy, Nate, Tracey, Ellis and Billy. I am sure there is a few more I want rid of if I give it more thought.

[Son of Cain]

Leanna was beautifully posed in the river bed.

[lizann]

billy or jacob blamed?

[Dennis tanner]

She may try to plant the ring on Jacob. Who knew that he had given it her back ?

I suppose those at the party will be too dumb to remember Meena was looking for the rucksack and they told her it was at the house.
I hope it doesn't drag out, the stupidity of it all is doing my head in. Totally agree

I was dreading the Liam scenes and I was right.

[Son of Cain]

The dialogue in this episode was terrible, no one in real life speaks like this. First the police officer dragging out the conversation, talking about managing the scene and naming Bernice as a passer-by to Jacob's outburst on the bridge wanting Liam to demand answers from the police.How could they do this when they do not know what happened. Even a drama queen like Bernice would not babble on the way she did, first to Liam, then to Gabby and Kim, instead of talking about Leanna being lost and alone and having her face in her head, surely she would just come out and say "Leanna's dead" and I found her. Even Marlon telling them to stop pointing the finger and listen, why did he simply not tell them what had happened. The special effects of blurry images and echoey soundtrack, did nothing to add to the drama, instead it did the opposite introducing an element of unintended comedy. Emmerdale seems to be trying to imitate Eastenders in this respect, and look at the state of mess that's in at present.

[Perdita]

I agree, I doubt people think where they're going in these situations.

I am sure I would run to the nearest place where I find other people like family, neighbours who were only a couple of houses away .. but then we would not have had a murder and now probably months and months of the incredibly useless police in Emmerdale/Hotten coming to the wrong conclusions .... :( :thumbsdown:

[Perdita]

The dialogue in this episode was terrible, no one in real life speaks like this. First the police officer dragging out the conversation, talking about managing the scene and naming Bernice as a passer-by to Jacob's outburst on the bridge wanting Liam to demand answers from the police.How could they do this when they do not know what happened. Even a drama queen like Bernice would not babble on the way she did, first to Liam, then to Gabby and Kim, instead of talking about Leanna being lost and alone and having her face in her head, surely she would just come out and say "Leanna's dead" and I found her. Even Marlon telling them to stop pointing the finger and listen, why did he simply not tell them what had happened. The special effects of blurry images and echoey soundtrack, did nothing to add to the drama, instead it did the opposite introducing an element of unintended comedy. Emmerdale seems to be trying to imitate Eastenders in this respect, and look at the state of mess that's in at present.

I think they were trying to show Bernice in shock and that is how she reacted and it is quite possible that some folk would be like that. As for people never letting others speak but rather jumping to conclusions and slagging people off ... that is very much soapland behaviour

[Son of Cain]

I think they were trying to show Bernice in shock and that is how she reacted and it is quite possible that some folk would be like that. As for people never letting others speak but rather jumping to conclusions and slagging people off ... that is very much soapland behaviour

I agree that they were trying to show Bernice in shock, but personally I feel they failed, especially with the special effects. When you compare this to a six part drama, which rarely ever portrays similar situations like this. Soaps seem to continually fall into the trap of over damatizing and dragging things out. Maybe it's because the actors are not capable of the subtlety required to act in a more realistic way. It seems that when they act the one part for so long they become a caricature. Although I am sure the writing is really mostly to blame.

[Dennis tanner]

I am sure I would run to the nearest place where I find other people like family, neighbours who were only a couple of houses away .. but then we would not have had a murder and now probably months and months of the incredibly useless police in Emmerdale/Hotten coming to the wrong conclusions .... :( :thumbsdown:

PC Swirling is not useless. He's a fine officer

[lizann]

why was liam not asked to identify leanna

gabby should have hugged her upset mother

[Dennis tanner]

Ridiculous scene tonight.

It is not the job of a pathologist to declare an accidental death. That's the job of a coroners court.

Be patient Noah. She's coming round.

[tammyy2j]

I do feel for Liam, the actor is doing a good job

Meena seems to be liking seeing and hearing about Leanna's death, helping Jacob, no guilt or remorse

Gabby should name her son Ashley or Sandy

[Dennis tanner]

Gabby should name her son Ashley or Sandy

Not if she has ambitions to be a DIngle

[Son of Cain]

Not if she has ambitions to be a DIngle

Does Gabby have ambitions to be a Dingle?

[flappinfanny]

I don't know what to make of Emmerdale right now, are we meant to believe in this? I feel Emmerdale/ Emmersty is more like an American soap now.

[Perdita]

Sharon Marshall said on This Morning that Meena will not be found out for a long time and worse is to come....

[Dennis tanner]

Sharon Marshall said on This Morning that Meena will not be found out for a long time and worse is to come....

Awful news

[lizann]

Sharon Marshall said on This Morning that Meena will not be found out for a long time and worse is to come....

dopey david will marry her

[lizann]

was the twins and april close friends with leanna even

[Snagglepus]

No one has noticed the ring missing from Leanna's personal effects yet, that may put doubt on the accident theory.

[Dennis tanner]

dopey david will marry her

A good description of him

[Dennis tanner]

No one has noticed the ring missing from Leanna's personal effects yet, that may put doubt on the accident theory.

What is their accident theory ? She walked on top of the wall and fell off? Scuff marks from high heels ? None.

[Ruffed_lemur]

No one has noticed the ring missing from Leanna's personal effects yet, that may put doubt on the accident theory.

Not sure if anyone knows she was wearing the ring again? Perhaps a few do.

[Dennis tanner]

Not sure if anyone knows she was wearing the ring again? Perhaps a few do.

It is clear that he ring will be important.....eventually (unfortunately)

[lizann]

Not sure if anyone knows she was wearing the ring again? Perhaps a few do.

jacob will know it

[lizann]

more cain and liam even if silent needed

[Dennis tanner]

jacob will know it

He appears to have forgotten that he has to pay for it.

[Dennis tanner]

Liam is predictably irritating. He was right about all those people at the bridge though. Leana didn't have any friends

Jimmy and Mandy.....NO !!!!!!!

[lizann]

Liam is predictably irritating. He was right about all those people at the bridge though. Leana didn't have any friends

Jimmy and Mandy.....NO !!!!!!!

gabby and jacob yes but april the twins amelia and liv no, she was a mean girl

[Son of Cain]

I cannot remember, but did Jimmy know that Mack had locked Nicola in the back of a van? I remember Mack called Jimmy to tell Jimmy something had happened to her, hence why he was racing back before the accident

[Snagglepus]

Jimmy and Mandy.....NO !!!!!!!

It was nice of Mandy to send Jimmy home.

[Son of Cain]

Liam is predictably irritating. He was right about all those people at the bridge though. Leana didn't have any friends

Jimmy and Mandy.....NO !!!!!!!

Since the advent of social media events like this have become a performance. People with little or no connection to what happened seem to feel a need to be involved and to be seen by the world to be involved. Still I suppose card and flower sellers do well out of it.

Jimmy and Mandy? I wonder if the writing team thought, everyone else in the village has been pared up , so why not?

[lizann]

I cannot remember, but did Jimmy know that Mack had locked Nicola in the back of a van? I remember Mack called Jimmy to tell Jimmy something had happened to her, hence why he was racing back before the accident

was jimmy racing back over juliette having the kids as nicola locked away, i did think nicola told him

is aunty cathy the troll online for april

[Dennis tanner]

I cannot remember, but did Jimmy know that Mack had locked Nicola in the back of a van? I remember Mack called Jimmy to tell Jimmy something had happened to her, hence why he was racing back before the accident

But that would mean that the nasty piece of work wouldn't get away with it as usual

[flappinfanny]

This Meena stuff is going to go on for ever. :(

[Dennis tanner]

This Meena stuff is going to go on for ever. :(

Her lie about not hearing any news was totally unneccessary.

Poor Jimmy needs to get a grip.

Liam needs to go back to work. He's letting his wife down, his patients down and Yorkshire down

[lizann]

Her lie about not hearing any news was totally unneccessary.

Poor Jimmy needs to get a grip.

Liam needs to go back to work. He's letting his wife down, his patients down and Yorkshire down

has meena worked once as a nurse, liam is grieving

[Dennis tanner]

has meena worked once as a nurse, She sometimes wears a uniform


liam is grieving I know this. He keeps telling us

[Dennis tanner]

When April first arrived in the village she made a good impression.

She has got a lot older but her acting has not improved at all. She's very wooden. She may need a new head

[Son of Cain]

I used to like Jimmy as a character but he has become just too stupid to be likeable any more. Nicola, altho she was always bossing him about, there was always humour in their relationship, but now it is just too drepessing to be enjoyable anymore. I really don't care if they get back together or not. Please do not put him together Mandy.

[Son of Cain]

Would any sane person take relationship advise from Bob?

Where on earth did he get a Naval Uniform at such short notice, does he have a wardrobe full of dressing up costumes

[Dennis tanner]

Would any sane person take relationship advise from Bob?

Where on earth did he get a Naval Uniform at such short notice, does he have a wardrobe full of dressing up costumes

The country is crying out for Lorry drivers and Daft Jimmy is working in a cafe

[lizann]

The country is crying out for Lorry drivers and Daft Jimmy is working in a cafe

is mac and charity doing all the driving, did jimmy get his licence suspended or banned from the accident or off scot free in court?

[Dennis tanner]

is mac and charity doing all the driving, did jimmy get his licence suspended or banned from the accident or off scot free in court?

He was found not guilty.

Meanwhile Jacon insults a grieving father.

[lizann]

jacob and leanna weren't even a couple when she died, he changed his mind over travelling numerous times

[Dennis tanner]

jacob and leanna weren't even a couple when she died, he changed his mind over travelling numerous times

This is what happens when you have different scriptwriters

[Son of Cain]

It is nearly August which has traditionally been known as the "Silly Season" but some of the current stories are not just silly, they are ridiculous. Oh, how I laughed at MacKenzie's misunderstanding of Brenda and Faith's antics. The village has become even more of a cesspit of gossip than usual with Bear, Bob, Dan Wendy , and Moira poking their noses into other people's business, eager for the next instalment of tittle tattle.

I am willing to bet that Jimmy and Nicola will not get divorced, although personally I am past caring if they do or not.

Did Sarah just walk into Pollard's without knocking?

[lizann]

Wendy very Worried about Jimmy

[Dennis tanner]

Wendy very Worried about Jimmy

Wendy is a secret agent seeking out village secrets

[Son of Cain]

Wendy very Worried about Jimmy

I think Wendy is a nosey busybody.

[Dennis tanner]

I do not believe that Paddy Kirk ( Not the Yorkshire Vet ) cured a dog of cancer once, let alone 3 times

[Dennis tanner]

No Jacob, it's not a good idea for the yoof of the village to sing Bridge over troubled water at the funeral

[Son of Cain]

I am trying to make up my mind if Liam's reaction to Leanne's death is credible or not. As a doctor he must have seen many peoples reaction to a loved ones death, so he must have seen different reactions and have more understanding of this than most. Obviously he is overcome with grief but this constant criticizing and attacking of others is not helping him, especially when he asks them for help and then rejects it, while doing very little himself. Mind you I do admire him for not telling smug vicar Charles to get lost. Where is Harriet, did I imagine we recently saw her returned from her retreat ?

[Perdita]

I am trying to make up my mind if Liam's reaction to Leanne's death is credible or not. As a doctor he must have seen many peoples reaction to a loved ones death, so he must have seen different reactions and have more understanding of this than most. Obviously he is overcome with grief but this constant criticizing and attacking of others is not helping him, especially when he asks them for help and then rejects it, while doing very little himself. Mind you I do admire him for not telling smug vicar Charles to get lost. Where is Harriet, did I imagine we recently saw her returned from her retreat ?

I agree with your thoughts on Liam's grieving .. as a doctor I am sure he would have advised a patient to get grief counselling .. could Manpreet or the vicar not suggest that to him as he seems incapable to think clearly .. I must admit, it is very well acted

[Dennis tanner]

Liam needs to get a grip, visit an undertakers and get back to work

[lizann]

im finding jacob irritating annoying

[Dennis tanner]

im finding jacob irritating annoying

Slightly less annoying that Liv and her drinking

Funerals are for the living and the most important living person in respect of this funeral is Liam.

Jacob needs to shut up and go away.

[Son of Cain]

Slightly less annoying that Liv and her drinking

Funerals are for the living and the most important living person in respect of this funeral is Liam.

Jacob needs to shut up and go away.

Jacob is being very insensitive, as you say funerals are for the living not the dead. He went to Portugal and forgot about her for months, and when he returned he could not even make up his mind if he was Leanna's boyfriend or not. I think he now has a distorted view of the past. I don't think many people still believe that the dead are up there looking down on us, I apologize if this upsets anyone here. Leyla really needs to tell him to let Liam have the funeral he wants. As for Liv's drinking, she is not content in drinking herself into an early grave now she is trying to get Jacob to join her.

[Perdita]

Liam needs to get a grip, visit an undertakers and get back to work

There is no way I would want a consultation about my health issues with Liam in his current state of mental health :nono:

[Dennis tanner]

There is no way I would want a consultation about my health issues with Liam in his current state of mental health :nono:

There are other things he could do to justify his salary.

[Son of Cain]

Is Meena setting her sights at Liam Now?

[LizzyBizzy]

My late mother outlived 2 of her 5 children. I don't remember much about my first brother dying but do about my second brother's death, by which time she was in her 80s. She was very resentful especially with her grandchildren' partners for some reason. She claimed no one was calling her. One day she complained about my children not calling her. My son had told me he'd spoken to her earlier in the day, I told her this. She said yes, but he hasn't called me. After going round in circles there was no point in continuing the conversation. A few days later she called me, my remaining brother and my sister. She was absolutely vitriolic to all of us. I was shell shocked, my sister was in floods tears and my brother thought she was completely dotty. It basically felt like she resented us for still being alive. Fortunately her sister, who'd also outlived 2 of her children spoke some sense to her. She called and apologised to which I said there was no need. I think my point is grief is a very personal thing. There can be a lot of harsh things said, it's not easy, but it's best to try and not dwell on them.

[lizann]

Is Meena setting her sights at Liam Now?

sociopath psychopath she loves being a hero but also seeing pain and hurt she causes

[Dennis tanner]

sociopath psychopath she loves being a hero but also seeing pain and hurt she causes

We really need to see the back of her. It's now too much.

Jacob was a disgrace and Leyla let Liam down.

[Dennis tanner]

Leyla needs to have a chat with Cain.

Cain will tell Liam what to do.

[Perdita]

Diane throwing out black bin liners .. Jamie comes along and asks "What are you doing with my stuff???" ... how did he know Diane was chucking out his property? :hmm:

[lizann]

Diane throwing out black bin liners .. Jamie comes along and asks "What are you doing with my stuff???" ... how did he know Diane was chucking out his property? :hmm:

probably the only guest there

[Dennis tanner]

probably the only guest there

For the umpteenth time Jamie tells Gabby that he wants nothing to do with her. She still lets him leave with Kim's money.

Who is Kim going to blame. Gabby or Will ?

[flappinfanny]

Is this the last we see of snivelling little rich boy Jamie, i do hope so.

[Perdita]

Is this the last we see of snivelling little rich boy Jamie, i do hope so.

He needs to upset Meena first by looking in her first aid box ;)

[Perdita]

probably the only guest there

Even if that was so, she could have thrown her own stuff out.....

[Son of Cain]

Even if that was so, she could have thrown her own stuff out.....

Diane could have been putting out the rubbish for the bin men, - Oh wait, perhaps that what she was doing.

I look forward to the day suitcases and holdalls are invented, then when characters move home they pack properly and leave with some dignity instead of using the obligatory bin bags.

[Perdita]

Diane could have been putting out the rubbish for the bin men, - Oh wait, perhaps that what she was doing.

I look forward to the day suitcases and holdalls are invented, then when characters move home they pack properly and leave with some dignity instead of using the obligatory bin bags.

And put more than a couple of boxer shorts into each one. Even when they use suitcases you can tell by the way they are being held that they are very light and empty :lol:

[Son of Cain]

And put more than a couple of boxer shorts into each one. Even when they use suitcases you can tell by the way they are being held that they are very light and empty :lol:

You would not say that if you saw me struggling through an airport, I am a true everything including the kitchen sink traveller.

[Dennis tanner]

Cain was just looking for an excuse to dump on Faith

He is part of the reason for Sarah's anxiety

[Dennis tanner]

Does Gabby really think that Jamie will give her half of what he is worth ?

She is deluded.

[lizann]

where is charity

[Dennis tanner]

where is charity

She here !!!

Emmerdale can no longer afford any extras.

[Son of Cain]

When I tuned in on Friday, I thought I had selected the wrong channel, I thought this must be WWF wrestling. A twist on mud wrestling, instead of mud it was birthday cake on a bouncy castle. - Was this comedy?
Jimmy doing his impression of an Ostrich again. - They really have turned him into an idiot.

[flappinfanny]

When I tuned in on Friday, I thought I had selected the wrong channel, I thought this must be WWF wrestling.You wish. :D Loved the food fight with Nicola and Mandy. well played.

[Perdita]

You wish. :D Loved the food fight with Nicola and Mandy. well played.
The food fight was funny ... the rest OTT and pathetic

[Dennis tanner]

The food fight was funny ... the rest OTT and pathetic

I have to say that I hate Food fights

[Dennis tanner]

Charity has never bene thick. She know he's a persistent thief. Is she playing a game?

Can Jimmy and Nico trust Lovejoy's daughter ?

[lizann]

has belle moved out of dingle manor

[Perdita]

Charity has never bene thick. She know he's a persistent thief. Is she playing a game?

They are going to declare their love for each other .. apparently... :sick:

[Snagglepus]

has belle moved out of dingle manor
I wondered that myself, where would she be living?

[Dennis tanner]

I wondered that myself, where would she be living?

She probably has a house in the Kings development

[Son of Cain]

We're we meant to be surprised when it turned out that it was Jacob that Liv had invited round.

[Dennis tanner]

We're we meant to be surprised when it turned out that it was Jacob that Liv had invited round.

She should have asked Noah

[lizann]

She should have asked Noah

he could be next

[lizann]

liv homeless despite owning a house with aaron and empty apartment next door

[Dennis tanner]

liv homeless despite owning a house with aaron and empty apartment next door

I got the impression that Liv purchased the house by herself because Livesy refused to have any of his father's money

[Son of Cain]

I know Emmerdale is a small quiet village, but do they never lock the cricket pavilion? - Half the village seems to have spent the night there at sometime.

I am beginning to wonder if it is Cathy or maybe Cathy and Heath who are trolling April?

[Son of Cain]

I got the impression that Liv purchased the house by herself because Livesy refused to have any of his father's money

I thought she said recently that it WAS HER HOUSE.

[Dennis tanner]

I know Emmerdale is a small quiet village, but do they never lock the cricket pavilion? - Half the village seems to have spent the night there at sometime.

I am beginning to wonder if it is Cathy or maybe Cathy and Heath who are trolling April?

Why is called a cricket pavillion when there is no cricket team and no cricket ground.

[Son of Cain]

Why is called a cricket pavillion when there is no cricket team and no cricket ground.

I think they do occasionally still play cricket once every few years. More frequently in the days when Tubby Turner was about.

[Dennis tanner]

I think they do occasionally still play cricket once every few years. More frequently in the days when Tubby Turner was about.

The problem is that the grass is too long, the slope is too steep and there is no cricket square. The pavillion does not appear to have dressing rooms or showers etc.

[Ruffed_lemur]

I thought she said recently that it WAS HER HOUSE.

I thought it was hers too.

[Dennis tanner]

April, Liv and Vinny......Tedius and boring.

[Snagglepus]

Who does Chas sell 300 pounds worth of food to, the Wooly is always empty.

edit - why does the pound symbol appear as ?

[Perdita]

Who does Chas sell 300 pounds worth of food to, the Wooly is always empty.

edit - why does the pound symbol appear as ?

Technical bug since last server upgrade

[lizann]

with vic and wendy's son not working for marlon in the pub kitchen how is he coping, busy with takeaway, is vic cooking from home or working in hop

[Dennis tanner]

with vic and wendy's son not working for marlon in the pub kitchen how is he coping, busy with takeaway, is vic cooking from home or working in hop

But there are no customers???

[lizann]

so it was is cathy but why donna and april are family

[Dennis tanner]

Some very silly Marlon scenes.

[Son of Cain]

Some very silly Marlon scenes.

Marlon has been a cartoon character for a while now. I think this is a danger for actors playing a soap character. Because they only play the one role for years and years, over time the character and mannerisms become slightly exaggerated a little bit at a time, perhaps even unnoticed, until they end up like Marlon as a caricature. I am sure if we look back, Marlon used to be much more "normal".

[Son of Cain]

Liv seems to have been able to give up booze very easily, no craving for a drink, no sweating, no headaches or nausea, no DTs. A couple of days ago she drank a bottle and a half of vodka and passed out, and regularly seemed to drink a bottle or more a day. Yet here she is looking reasonably bright eyed and bushy tailed. It is no wonder she was not worried about her drinking if she knew she could give it up so easily. I never found her drinking to be very realistic, the amount she was putting away, she should be dead by now.

So now we know that Cathy has been trolling April, and maybe Heath was too. If a story is meant to be a mystery, they really should make it less obvious, it has been obvious for a while now that it was Cathy.

[Perdita]

Marlon has been a cartoon character for a while now. I think this is a danger for actors playing a soap character. Because they only play the one role for years and years, over time the character and mannerisms become slightly exaggerated a little bit at a time, perhaps even unnoticed, until they end up like Marlon as a caricature. I am sure if we look back, Marlon used to be much more "normal".

He was quite a horrible character when the Dingles first were introduced but then changed his ways .. I agree, he is OTT lately, hope he stops that again sooner rather than later

[Son of Cain]

He was quite a horrible character when the Dingles first were introduced but then changed his ways .. I agree, he is OTT lately, hope he stops that again sooner rather than later

Being a horrible character is "normal", we need some "baddies" to boo. As you say he is OTT lately, with the constant gurning and exaggerated hand and body movements, that's what annoys me now. Bob is also a bit OTT but I think he was always a bit like that. One OTT character in the show is enough.

[lizann]

how is marlon now broke and bob isn't anymore, has money

[Dennis tanner]

how is marlon now broke and bob isn't anymore, has money

Marlon is broke because he bought half the pub while still paying the mortgage on the house where none of his tenants bother to pay him.

[Dennis tanner]

Meena is suddenly desperate to look after the child and then the child goes missing.

Nobody puts 2 and 3 together

[Perdita]

Why do they never seem to lock doors in Emmerdale? Meena especially can quietly let herself in anywhere she wants to either steal things to frame others with or kidnap a child...

[Dennis tanner]

Why do they never seem to lock doors in Emmerdale? Meena especially can quietly let herself in anywhere she wants to either steal things to frame others with or kidnap a child...

It's a crime free zone .....apparently

[flappinfanny]

A true Bromance between Ryan and Mackenzie. Surely if Marlon has money issues so does Saint Chas?

[Dennis tanner]

A true Bromance between Ryan and Mackenzie. Surely if Marlon has money issues so does Saint Chas?

But Chas is married to Yorkshire's favouite Vet

[Son of Cain]

Is Eddie trying to contact Ethan to tell him he has a STI?

[Perdita]

Is Eddie trying to contact Ethan to tell him he has a STI?

Dawn had that not so long ago .... but probably worth highlighting the dangers of unprotected sex which is what is the norm in soapland. Where is Dawn btw?

[Son of Cain]

Dawn had that not so long ago .... but probably worth highlighting the dangers of unprotected sex which is what is the norm in soapland. Where is Dawn btw?

And Harriet, not seen her for a while. Charles did Leanne's funeral, altho Harriet had known her longer. She went on a retreat, but I thought we had seen her back from that.

[Dennis tanner]

Liv is still a boring useless scrote and Vinny is nearly as bad.

[lizann]

did aaron or liv not think about the two strangers she drank with, liv did more damage to noah

[Dennis tanner]

did aaron or liv not think about the two strangers she drank with, liv did more damage to noah

Livesy and his sister are rather thick and he is still a thug. Poor Noah.

[Perdita]

Would a grandmother really not tell the mother of her grandson that the newly arrived grandad is a bad one and wants to con her out of the inheritance? I appreciate Wendy is embarassed, ashamed and maybe even scared but why on earth is she not telling anyone what Russ is all about? The whole village will rally round and support her ... of course, there would not be any drama though .. yawnnnn...I appreciate there has to be drama but please, soapland producers/writers ... do not always make it so very unbelievable....

[Dennis tanner]

Would a grandmother really not tell the mother of her grandson that the newly arrived grandad is a bad one and wants to con her out of the inheritance? I appreciate Wendy is embarassed, ashamed and maybe even scared but why on earth is she not telling anyone what Russ is all about? The whole village will rally round and support her ... of course, there would not be any drama though .. yawnnnn...I appreciate there has to be drama but please, soapland producers/writers ... do not always make it so very unbelievable....

Livesy could have avoided all his drama by simply checking his security cameras.

[Son of Cain]

Would a grandmother really not tell the mother of her grandson that the newly arrived grandad is a bad one and wants to con her out of the inheritance? I appreciate Wendy is embarassed, ashamed and maybe even scared but why on earth is she not telling anyone what Russ is all about? The whole village will rally round and support her ... of course, there would not be any drama though .. yawnnnn...I appreciate there has to be drama but please, soapland producers/writers ... do not always make it so very unbelievable....
I got the impression that Russ has a criminal past, which Wendy benefited from. Now she is afraid that he will tell people about this past if she does not do as he says. But I would have thought she would tell Bob and Victoria in confidence what Russ is up to. As you say drama for dramas sake even if it is unbelievable.

[lizann]

meena break in, terrorising vic will probably be blamed on russ

[Perdita]

I got the impression that Russ has a criminal past, which Wendy benefited from. Now she is afraid that he will tell people about this past if she does not do as he says. But I would have thought she would tell Bob and Victoria in confidence what Russ is up to. As you say drama for dramas sake even if it is unbelievable.

Definitely think he was in prison when he was "working away from home" ... but her knowing it and keeping quiet should not really give him such a hold over her as he seems to have plus the implication about her qualifications... I guess the outcome of this will be another part of the Christmas storyline YAWN

[Son of Cain]

Definitely think he was in prison when he was "working away from home" ... but her knowing it and keeping quiet should not really give him such a hold over her as he seems to have plus the implication about her qualifications... I guess the outcome of this will be another part of the Christmas storyline YAWN

He said that she had enjoyed the "fruits of his labours" clothes, cars and nice holidays. Perhaps she covered for him or helped him in his dodgy dealings. I do not know why she is worried about villagers finding out, so many of them have a chequered past. Better if she just told people herself then he would have no hold over her, I cannot imagine she done anything so terrible. I am sure it will be a great disappointment when he, as he surely will, reveals all.

[Perdita]

He said that she had enjoyed the "fruits of his labours" clothes, cars and nice holidays. Perhaps she covered for him or helped him in his dodgy dealings. I do not know why she is worried about villagers finding out, so many of them have a chequered past. Better if she just told people herself then he would have no hold over her, I cannot imagine she done anything so terrible. I am sure it will be a great disappointment when he, as he surely will, reveals all.

I agree, the big reveal will be disappointing, I am sure

[Dennis tanner]

Faith parked Pollard's car at an angle in a narrow country road and went and sat in a field.

The Country is amazed how easily Emmerdale residents can get access to doctors and medical health services.

Charity should stop telling Poor Noah that he is weird when most of the village is weird.

[Snagglepus]

From the road to the tree looked a long distance to hold a conversation without yelling.

[Perdita]

From the road to the tree looked a long distance to hold a conversation without yelling.

Maybe she is the Six Million Dollar Woman with a bionic ear ??

[lizann]

did i miss an episode as moira had frankie now in unit with tracy

[lizann]

david is a wet blanket dope

[Dennis tanner]

did i miss an episode as moira had frankie now in unit with tracy

You tell them that you had thoughts about killing yourself and your baby so they put you in the same room

[Dennis tanner]

david is a wet blanket dope

He's really thick. He never has a clue about what's going on.

Having said that, why does Meena really need to go with her sister ???

I had high hopes for Ryan but he's now annoying me

[Son of Cain]

david is a wet blanket dope

Personally I think it is a toss up between David and Nate as to who is the thickest.

[Dennis tanner]

Personally I think it is a toss up between David and Nate as to who is the thickest.

Both came into the show pretending to be something else. Both quickly forgiven when found out. I can understand Eric but not Cain.

[lizann]

Both came into the show pretending to be something else. Both quickly forgiven when found out. I can understand Eric but not Cain.

he forgave moira he can forgive his son

[Dennis tanner]

he forgave moira he can forgive his son

Moira didn't know that he was Cain's son.

Tracey must die or be cured asap.

[Son of Cain]

Both came into the show pretending to be something else. Both quickly forgiven when found out. I can understand Eric but not Cain.

Exactly! - I have never found it possible to believe that Cain would ever have forgiven Nate.

[Son of Cain]

Another mad person with a shotgun in The Village of the Damned. - How many is that now?

[Dennis tanner]

Another mad person with a shotgun in The Village of the Damned. - How many is that now?

Will Wendy be exposed ?

[Son of Cain]

Will Wendy be exposed ?

So Wendy did not qualify as a nurse, did she study and not qualify, did she fail, she seems quite knowledgeable, did she just gain this knowledge from reading Nursing Times. I thought there was a list of all qualified nurses, did Liam not check when Wendy was hired. Let's hope all will be revealed.

[Dennis tanner]

Russ to die in a storm of bullets and Wendy's secret to be safe please.

[Perdita]

Russ to die in a storm of bullets and Wendy's secret to be safe please.

No secret in soapland can ever be safe...

[Dennis tanner]

No secret in soapland can ever be safe...

Safe for the moment then

[Son of Cain]

Russ to die in a storm of bullets and Wendy's secret to be safe please.
Victoria will still know her secret, unless Russ has just shot and killed her.

[Perdita]

Victoria will still know her secret, unless Russ has just shot and killed her.

I wonder if Wendy manages to get the gun off Russ and shoots him?

[lizann]

a shotgun would leave a huge hole in david's stomach but he'll survive

[Dennis tanner]

a shotgun would leave a huge hole in david's stomach but he'll survive

He could be shot though the head and it would miss his brain.

[Dennis tanner]

The Police were way OTT as usual

[Son of Cain]

a shotgun would leave a huge hole in david's stomach but he'll survive

At that close range it would have went straight though him and come out his back, removing most of his insides. - But I must say that was the most realistic siege scene ever seen in a Soap. - I don't think. -Jacob, Bob and Dan just outside The Hide arguing with the police. First thing a Armed Resonse Team would do, is move everyone well back out of sight of stray shots. Russ only had a single barrelled shotgun, was he a cut price armed robber who could not afford a second barrel? Once he fired it, it's only use was as a club. We did not see him reload so Wendy or Victoria could have opened the door and escaped allowing the police to rush in. At least Meena will be in her element now as the distraught girlfriend whose boyfriend's life hangs in the balance.

[Dennis tanner]

At that close range it would have went straight though him and come out his back, removing most of his insides. - But I must say that was the most realistic siege scene ever seen in a Soap. - I don't think. -Jacob, Bob and Dan just outside The Hide arguing with the police. First thing a Armed Resonse Team would do, is move everyone well back out of sight of stray shots. Russ only had a single barrelled shotgun, was he a cut price armed robber who could not afford a second barrel? Once he fired it, it's only use was as a club. We did not see him reload so Wendy or Victoria could have opened the door and escaped allowing the police to rush in. At least Meena will be in her element now as the distraught girlfriend whose boyfriend's life hangs in the balance.

Meena will be wanting a suitable souvenir. I am sure I sure I heard Jacob shouting, " You've got to get him out. He was the fiancee of my girlfriend"

[Son of Cain]

Not much sympathy from Jake, David comes round to a lecture about morality and commitment.

[Son of Cain]

Wendy is I would think in her middle to late forties or early fifties, yet she says she was at University presumably studying to be a nurse. Nursing became a degree course in 2009, so unless she went to Uni as a mature student something does not add up.

[Snagglepus]

When David was coming round Jacob went looking for a nurse, next minute he's sitting there telling David a nurse is coming... so who removed all his tubes?

[Dennis tanner]

Wendy is I would think in her middle to late forties or early fifties, yet she says she was at University presumably studying to be a nurse. Nursing became a degree course in 2009, so unless she went to Uni as a mature student something does not add up.

She went to University before the boys were born. I agree that it does add up.

Victoria was vile to Wendy. The fact is that if she hadn't made a move on Russ, David would not have been shot.

[Son of Cain]

Did I imagine that Marlon had to borrow Bob's credit card recently to pay for something, or was that someone else? If he did where did he find the money to pay for half the Bar-B-Que grill? He said he did not know how expensive it was to own half a pub and here he is subsidizing Chastity's half.

[Son of Cain]

Don't know why Kim, Al and Jai are worried about The HOP losing trade after the siege, normally this type of incident attracts all sorts of ghouls and sightseers, if anything passing trade should be up.

[lizann]

david staying with meena for jacob, they don't like each other

[Perdita]

david staying with meena for jacob, they don't like each other

Absoultely ridiculous. Jacob is 18 and off to university soon .. and he is not keen on Meena .. I used to like David but ever since he split from Tracy I am going off him more and more. I predict that the big Christmas storyline this year is Meena being found out about, hope I can stay watching for another 3 months but sure will not miss anything riveting if I cannot.

[lizann]

Absoultely ridiculous. Jacob is 18 and off to university soon .. and he is not keen on Meena .. I used to like David but ever since he split from Tracy I am going off him more and more. I predict that the big Christmas storyline this year is Meena being found out about, hope I can stay watching for another 3 months but sure will not miss anything riveting if I cannot.

yes what leyla said make no sense, nothing interesting with any of the storylines

[Son of Cain]

I know the NHS are short of beds but it is ridiculous to say David will be home tomorrow. He still looks like he is at death's door. He was shot in the abdomen with a shotgun, I doubt he would be able to eat or drink. I really hate that Soaps and TV Dramas do not understand the difference between shotguns and rifles. They keep saying David took a bullet, shotguns do not fire bullets, they fire lead shot or steel balls which speads as it leaves the barrell and creates a large wound. It is possible to fire a solid round from a shotgun, this is the sort of thing Navy Seals use to blast a large hole in a door to execute a forced entrance, David would certainly not have survived such a round.

[Dennis tanner]

Considering the way that Jacob betrayed David, his attitude sickens me.

Daft David thinks that Meena is a good person.

[Perdita]

Daft David thinks that Meena is a good person.
So far the rest of the village think she is .... hopefully not for too much longer now.. still think Christmas storyline will be titled: Meena, The Killer Is Found Out.... :D

[lizann]

I know the NHS are short of beds but it is ridiculous to say David will be home tomorrow. He still looks like he is at death's door. He was shot in the abdomen with a shotgun, I doubt he would be able to eat or drink. I really hate that Soaps and TV Dramas do not understand the difference between shotguns and rifles. They keep saying David took a bullet, shotguns do not fire bullets, they fire lead shot or steel balls which speads as it leaves the barrell and creates a latge wound. It is possible to fire a solid round from a shotgun, this is the sort of thing Navy Seals use to blast a large hole in a door to execute a forced entrance, David would certainly not have survived such a round.

he care barely speak without oxygen but let him home

[Perdita]

I know the NHS are short of beds but it is ridiculous to say David will be home tomorrow. He still looks like he is at death's door. He was shot in the abdomen with a shotgun, I doubt he would be able to eat or drink. I really hate that Soaps and TV Dramas do not understand the difference between shotguns and rifles. They keep saying David took a bullet, shotguns do not fire bullets, they fire lead shot or steel balls which speads as it leaves the barrell and creates a large wound. It is possible to fire a solid round from a shotgun, this is the sort of thing Navy Seals use to blast a large hole in a door to execute a forced entrance, David would certainly not have survived such a round.

He will be back working in the shop by Friday...

[Snagglepus]

Dianne has David sized up... a lummox.

[lizann]

maybe meena will do a misery with david, like emma and james

[Snagglepus]

It looked to me like Rhona was defending herself, Brenda was giving her a bear hug, an elbow to the face was a way of getting her to release her.
When it is explained to the police that Brenda jumped on her first the police will drop the charges.
Not in court till next week, the Emmerdale judicial system is not as fast as Weatherfield's

[Dennis tanner]

It looked to me like Rhona was defending herself, Brenda was giving her a bear hug, an elbow to the face was a way of getting her to release her.
When it is explained to the police that Brenda jumped on her first the police will drop the charges.
Not in court till next week, the Emmerdale judicial system is not as fast as Weatherfield's

I didn't know that the Police concerned themselves with common assault.

So why didn't The Yorkshire Vet fork out for a bit of compo for daft Matty.

[lizann]

matty is as much at fault as marlon, moira too pushy

[Son of Cain]

matty is as much at fault as marlon, moira too pushy

Matty still seems remarkably chipper for someone who has suffered partial thickness burns to his hands. He seems to have no pain even though his hands are bandaged up like a boxers. Who on earth would pour lighter fuel on a fire that was already burning, you only do that to get the fire started, apart from anything else it taints the food. The way it was filmed it was a monentary flare up, his hands were not in prolonged contact with the flames. In real life I doubt he would have suffered no more than singed eyebrows. While over in Walford Phil survives a house fire without so much as a blister and his face did not even seem any more red than usual
I wonder if Moira has been as thorough in her own attention to Health and Safety on the farm, which is a much more dangerous place than a bar-g-que.
Chastity is suppose to be experienced in running a pub and yet she waits until the booze stock has almost runs out before getting more in. Then Charity just happens to have a supply of knock-off booze to help out.
If Marlon has any sense he will sell his share of the pub to Al as soon as possible, before it turns him completely insane.

[Son of Cain]

He will be back working in the shop by Friday...

Still since he only ever seems to have about half a dozen customers that should not tax him too much.

[Son of Cain]

It looked to me like Rhona was defending herself, Brenda was giving her a bear hug, an elbow to the face was a way of getting her to release her.
When it is explained to the police that Brenda jumped on her first the police will drop the charges.
Not in court till next week, the Emmerdale judicial system is not as fast as Weatherfield's

I suppose Brenda could counter by saying that Rhona had grabbed Cathy, so she was coming to Kathy's defense, and that Rhona was the aggressor. Mind you I don't have any any sympathy for Brenda, she is an interfering busybody and a gossip.
I wonder if this is going to lead to a break-up between Marlon and Rhona, just to heap more misery on idiotic chef. If he has to move back to his own house with April where will his tennants go. Good example of the "Butterfly's Wings in the Chaos Theory.

[Perdita]

Rhona never pushed Brenda .. she turned round with her arm up because Brenda was holding her from behind .. or did I see something wrong??

[lizann]

Rhona never pushed Brenda .. she turned round with her arm up because Brenda was holding her from behind .. or did I see something wrong??

brenda fell rhona did nought wrong

[Son of Cain]

Rhona never pushed Brenda .. she turned round with her arm up because Brenda was holding her from behind .. or did I see something wrong??

You saw nothing wrong, it was just a bit of a tussle which would have best been forgotten. An elbow strike to the head or ribs, is one of the defences taught to being grabbed from behind. Rhona grabbed hold of Cathy which in law can be seen as an assault. Brenda overreacted by rushing in and grabbing Rhona. Rhona struck Brenda on the side of the head while turning causing Brenda to fall. It was a cross between a strike, a push and a throw. Rhona did not hit Brenda hard or fast enough for this to be called a strike, so technically it was a push with her elbow and upper arm helped by the turning motion of her body that caused Brenda to fall. Ideally the incident should have been forgotten, in a small village like Emmerdale the police should have had words with both of them and told them to shake hands and behave themselves. But Brenda being Brenda had to call the police. - All in the name of drama.

[tammyy2j]

Can Cathy get charged, was a new law introduced about on line bullying? Bob said Cathy was cautioned

[Dennis tanner]

Can Cathy get charged, was a new law introduced about on line bullying? Bob said Cathy was cautioned

Anyone can get charged if they are old enough. The Police can caution anyone if they think it's appropriate.

[flappinfanny]

I wish Rhona had knocked Brenda out. Emmerdale has been quite decent this week, even Bob and Marlon were bearable. I did laugh at Cain in the Woolie not letting Al get by.

[Perdita]

Why is Al so keen on buying into the pub that is not doing any business ???

[lizann]

Why is Al so keen on buying into the pub that is not doing any business ???

his 1% in hop not allowing him expand his ideas

[Dennis tanner]

The Corrupt Yorkshire Vet was very rude to Mike Swirling.

Why would Chas believe that any honest person with money would want to employ her daft husband ?

I don't understand why Cain assaulted Charity. All he needed to do was explain what he was doing

[lizann]

The Corrupt Yorkshire Vet was very rude to Mike Swirling.
Why would Chas believe that any honest person with money would want to employ her daft husband ?
I don't understand why Cain assaulted Charity. All he needed to do was explain what he was doing

he pushed her

mack in love

[Son of Cain]

I am hoping that the drugs Paddy is giving Medicinal Brandy will cause him to become super aggressive, go on a rampage and kick Jamie in the head causing instant death and we can be shot of him for ever.

[lizann]

jamie makes a splash

charity out of hospital back riding already after a day

[Son of Cain]

Could be I do not need Paddy and Medicinal Brandy after all.

[Dennis tanner]

Why would you be daft enough to cobfess and then argue about your corruption in the middle of the village. Ridiculous.

Tis a pity that Gobby will probably never know that her phone call caused her beloved to die.

[lizann]

al on to paddy and jamie missing

[Dennis tanner]

al on to paddy and jamie missing

It is unbelievable that Jamie could have escaped from that car.

[lizann]

It is unbelievable that Jamie could have escaped from that car.

ross and tom joe came back from the dead so anything is possible

[Dennis tanner]

ross and tom joe came back from the dead so anything is possible

You would need to open a window to let water in so you could open the door. The windows appeared to be shut.

I have read the spoilers

[flappinfanny]

You would need to open a window to let water in so you could open the door. The windows appeared to be shut.

I have read the spoilers

Is Jamie dead, he looked as though he was not in that car? Typical Emmerdale

[Ruffed_lemur]

You would need to open a window to let water in so you could open the door. The windows appeared to be shut.

I have read the spoilers

I'm pretty sure the driver's side window was open. I think he's out there somewhere.

[Snagglepus]

You would need to open a window to let water in so you could open the door. The windows appeared to be shut.

It sank quick enough though.

[Perdita]

I'm pretty sure the driver's side window was open. I think he's out there somewhere.

I think so too ....

[Son of Cain]

I'm pretty sure the driver's side window was open. I think he's out there somewhere.

What a surprize! that Jamie was not in the car. The real surprize would have been, if he was in the car. Now they can tease us for weeks, is he dead, did he escape? - such imagination.
I also noticed the window was open, as we saw the water pouring out of it when the car was brought up. Since most cars have electric windows nowadays, would they still work underwater?

[lizann]

where is laurel and bernice?

[Dennis tanner]

Poor Noah. His mom has let him down again.

[lizann]

Poor Noah. His mom has let him down again.

to be fair to charity noah said he had a girlfriend chloe who is more into sarah and mack hiding in the bush waiting for a ride

[flappinfanny]

Does Kim Alexis Carrington Colby Tate know her brat of a son is still alive, is she in on it? is there is going to be a twist?

[Dennis tanner]

Does Kim Alexis Carrington Colby Tate know her brat of a son is still alive, is she in on it? is there is going to be a twist?

I don't see how she can be in on it unless he has contacted her. In any case, what crime has he committed ?

[Son of Cain]

Priya is becoming a bit of a know-it-all, interfering busybody. She should just keep out of Leyla and Liam's business.

[lizann]

Priya is becoming a bit of a know-it-all, interfering busybody. She should just keep out of Leyla and Liam's business.

leyla drags her in

[Dennis tanner]

I don't see how she can be in on it unless he has contacted her. In any case, what crime has he committed ?

Looks like he has emptied Kirk's pathetic Vet's bank account. Who knew that The Yorkshire Vet had staff ? The only Vetting he does is illegal.

[LizzyBizzy]

With Manpreet out of the country, why is Liam pretending to be working at a hospital? Surely he'd be covering for her?

[Son of Cain]

With Manpreet out of the country, why is Liam pretending to be working at a hospital? Surely he'd be covering for her?

He said he was getting a locum. If he does not get back to work soon, he will be running out of money.

[LizzyBizzy]

Thanks for that, obviously missed it.

[Dennis tanner]

Mark my words, that Meena is a wrong un.

Mark my words, that 'Vet' is a total idiot.