PDA

View Full Version : Emmerdale - Current Episode Discussion - III



Pages : 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 [42] 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57

Perdita
04-03-2023, 17:46
I sincerely hope that anyone who has watched this and can relate to Paddy .. please please go and talk to either your partner, family member, friend, Samaritans, or any other helpline ... I will be willing to message with anyone on here in total confidence if you want to do that....You are not alone

lizann
05-03-2023, 00:20
Some fine acting again from Dominic Brunt and Mark Charnock, the only downside is the hour episodes, much prefer the 22 minute each night. Pesky football.

marlon broke me

Dennis tanner
05-03-2023, 02:16
If Kirk's father is Bear, shouldn't he call himself Paddy Bear. I rarely watch the episodes live these days so I will be fastforwarding through his scenes.

lizann
05-03-2023, 02:50
If Kirk's father is Bear, shouldn't he call himself Paddy Bear. I rarely watch the episodes live these days so I will be fastforwarding through his scenes.

bear is nickname from wrestling

Dennis tanner
05-03-2023, 17:53
bear is nickname from wrestling

I agree and Paddy is also a nickname. His mother called him Patrick.

lizann
06-03-2023, 22:32
has rishi a lodger in secret

Son of Cain
07-03-2023, 07:43
has rishi a lodger in secret

Someone living in his loft? - Altho they have done this before with Lachlan.

lizann
07-03-2023, 11:30
Someone living in his loft? - Altho they have done this before with Lachlan.

is it alex or escaped meena

johntrevor
07-03-2023, 12:53
has rishi a lodger in secret

Emmerdale has confirmed that a mystery intruder is surveying the home of Rishi Sharma.

Snagglepus
07-03-2023, 16:00
Emmerdale has confirmed that a mystery intruder is surveying the home of Rishi Sharma.
The thing is Rishi knows they are there yet did nothing. Not even call the plod. Is Rishi saying nothing for fear no one will believe him. How long are they going to keep this going.

Dennis tanner
07-03-2023, 16:29
The thing is Rishi knows they are there yet did nothing. Not even call the plod. Is Rishi saying nothing for fear no one will believe him. How long are they going to keep this going.
Whether he believed him or not, Mike Swirling would seasrch the house.

Son of Cain
08-03-2023, 07:46
Did Amy suddenly remember her part in Frank's death, when Kyle said "everyone does something bad sometime, even you"? Is this why she took him back to Moira and Cain?

Perdita
08-03-2023, 10:04
Did Amy suddenly remember her part in Frank's death, when Kyle said "everyone does something bad sometime, even you"? Is this why she took him back to Moira and Cain?

I doubt it, they never even mention his name these days. I hope Matty does not marry her as she only proposed to make it look better for her to get custody.

Son of Cain
08-03-2023, 11:25
I doubt it, they never even mention his name these days. I hope Matty does not marry her as she only proposed to make it look better for her to get custody.

The reason I asked was that she seemed to look thoughtful as if she was remembering something, as Kyle left The room. Maybe I was reading too much into the scene, as I am not sure she is that good an actor.

I really wish that somehow the truth would come out about her and Kerry, as they both have vindictive " holier than thou" attitudes.

Son of Cain
08-03-2023, 11:33
The thing is Rishi knows they are there yet did nothing. Not even call the plod. Is Rishi saying nothing for fear no one will believe him. How long are they going to keep this going.

Rushi is another one they have turned into a bit of a bumbling idiot. I am sure he was a much more serious character when he first appeared.

Perdita
08-03-2023, 11:50
The reason I asked was that she seemed to look thoughtful as if she was remembering something, as Kyle left The room. Maybe I was reading too much into the scene, as I am not sure she is that good an actor.

I really wish that somehow the truth would come out about her and Kerry, as they both have a vindictive " holier than thou" attitudes.

I doubt that the subject will ever be raised again. They literally got away with involuntary manslaughter.

johntrevor
08-03-2023, 11:54
Did Amy suddenly remember her part in Frank's death, when Kyle said "everyone does something bad sometime, even you"? Is this why she took him back to Moira and Cain?

Hadn't thought of that....Good point

Perdita
08-03-2023, 11:56
Rushi is another one they have turned into a bit of a bumbling idiot. I am sure he was a much more serious character when he first appeared.

I guess that they do not know what to do with the character

Perdita
08-03-2023, 12:02
Did Amy suddenly remember her part in Frank's death, when Kyle said "everyone does something bad sometime, even you"? Is this why she took him back to Moira and Cain?

Would Kyle know? Does anyone apart from Amy and Kerry know? I cannot remember :hmm:

lizann
08-03-2023, 12:38
The reason I asked was that she seemed to look thoughtful as if she was remembering something, as Kyle left The room. Maybe I was reading too much into the scene, as I am not sure she is that good an actor.

I really wish that somehow the truth would come out about her and Kerry, as they both have vindictive " holier than thou" attitudes.

considering vanessa did nothing and while tracy "pushed" kerry that is it

Son of Cain
08-03-2023, 13:10
[QUOTE=Perdita;991688]Would Kyle know? Does anyone apart from Amy and Kerry know? I cannot remember :hmm:[/Q
No , Kyle would not know, but when he said "everyone does something bad, sometimes, even you, I bet" I thought the scene was shot as if it triggered her memory. Vanessa and Tracey know, but they are conveniently not here, and for some reason did not tell anyone.

Dennis tanner
08-03-2023, 13:26
Did Amy suddenly remember her part in Frank's death, when Kyle said "everyone does something bad sometime, even you"? Is this why she took him back to Moira and Cain?

I guess that she realised that he would continually plead with her to go back to Cain.

Dennis tanner
08-03-2023, 13:28
Rushi is another one they have turned into a bit of a bumbling idiot. I am sure he was a much more serious character when he first appeared.

Yoda is very trouble at the moment. St Arthur knows he is troubled but doesn't intend to help him.

Perdita
08-03-2023, 15:18
I guess that she realised that he would continually plead with her to go back to Cain.

I think so too

Perdita
08-03-2023, 15:19
[QUOTE=Perdita;991688]Would Kyle know? Does anyone apart from Amy and Kerry know? I cannot remember :hmm:[/Q
No , Kyle would not know, but when he said "everyone does something bad, sometimes, even you, I bet" I thought the scene was shot as if it triggered her memory. Vanessa and Tracey know, but they are conveniently not here, and for some reason did not tell anyone.

Did Tracey find out? Do not remember that but knowing soapland she probably found out by overhearing a conversation..

Son of Cain
08-03-2023, 16:36
[QUOTE=Son of Cain;991693]

Did Tracey find out? Do not remember that but knowing soapland she probably found out by overhearing a conversation..
I thought so, but I may be wrong. I thought Tracey disliked Amy, so assumed she knew. I thought Vanessa told her. Problem with Soaps is that when a character does something really bad, or carries out a serious crime, and is not leaving or being written out, they have find some half baked reason to let them off with the crime, so they can stay. More often than not, they are forgiven shortly after. More forgiveness in Soaps than there ever would be in real life.

Dennis tanner
08-03-2023, 18:27
I thought so, but I may be wrong. I thought Tracey disliked Amy, so assumed she knew. I thought Vanessa told her. Problem with Soaps is that when a character does something really bad, or carries out a serious crime, and is not leaving or being written out, they have find some half baked reason to let them off with the crime, so they can stay. More often than not, they are forgiven shortly after. More forgiveness in Soaps than there ever would be in real life.

Something I have not thought of much before.

lizann
08-03-2023, 20:32
did kerry or amy confess it to them? megan was never told

Dennis tanner
08-03-2023, 21:06
So Matty and Amy are 'off' at the moment. Kyle will be gutted if his brother is not going to marry his mom

Snagglepus
09-03-2023, 00:16
I seem to remember that Nate knows something that Tracy told him but I can't remember what it was and he has never mentioned it since.

Son of Cain
09-03-2023, 11:23
If Marlon keeps forcing himself on Paddy he could drive him to suicide or doing a runner again. Sometimes when people say they want to be alone, they really mean it. There are times when having to deal with others, takes just too much effort.

Perdita
09-03-2023, 12:34
If Marlon keeps forcing himself on Paddy he could drive him to suicide or doing a runner again. Sometimes when people say they want to be alone, they really mean it. There are times when having to deal with others, takes just too much effort.

Absolutely, enough people around to keep an eye on Paddy without constantly confronting him.

Dennis tanner
09-03-2023, 12:57
If Marlon keeps forcing himself on Paddy he could drive him to suicide or doing a runner again. Sounds like a plan !!!

johntrevor
09-03-2023, 12:57
Absolutely, enough people around to keep an eye on Paddy without constantly confronting him.

I agree..But Marlon is only doing, out of love and kindness, what he thinks will help Paddy, but doen't realise he is making things worse.

Perdita
09-03-2023, 16:12
I agree..But Marlon is only doing, out of love and kindness, what he thinks will help Paddy, but doen't realise he is making things worse.

I know, I hope Marlon will get the message before long.

lizann
09-03-2023, 16:46
I agree..But Marlon is only doing, out of love and kindness, what he thinks will help Paddy, but doen't realise he is making things worse.

i agree plus he is afraid to leave paddy alone for fear he will try again

Son of Cain
09-03-2023, 17:28
Sounds like a plan !!!

Oh dear, Dennis.

hward
09-03-2023, 23:27
Sounds like a plan !!!

I get you dont like the character but I don't think there's any need wish that

johntrevor
10-03-2023, 12:01
Oh dear, Dennis.

I agree completely with you. Very strange comment.

johntrevor
10-03-2023, 12:04
I get you dont like the character but I don't think there's any need wish that

Quite agree. Completely unnecessary comment.

lizann
10-03-2023, 13:19
laurel should call the police and social services for marshall

mouthy leyla just does not learn

matty and ethan very annoying

Son of Cain
10-03-2023, 14:16
Am I the only one that does not have a sparkly outfit in my wardrobe?

lizann
10-03-2023, 15:48
Am I the only one that does not have a sparkly outfit in my wardrobe?

ages ago id wear a bit of sparkle at Christmas not now

johntrevor
10-03-2023, 16:35
Am I the only one that does not have a sparkly outfit in my wardrobe?

No that makes at least 2 of us

Son of Cain
10-03-2023, 16:40
Marlon persists, personally if I was Paddy I would lock myself in my room. I cannot think of anything worse than being in a room full of people trying to get me to talk about my problems. Marlon should let Paddy dictate the pace of when he is ready to talk.

Perdita
10-03-2023, 18:51
No that makes at least 2 of us

Makes at least 3 of us now ...

Perdita
10-03-2023, 18:56
Marlon persists, personally if I was Paddy I would lock myself in my room. I cannot think of anything worse than being in a room full of people trying to get me to talk about my problems. Marlon should let Paddy dictate the pace of when he is ready to talk.

That is what I meant by my post that there are plenty of people keeping an eye on Paddy. but then they are all busy with their own lives.... I get Marlon being worried sick about Paddy saying "Not today"... could it be tomorrow, day after .. etc.. difficult situation for all to find the right balance ... :(

lizann
10-03-2023, 20:04
paddy will always be an honorary dingle, what a sight sam's behind and cain the wise man

Snagglepus
10-03-2023, 21:46
Paddy can't get over everyone knowing he is no good in the sack, and his wife was going elsewhere.
Didn't she tell Al that the only reason she was seeing him was for a good bonk.
All seems forgiven for Chas now.

johntrevor
11-03-2023, 12:58
Makes at least 3 of us now ...

HA HA Happy you could join us

johntrevor
11-03-2023, 13:02
That is what I meant by my post that there are plenty of people keeping an eye on Paddy. but then they are all busy with their own lives.... I get Marlon being worried sick about Paddy saying "Not today"... could it be tomorrow, day after .. etc.. difficult situation for all to find the right balance ... :(

I thought the lock-in episode was good. I know it was meant to be for Paddy's sake, but it also seemed to help Liam and Cain.

lizann
11-03-2023, 16:06
I thought the lock-in episode was good. I know it was meant to be for Paddy's sake, but it also seemed to help Liam and Cain.

i like cain and liam's bromance friendship

it was funny and sad but overall a really good episode, it should have been a hour

Dennis tanner
11-03-2023, 18:13
Oh dear, Dennis.

Sorry. I refuse to care about the bumbling idiot.

Dennis tanner
11-03-2023, 18:15
I get you dont like the character but I don't think there's any need wish that

Why are you so concerned about the well being of a fictional character ?

Son of Cain
12-03-2023, 10:07
Paddy can't get over everyone knowing he is no good in the sack, and his wife was going elsewhere.
Didn't she tell Al that the only reason she was seeing him was for a good bonk.
All seems forgiven for Chas now.

I think the fact that Paddy is living so close to Chas is one of the reasons he is finding it so difficult, I think he should have stayed away. If he does not want to start rebuilding his life from scratch he should at least move to Connelton or Hotten, that way he could keep his job at the vet's practice and not have to see Chas so often. Personally I thought the lock-in at the pub to get Paddy to open up, was a bit unrealistic. Being faced by that many people would be terrifying, especilly as they now all seem to have completely forgiven Chas even though she was to blame for the break up. I found Liam's tale just a bit to convenient in getting Paddy to join them in the bar. Wondering how long it will be until the whole sorry tale will be forgotten forever.

Son of Cain
12-03-2023, 10:09
Did Matty make a mistake by not getting up an running the moment Amy rang that bell?

Perdita
12-03-2023, 11:55
Did Matty make a mistake by not getting up an running the moment Amy rang that bell?

Won't last anyway

Dennis tanner
13-03-2023, 22:29
If you want to see a doctor in Emmerdale, do you go to the surgery or the allotment ?

By the way Suzi, it is all your fault. You started Leyla on the drugs.

lizann
14-03-2023, 01:34
If you want to see a doctor in Emmerdale, do you go to the surgery or the allotment ?
By the way Suzi, it is all your fault. You started Leyla on the drugs.

no one forced her

johntrevor
14-03-2023, 12:32
no one forced her

Quite right

Dennis tanner
14-03-2023, 16:35
no one forced her

I agree. Nobody forced Suzi to get her on drugs.

lizann
15-03-2023, 02:40
caleb telling leyla no matter how long he goes for revenge, is it on cain? why was caleb in the graveyard?

Dennis tanner
15-03-2023, 05:26
caleb telling leyla no matter how long he goes for revenge, is it on cain? why was caleb in the graveyard?

Caleb tells Leyla to take matters into her own hands. That went well !!!!

Son of Cain
15-03-2023, 10:05
Caleb tells Leyla to take matters into her own hands. That went well !!!!

Was not sure what to make of Leyla's conversation with Caleb, I found it a bit surreal, telling her she was tough and could handle herself. These are terms usually used to descibe someones ability in a physical way. Was he saying that she should and beat Callum up? Also wondering if they were hinting that Caleb is some sort of gangster?1
Leyla told Callum she would meet him in one hour, then turned up with a bundle of cash, saying she sold her car and maxed out her credit cards. But we have never seen any car dealers, banks or ATMs in the village, and she managed all this in an hour?

Son of Cain
15-03-2023, 10:12
Have we ever been told what Caleb does for a living, I cannot recall if we have. Given that he seems successful, drives a Bentley, I cannot ever recall any of the Dingles asking him, which seems very unrealistic. Do we know anything about him since he met Cain at sixteen? - Caleb "Man of Mystery" I feel they are carrying this too far.

Perdita
15-03-2023, 10:37
Have we ever been told what Caleb does for a living, I cannot recall if we have. Given that he seems successful, drives a Bentley, I cannot ever recall any of the Dingles asking him, which seems very unrealistic. Do know anything about him since he met Cain at sixteen? - Caleb "Man of Mystery" I feel they are carrying this too far.

If they have, I have missed it. Online speculation was that he is an undercover cop but the producer stated that he is not. Only seen him referred to as successful businessman but not what business. I believe that it will not be long now though before we will find out.

Perdita
15-03-2023, 10:39
Was not sure what to make of Leyla's conversation with Caleb, I found it a bit surreal, telling her she was tough and could handle herself. These are terms usually used to descibe someones ability in a physical way. Was he saying that she should and beat Callum up? Also wondering if they were hinting that Caleb is some sort of gangster?1
Leyla told Callum she would meet him in one hour, then turned up with a bundle of cash, saying she sold her car and maxed out her credit cards. But we have never seen any car dealers, banks or ATMs in the village, and she managed all this in an hour?

Hotten or Robblesfield does not seem too far away.. stupid of Leyla to go on her own though, why does she never learn?? :wall:

Son of Cain
15-03-2023, 10:59
If they have, I have missed it. Online speculation was that he is an undercover cop but the producer stated that he is not. Only seen him referred to as successful businessman but not what business. I believe that it will not be long now though before we will find out.

"Business" is a word beloved of Soaps, it can mean everything and nothing. It is a word overused often used as "businesd meeting", "business conntacts" when the rest of us would simply say meeting or contacts.

Son of Cain
15-03-2023, 11:01
Hotten or Robblesfield does not seem too far away.. stupid of Leyla to go on her own though, why does she never learn?? :wall:

I would think far enough away, when you have no transport beause you sold your car, and still have to get to the bridge within an hour..

Snagglepus
15-03-2023, 11:08
Leyla told Callum she would meet him in one hour, then turned up with a bundle of cash, saying she sold her car and maxed out her credit cards. But we have never seen any car dealers, banks or ATMs in the village, and she managed all this in an hour?

And she wasn't singing 'I've just sold my cah ah ar on we buy any cah ah ar'. ( I can't stand those adverts).

Son of Cain
15-03-2023, 11:23
And she wasn't singing 'I've just sold my cah ah ar on we buy any cah ah ar'. ( I can't stand those adverts).

But they provide work for Philip Schofield and Rylan Clark, would you deny them money for nothing.

lizann
15-03-2023, 19:04
Have we ever been told what Caleb does for a living, I cannot recall if we have. Given that he seems successful, drives a Bentley, I cannot ever recall any of the Dingles asking him, which seems very unrealistic. Do we know anything about him since he met Cain at sixteen? - Caleb "Man of Mystery" I feel they are carrying this too far.

he knows about horses and has good legal contacts

Son of Cain
15-03-2023, 21:19
he knows about horses and has good legal contacts

The fact that he knows a top team of defence lawyers, suggests that he has had need of them in the past, so is likely to be some sort of crook.

katie hunter
15-03-2023, 21:42
Caleb and Leyla have officially shared one scene together. Wedding bells won't be too far away I'm calling it now 😅

katie hunter
15-03-2023, 21:44
Have we ever been told what Caleb does for a living, I cannot recall if we have. Given that he seems successful, drives a Bentley, I cannot ever recall any of the Dingles asking him, which seems very unrealistic. Do we know anything about him since he met Cain at sixteen? - Caleb "Man of Mystery" I feel they are carrying this too far.

No one appears to know where he lives either, he just disappears in his Bentley. I half expected him to be caught living in Rishi's house.

lizann
15-03-2023, 21:52
i was thinking caleb is callum's top boss

Dennis tanner
15-03-2023, 22:52
Caleb and Leyla have officially shared one scene together. Wedding bells won't be too far away I'm calling it now 😅

I don't think he's a fool.

Perdita
16-03-2023, 04:47
Leyla needs to learn when to shut up....

vapeat
16-03-2023, 05:58
Just a thought but is it possible that Caleb and Nicky are related and are in cahoots to get Home Farm.

Son of Cain
16-03-2023, 09:54
i was thinking caleb is callum's top boss

I have convinced myself that Callum is a major cocaine dealer.

johntrevor
16-03-2023, 12:08
I have convinced myself that Callum is a major cocaine dealer.

Not sure about that...He went into panic mode when Leyla said no to delivering for him, and he talked of doing a runner to Spain

Perdita
16-03-2023, 12:28
Once again, a super fast recovery of someone very ill in hospital one day, only a small plaster on the forehead and out of hospital again the next....

johntrevor
16-03-2023, 14:02
Once again, a super fast recovery of someone very ill in hospital one day, only a small plaster on the forehead and out of hospital again the next....

That Hotten General really is something isn't it. No NHS problems there.

Dennis tanner
16-03-2023, 14:43
That Hotten General really is something isn't it. No NHS problems there.

Only the Amos Brearly wing is good.

Son of Cain
16-03-2023, 16:45
Not sure about that...He went into panic mode when Leyla said no to delivering for him, and he talked of doing a runner to Spain

I meant to type Caleb, I am sure I did, sometimes this auto correct thinks it knows what I mean better than me. It would explain how he owns a Bentley and never actually seems to go to work.

Dennis tanner
16-03-2023, 18:18
I meant to type Caleb, I am sure I did, sometimes this auto correct thinks it knows what I mean better than me. It would explain how he owns a Bentley and never actually seems to go to work.

Perhaps there is a big demand for Horse whisperers

Son of Cain
16-03-2023, 19:12
Only the Amos Brearly wing is good.

Do the doctors there all have pork chop side whiskers?

Dennis tanner
16-03-2023, 21:57
Do the doctors there all have pork chop side whiskers?

Alas, no longer. The wing was named in his honour though.

lizann
17-03-2023, 03:02
so thats it for callum anti climax

chas forgiven

Perdita
17-03-2023, 04:57
Who called the police and told them where to go??? :hmm:

johntrevor
17-03-2023, 12:02
Who called the police and told them where to go??? :hmm:

Well when they wer all shouting in the barn, Callum said how did the police find out, and Suzy said I'm sorry I had to, so I assume she phoned them

lizann
17-03-2023, 15:57
david and liam didn't go looking, didn't seem worried

Son of Cain
17-03-2023, 16:31
There's now an empty shed in the woods with electricity, that Paddy could move into.

Son of Cain
17-03-2023, 16:34
david and liam didn't go looking, didn't seem worried

Probably hoping they never see her again. - Cannot stand any more drama in their lives.

Dennis tanner
17-03-2023, 18:22
Well when they wer all shouting in the barn, Callum said how did the police find out, and Suzy said I'm sorry I had to, so I assume she phoned them

Suzy persuaded a team of armed police to come to what was an empty barn ???

Son of Cain
17-03-2023, 19:34
"Fancy being held at gunpoint" says Brenda - half the village has been held at gunpoint at one time or another.

Dennis tanner
18-03-2023, 02:15
3 of his flock are kidnapped and held at gun point.

Does the vicar visit them or does he play chess ?

Dennis tanner
20-03-2023, 21:11
Two questions.

Kirk said that Marlon would be there to pick him up when he was down. How on earth would he do that?

Regarding Cathy, how would the Vivienne, have dealt with it ?

lizann
20-03-2023, 22:34
Two questions.

Kirk said that Marlon would be there to pick him up when he was down. How on earth would he do that?

Regarding Cathy, how would the Vivienne, have dealt with it ?

cathy should be in any discussions about her from the start now a specialist has to diagnose "Premenstrual Dysphoric Disorder" for cathy and where was brenda

lizann
22-03-2023, 00:24
no sympathy for naomi , alex wants nought to do with his own kids with dawn

Dennis tanner
22-03-2023, 15:14
no sympathy for naomi , alex wants nought to do with his own kids with dawn

Very strange behaviour from Naomi. Jobless Alex was never going to pay for her nightly partying.

lizann
23-03-2023, 02:01
is alex living with charles

flappinfanny
23-03-2023, 23:41
I enjoyed that tonight, plenty of light and shade. I like a drunk fun Cain, played so well by Geoff, without over egging the pudding. Mixed emotions for Chas with Paddy leaving. I think we can safely say Paddy and Bear will be back at the Woolie within days. And finally Mack looked mighty lovely in that Kilt, I wonder if he wore it the Scottish traditional way? Emmerdale soap of the night.
P.S just wanted to rewind to Wednesday episode and I thought Nicola was her amazing bitchy self in the Cafe, wonderful stuff, delivered to perfection by the actress also called Nicola. :D

lizann
24-03-2023, 00:33
chas all forgiven, al forgot about, off easy even with all collateral damage

Dennis tanner
24-03-2023, 16:02
It's strange that Eve never had trouble sleeping when Kirk went AWOL for a few weeks.

The keys go missing. The surgery is insecure and the recently released jailbird is seen to be filming Manpreet opening the secure cabinet.

Nobody is suspicious. Are they all totally stupid?

lizann
24-03-2023, 20:27
It's strange that Eve never had trouble sleeping when Kirk went AWOL for a few weeks.

The keys go missing. The surgery is insecure and the recently released jailbird is seen to be filming Manpreet opening the secure cabinet.

Nobody is suspicious. Are they all totally stupid?

naomi yes very stupid and annoying

Dennis tanner
24-03-2023, 21:06
I think that Mack should tell Charity about the baby before they get married. Yes, they will fall out for a while but I think it would be better for them long term

lizann
25-03-2023, 00:47
I think that Mack should tell Charity about the baby before they get married. Yes, they will fall out for a while but I think it would be better for them long term

i thinks she knows

Dennis tanner
25-03-2023, 02:37
i thinks she knows

If so, it would be good if she told him.

katie hunter
25-03-2023, 11:09
Are we supposed to feel sorry for Chloe? I find her unbearable 😩

lizann
25-03-2023, 12:13
If so, it would be good if she told him.

expect wedding day fireworks and baby arriving

lizann
27-03-2023, 21:50
Are we supposed to feel sorry for Chloe? I find her unbearable 😩

same

alex lost the kim money fast, must be spent on drugs

Dennis tanner
27-03-2023, 22:51
Sam is annoying me but Amelia is annoying me even more.

If Sam showed an intererest in her she would drop Noah like a stone.

She will probably see Noah as the villain who paid Sam to keep them apart.

Noah is a fool for wasting all his money

lizann
28-03-2023, 01:01
Sam is annoying me but Amelia is annoying me even more.

If Sam showed an intererest in her she would drop Noah like a stone.

She will probably see Noah as the villain who paid Sam to keep them apart.

Noah is a fool for wasting all his money

noah should move on from amelia with any money he has left, get samson done for blackmail extortion

Dennis tanner
28-03-2023, 01:31
noah should move on from amelia with any money he has left, get samson done for blackmail extortion

I can't see any offence here. Noah was daft enough to pay him. He was not obliged to pay anything.

lizann
28-03-2023, 02:00
I can't see any offence here. Noah was daft enough to pay him. He was not obliged to pay anything.

noah should have recorded samson and how has no one noticed all samson new spends, a classy phone etc.,

Dennis tanner
28-03-2023, 03:19
noah should have recorded samson and how has no one noticed all samson new spends, a classy phone etc.,

Samson will say that Noah persuaded him to take the money and stay away ????

lizann
28-03-2023, 20:39
amelia could defer college for a few years

Son of Cain
28-03-2023, 20:58
When Samson went up the stairs, I hope it was to pack his bags, ready to get off his mark. I certainly would not want to be hanging about when an irate Charity came looking for me.

flappinfanny
28-03-2023, 23:33
Who is going to find out about Chloe and Mack next? Samson is a real delight I don't think. So Charity knows about Samson. I quite enjoyed that episode not a lot happened but it was an easy watch for 22 minutes without anything harrowing happening unlike it's big sister over the Pennines.

Dennis tanner
28-03-2023, 23:51
Noah is an idiot but I do feel sorry for him.

He probably feels and may well be right, that no other girl would want to know him because of his conviction.

Son of Cain
29-03-2023, 07:58
Talk about poking the bear, both Dawn and Billy really need to learn to keep their mouths shut. Alex was quite prepared to let the adoption go ahead until they started mouthing off, who knows what will happen now. Don't understand why Naomi is urging Alex to fight for his kids, does she really want a boyfriend with a couple of kids in tow.

hward
29-03-2023, 13:40
Glad Charity knows. With a bit of luck she'll wipe the smirk off Samson's face. He's such a horrid piece of work

lizann
29-03-2023, 17:46
Glad Charity knows. With a bit of luck she'll wipe the smirk off Samson's face. He's such a horrid piece of work

he was a good lad and then boom overnight change to a villain

katie hunter
29-03-2023, 21:16
Amelia is so ungrateful and she would probably have dropped Noah like a hot stone if Samson had shown any interest in her. Run Noah run.

Dennis tanner
29-03-2023, 21:25
Amelia is so ungrateful and she would probably have dropped Noah like a hot stone if Samson had shown any interest in her. Run Noah run.

Fast and far.

lizann
29-03-2023, 23:15
Amelia is so ungrateful and she would probably have dropped Noah like a hot stone if Samson had shown any interest in her. Run Noah run.

amelia mad no money or samson, noah deserves better

Dennis tanner
30-03-2023, 02:13
amelia mad no money or samson, noah deserves better

Of course he does but he wasn't blackmailed.

alan45
30-03-2023, 09:27
Talk about poking the bear, both Dawn and Billy really need to learn to keep their mouths shut. Alex was quite prepared to let the adoption go ahead until they started mouthing off, who knows what will happen now. Don't understand why Naomi is urging Alex to fight for his kids, does she really want a boyfriend with a couple of kids in tow.

Think its part of the plot to have a number of suspects when Alex gets knocked down/bumped off

Son of Cain
30-03-2023, 10:08
Does Charles never get tired of poking his nose into other people's business. He constantly gets involved in things without considering the reactions he causes.

Son of Cain
30-03-2023, 10:14
What a remarkable coincidence that Sam, Samson, Charity, Noah, Amelia and Dan all happened to be in the High Street at the same time.

Dennis tanner
30-03-2023, 16:02
Does Charles never get tired of poking his nose into other people's business. He constantly gets involved in things without considering the reactions he causes.

I can just about excuse his stupid daughter but he should know better.

lizann
30-03-2023, 21:09
silly billy

Dennis tanner
30-03-2023, 23:35
silly billy

Of all the cars in all the world, you had to step in front of mine.

I am still puzzled as to how Alex managed to cause that van to crash.

Charity....This is urgent. Please sort Noah out.

The reaction of stupid Naomi was totally predictable.

Kim is still waiting for her fish and chips.

lizann
30-03-2023, 23:39
kim has an elvis in will, im sure the kids enjoyed that

gabby pregnant, i find her and nicky boring

Son of Cain
31-03-2023, 09:38
Of all the cars in all the world, you had to step in front of mine.

I am still puzzled as to how Alex managed to cause that van to crash.

Charity....This is urgent. Please sort Noah out.

The reaction of stupid Naomi was totally predictable.

Kim is still waiting for her fish and chips.

Not just Silly Billy, but, Stupid, Thick Idiotic Billy. Why on earth did he drive off, there was no witnesses so if he said Alex jumped out in front of him, who is to question it.
A poorly written and filmed episode. I really dislike these "jump forward" cuts, they add nothing, indeed they spoiled the actual moment when Alex was hit, because we were expecting it and waiting for it to happen. Alex standing in the road on the phone on the other side of the road from Billy suddenly turns and runs into the path of Billy's car, for no good reason that I could see. Billy driving down the road sees someone standing in the road on the phone but does not slow up like almost everyone else would do, keeps on speeding along so that he could not stop and avoid hitting Alex. Earlier it looked to me, that Alex would have had time to get into the car, lock the door to stop Charles reaching him and then drive off.
It is obvious that Alex used mind control to make the van driver run off the road and crash. Much more efficient than Aaron and Mack's heists.
Of course with Charles having gone for a "drive" he is probably going to be in the frame for this.

Son of Cain
31-03-2023, 09:43
Church going christian Amelia is not very forgiving, is she.

johntrevor
31-03-2023, 11:23
Not just Silly Billy, but, Stupid, Thick Idiotic Billy. Why on earth did he drive off, there was no witnesses so if he said Alex jumped out in front of him, who is to question it.
A poorly written and filmed episode. I really dislike these "jump forward" cuts, they add nothing, indeed they spoiled the actual moment when Alex was hit, because we were expecting it and waiting for it to happen. Alex standing in the road on the phone on the other side of the road from Billy suddenly turns and runs into the path of Billy's car, for no good reason that I could see. Billy driving down the road sees someone standing in the road on the phone but does not slow up like almost everyone else would do, keeps on speeding along so that he could not stop and avoid hitting Alex. Earlier it looked to me, that Alex would have had time to get into the car, lock the door to stop Charles reaching him and then drive off.
It is obvious that Alex used mind control to make the van driver run off the road and crash. Much more efficient than Aaron and Mack's heists.
Of course with Charles having gone for a "drive" he is probably going to be in the frame for this.

Completely agree a terrible episode, more holes than a fishing net. Alex's car was stopped behind the phamacy drivers, so how the hell did he get him to stop and end up slumped over the steering wheel? Why was Billy evn on that road when he hit Alex, he was only going for fish and chips, can't you get them anywhere in the village?

Son of Cain
31-03-2023, 11:32
Completely agree a terrible episode, more holes than a fishing net. Alex's car was stopped behind the phamacy drivers, so how the hell did he get him to stop and end up slumped over the steering wheel? Why was Billy evn on that road when he hit Alex, he was only going for fish and chips, can't you get them anywhere in the village?

I think the one positive thing we learned from this episode, is there is no fish and chip shop in the village. I think many years ago they may have mentioned that there use to be a fish and chip van that came round once a week. On the negative side, it must mean that your fish and chips would be cold and soggy by the time you got back to the village.

Perdita
31-03-2023, 15:59
I expect Alex to be wide awake and alert next episode in hospital talking to the police, plaster on forehead, oxygen tube up nostrils and getting ready for discharge. Of course he will remember that it was Billy who hit him and ran.

Dennis tanner
31-03-2023, 16:10
Church going christian Amelia is not very forgiving, is she.

Perhaps Noah's devotion was unforgiveable

lizann
31-03-2023, 19:04
I expect Alex to be wide awake and alert next episode in hospital talking to the police, plaster on forehead, oxygen tube up nostrils and getting ready for discharge. Of course he will remember that it was Billy who hit him and ran.

blackmail $$$$$$$$

Son of Cain
31-03-2023, 19:57
I am shocked and surprised that the police should think that the good vicar Charles should be responsible for Alex's hit and run, just because he went for a "drive".

lizann
31-03-2023, 20:06
where's all the drugs

Dennis tanner
31-03-2023, 20:08
where's all the drugs

I am baffled as to why he didn't keep them with him.

alan45
31-03-2023, 20:35
I am shocked and surprised that the police should think that the good vicar Charles should be responsible for Alex's hit and run, just because he went for a "drive".

One look at the Vicarmobile will soon prove his innocence unless of course there was no contact between Alex and the offending vehicle and the soap police just scoop him because he was out for a drive.

Son of Cain
31-03-2023, 20:46
where's all the drugs

Alex was saying he had stashed them on the phone to Clare just before he was hit. So presumably they are hidden in the woods somewhere.

lizann
31-03-2023, 21:00
charles and alex had a scruffle on his car bonnet or alex car bonnet so dna might be on it which is another bit of evidence against the vicar

naomi probably thinks him guilty

Son of Cain
31-03-2023, 21:04
One look at the Vicarmobile will soon prove his innocence unless of course there was no contact between Alex and the offending vehicle and the soap police just scoop him because he was out for a drive.

Charles has already admitted that he pushed Alex against his bonnet with enough force to dent it, so there is likely to be some trace to prove this, hopefully no blood.

Snagglepus
31-03-2023, 21:19
Charles will be ok, he has god on his side, this is just a test.

katie hunter
31-03-2023, 22:40
So many plot holes. What about the hijacked pharmacy driver? Didn't Charles have some of the boxes of pills to prove his story? How could that dent in the car cause Alex injuries? 😵

Dennis tanner
31-03-2023, 23:36
charles and alex had a scruffle on his car bonnet or alex car bonnet so dna might be on it which is another bit of evidence against the vicar

naomi probably thinks him guilty

Naomi is stupid enough to believe anything

Dennis tanner
31-03-2023, 23:37
So many plot holes. What about the hijacked pharmacy driver? Didn't Charles have some of the boxes of pills to prove his story? How could that dent in the car cause Alex injuries? 😵

and what happened to those Fish & Chips for Home Farm ?

flappinfanny
01-04-2023, 23:06
Is Nicky's secret something to do with Caleb? or am I barking up the wrong tree?

I am really liking Mandy right now, she is better when she is toned down a tad. The scenes in the Salon and Woolie with charity were spot on.

Dennis tanner
02-04-2023, 03:10
I am really liking Mandy right now, she is better when she is toned down a tad. The scenes in the Salon and Woolie with charity were spot on.

I feel obliged to say that I have never liked Mandy Dingle and never will.

Son of Cain
02-04-2023, 11:59
Mandy offering Amelia a job. - Not so long ago she was telling Bernice she could not afford to keep her on.

Snagglepus
02-04-2023, 13:30
I am really liking Mandy right now.
She flaps her hands too much for me.

Dennis tanner
02-04-2023, 15:23
She flaps her hands too much for me.

and her gums

alan45
03-04-2023, 00:02
Charles has already admitted that he pushed Alex against his bonnet with enough force to dent it, so there is likely to be some trace to prove this, hopefully no blood.
Still I don't think the damage caused by that would comprevto the damage caused striking Alex in a traffic accident and causing multiple, hopefully life threatening injuries.

Son of Cain
03-04-2023, 12:13
and what happened to those Fish & Chips for Home Farm ?

I always have some in the freezer, hopefully Lydia does the same for Kim. Either that, or it was Pot Noddle time.

Dennis tanner
03-04-2023, 14:03
Still I don't think the damage caused by that would comprevto the damage caused striking Alex in a traffic accident and causing multiple, hopefully life threatening injuries.

Real experts could tell the difference

lizann
03-04-2023, 20:09
well said ethan, finally a good scene with him

Dennis tanner
04-04-2023, 00:08
well said ethan, finally a good scene with him Quite.

Naomi just regards Charles as a meal ticket.

Alex's girlfriend was spot on....She really is that stupid.

A good search by the Police should locate those stolen drugs

Son of Cain
04-04-2023, 09:48
Alex standing in the middle of the road using his phone, and Billy says he did not see him. If his eyesight is that bad, he should not be driving. I am still puzzled why Alex chose to step out onto the road instead of staying on the verge where he was safe.

Dennis tanner
04-04-2023, 15:53
Alex standing in the middle of the road using his phone, and Billy says he did not see him. If his eyesight is that bad, he should not be driving. I am still puzzled why Alex chose to step out onto the road instead of staying on the verge where he was safe.

So he could knocked over I assume

Son of Cain
04-04-2023, 17:23
So he could knocked over I assume

Did you notice if he had pinned a target on his back?

Dennis tanner
04-04-2023, 20:39
Did you notice if he had pinned a target on his back?

He was told to cross the road for no apparent reason and then walk back over when there was a car coming.

Chas knows the truth. ( Can I call him Chas or is that too confusing ?)

I am confident he will not go to the Police but he's daft enough to tel his stupid daughter who is already making it all about her.

Bite the bullet Kim. Kick out Gobby, her fiancee and Thomas Thomas

Son of Cain
04-04-2023, 21:38
Thomas Thomas? Is he really called that? Surely not even Dim Gabby would call him that? Think of the nicknames he could have. Double T, TT and Tom Tom.

Son of Cain
04-04-2023, 21:40
Not that Charles knows Billy hit Alex, he does not seem to mind so much that he stands accused, as this gives him a chance to do some good work".

lizann
04-04-2023, 23:53
Thomas Thomas? Is he really called that? Surely not even Dim Gabby would call him that? Think of the nicknames he could have. Double T, TT and Tom Tom.

thomas tate

lizann
04-04-2023, 23:56
all talk of a murder charge but alex is alive and now awake

Dennis tanner
05-04-2023, 01:48
Thomas Thomas? Is he really called that? Surely not even Dim Gabby would call him that? Think of the nicknames he could have. Double T, TT and Tom Tom.

I think that Kim prefers the Tate surname.

Son of Cain
05-04-2023, 07:45
thomas tate

Disappointed - Thomas Thomas had a ring to it.

Son of Cain
05-04-2023, 07:49
all talk of a murder charge but alex is alive and now awake

For it to murder there they would need to prove intent, I doubt they would even get a manslaughter charge out of this. There were no witnesses, at most it would probably be careless driving, not even that if he said Alex stepped out suddenly without warning.

johntrevor
05-04-2023, 12:16
For it to murder there they would need to prove intent, I doubt they would even get a manslaughter charge out of this. There were no witnesses, at most it would probably be careless driving, not even that if he said Alex stepped out suddenly without warning.

I wonder if it's possible that Alex saw Billy.

When Billy stood over him checking him out Alex had his eyes open, he closed them as Billy walked away.

lizann
05-04-2023, 14:41
I wonder if it's possible that Alex saw Billy.

When Billy stood over him checking him out Alex had his eyes open, he closed them as Billy walked away.

he probably did and will blackmail

lizann
05-04-2023, 14:43
billy was heard threatening alex and they have previous

lizann
05-04-2023, 20:11
dark bad charles got interesting going pulp fiction on alex thought he'd kill him off

Dennis tanner
05-04-2023, 20:34
billy was heard threatening alex and they have previous

Billy shouldn't worry. I have told Hotton Police that he was with me in Hotton all that day

Son of Cain
05-04-2023, 20:47
Billy shouldn't worry. I have told Hotton Police that he was with me in Hotton all that day

You do realize that perverting the course of justice can carry a life sentence - good luck with that.

katie hunter
05-04-2023, 20:59
Alex joins a long list of 'near deaths door miraculous recoveries'. The only one I can recall ever dying at Hotten General is John Barton? There can't be many more?

Who is the hooded person watching Caleb?

Dennis tanner
05-04-2023, 23:52
You do realize that perverting the course of justice can carry a life sentence - good luck with that.

They would need to prove it.

Dennis tanner
05-04-2023, 23:54
Alex joins a long list of 'near deaths door miraculous recoveries'. The only one I can recall ever dying at Hotten General is John Barton? There can't be many more?

Who is the hooded person watching Caleb?

The chap in the hood is Callum isn't it ?

lizann
06-04-2023, 00:21
The chap in the hood is Callum isn't it ?

is it someone after caleb or working for caleb, nicky?

did i sense jealousy from kim over leyla with caleb

Son of Cain
06-04-2023, 07:49
They would need to prove it.

Or me and paddy could dob you in.

johntrevor
06-04-2023, 12:23
dark bad charles got interesting going pulp fiction on alex thought he'd kill him off

Very hypocritical of Charlie Boy. He threatens Alex for how he's treated Naomi, not long after he gave Will and Kim a good rollicking over the way they treated Alex for threatening Dawn. Weird.

Dennis tanner
06-04-2023, 16:12
Or me and paddy could dob you in.

Fair enough. I withdraw my alibi.

Dennis tanner
06-04-2023, 16:13
Very hypocritical of Charlie Boy. He threatens Alex for how he's treated Naomi, not long after he gave Will and Kim a good rollicking over the way they treated Alex for threatening Dawn. Weird.

I had to snigger when he took off his dog collar.

lizann
06-04-2023, 19:32
well i didn't expect caleb to be frank tate's son, he is also really faith's son?

Dennis tanner
06-04-2023, 20:32
well i didn't expect caleb to be frank tate's son, he is also really faith's son?

Certainly, if that's what Emmerdale wants

lizann
06-04-2023, 20:37
Certainly, if that's what Emmerdale wants

faith and frank hooked up

alan45
06-04-2023, 23:26
Very hypocritical of Charlie Boy. He threatens Alex for how he's treated Naomi, not long after he gave Will and Kim a good rollicking over the way they treated Alex for threatening Dawn. Weird.

Not unusual for the post of Vicar in Emmerdale. Harriett was involved in some dodgy dealings too.

Perdita
07-04-2023, 04:24
Paul Lambert, Bernice's half-brother was mentioned.... wonder if he returns from Portugal ....

Dennis tanner
07-04-2023, 05:17
Paul Lambert, Bernice's half-brother was mentioned.... wonder if he returns from Portugal ....

Paul was a good character.

Perdita
07-04-2023, 06:03
Paul was a good character.

Yes, I liked him, would be nice if he came to visit Pollard

lizann
07-04-2023, 15:57
Yes, I liked him, would be nice if he came to visit Pollard

and nicola, rodney and bernice

lizann
07-04-2023, 19:54
nicky is funny

"baby talking stupidity and that's just gabby"

Dennis tanner
07-04-2023, 22:52
If Frank Tate thought that Caleb was entitled to anything, he would have mentioned him in his will.

Noah has a far better claim to Tate money but you don't see him plotting to steal Kim's money

lizann
07-04-2023, 23:26
If Frank Tate thought that Caleb was entitled to anything, he would have mentioned him in his will.

Noah has a far better claim to Tate money but you don't see him plotting to steal Kim's money

but frank may not have known about caleb or liam ( the son zoe killed )

Dennis tanner
08-04-2023, 00:35
but frank may not have known about caleb or liam ( the son zoe killed )

I agree but that doesn't make Caleb's claim relevant.

lizann
08-04-2023, 00:39
had frank divorced kim when she let him die as she was with dave?

it seems caleb has no interest in his tate family like noah and zoe and joe but yes his "dingle" side

Dennis tanner
08-04-2023, 04:08
had frank divorced kim when she let him die as she was with dave?

it seems caleb has no interest in his tate family like noah and zoe and joe but yes his "dingle" side

Noah is a Dingle

I wish Mary and Faye well but they are boring me big time

I may be missing something here but why is Rhona so reluctant to help Gus ?

Perdita
08-04-2023, 04:15
[QUOTE=Dennis tanner;993340

I may be missing something here but why is Rhona so reluctant to help Gus ?[/QUOTE]

It is her eggs he wants to use so basically Gus and his wife will raise Rhona's child

Son of Cain
08-04-2023, 09:51
Nicky has very strong accent (what accent is that) quite different to his dad.

Son of Cain
08-04-2023, 10:02
I hate when Soap's bring back characters, or revive stories from the past. My memory is just not good enough to remember, who is or who, or who did what to who. This Caleb business is a prime example, particularly as Kim's back story is so complicated. For new viewers it must be even more puzzling. Instead of sitting back and enjoying the programme I am now constantly Goggling and trying to remember history. Made even worse when sometimes Soaps see it as an opportunity to rewrite that history.

Son of Cain
08-04-2023, 10:05
Nicky is talking about needing money to prevent "mam" from becoming homeless, but Caleb is still driving a Bently and consulting expensive lawyers.

johntrevor
08-04-2023, 12:52
Nicky is talking about needing money to prevent "mam" from becoming homeless, but Caleb is still driving a Bently and consulting expensive lawyers.

And is the "mam" at some stage going to appear and be somebody we know from Emmerdale history.

flappinfanny
08-04-2023, 14:33
The Dingle/Tate family tree is getting a tad complicated. :D

Dennis tanner
08-04-2023, 15:45
It is her eggs he wants to use so basically Gus and his wife will raise Rhona's child

A child who wouldn't even exist if she just left the eggs where they were or destroyed them.

Perdita
08-04-2023, 15:48
A child who wouldn't even exist if she just left the eggs where they were or destroyed them.t
She was under the impression that they had been destroyed but Gus paid for their frozen term to be extended which Rhona was unaware of. I hope she refuses and has them destroyed now, horrible thing for Gus to do even if it means he and his wife will be childless, they can maybe go for adoption or fostering but to ask Rhona is a mean and selfish thing to do in my opinion.

Dennis tanner
08-04-2023, 18:09
t
She was under the impression that they had been destroyed but Gus paid for their frozen term to be extended which Rhona was unaware of. I hope she refuses and has them destroyed now, horrible thing for Gus to do even if it means he and his wife will be childless, they can maybe go for adoption or fostering but to ask Rhona is a mean and selfish thing to do in my opinion.

I totally disagree. If she refuses, it will be Rhona who is being selfish

Son of Cain
08-04-2023, 18:54
t
She was under the impression that they had been destroyed but Gus paid for their frozen term to be extended which Rhona was unaware of. I hope she refuses and has them destroyed now, horrible thing for Gus to do even if it means he and his wife will be childless, they can maybe go for adoption or fostering but to ask Rhona is a mean and selfish thing to do in my opinion.

I think this is a story that could possibly be explored in more depth. If Gus and his wife live close by or move to be close. Then if Rhona gave permission for the embryos to be used she could have contact with the child/children growing up and have some input into their lives. I am not saying this what should happen, but it could be an interesting and new approach to parenting. I don't think it is something that has happened in a Soap before, and is certainly no more far fetched than many stories in the past.

Son of Cain
08-04-2023, 19:03
The Dingle/Tate family tree is getting a tad complicated. :D

Exactly - One of the reasons I dislike tales that delve into the past.

I would prefer them to introduce new characters that had no connection to the village or it's inhabitants.

Dennis tanner
08-04-2023, 20:09
I think this is a story that could possibly be explored in more depth. If Gus and his wife live close by or move to be close. Then if Rhona gave permission for the embryos to be used she could have contact with the child/children growing up and have some input into their lives. I am not saying this what should happen, but it could be an interesting and new approach to parenting. I don't think it is something that has happened in a Soap before, and is certainly no more far fetched than many stories in the past.

I just think she should let them get on with it and then forget all about it.

lizann
08-04-2023, 20:55
Nicky has very strong accent (what accent is that) quite different to his dad.

geordie

tammyy2j
08-04-2023, 22:53
I am confused now that Caleb is Frank's son and coming for his will share, when did he find out?

johntrevor
09-04-2023, 12:08
I just think she should let them get on with it and then forget all about it.

I disagree competely they are Rhona's eggs not Gus's and most definitely not Lucy's. It is up to Rhona to decide what happens to HER eggs.

Son of Cain
09-04-2023, 14:46
I disagree competely they are Rhona's eggs not Gus's and most definitely not Lucy's. It is up to Rhona to decide what happens to HER eggs.

Is it that simple? They are talking about embryos, fertilized eggs, which could be argued are owned, jointly, 50/50 by Rhona AND Gus. Seems this is the sort of thing that a court would need to decide.

Perdita
09-04-2023, 16:38
And is the "mam" at some stage going to appear and be somebody we know from Emmerdale history.
I am sure she will appear, no doubt in my mind on that!! Whether the character has been in Emmerdale before remains to be seen.

lizann
09-04-2023, 19:33
And is the "mam" at some stage going to appear and be somebody we know from Emmerdale history.

of course she will, some speculation it is tina dingle

Dennis tanner
10-04-2023, 00:56
I disagree competely they are Rhona's eggs not Gus's and most definitely not Lucy's. It is up to Rhona to decide what happens to HER eggs.

They are egss which she abandoned years ago.

Why not try and help someone who needs them.

Perdita
10-04-2023, 04:16
They are egss which she abandoned years ago.

Why not try and help someone who needs them.

It would be her child that is being raised by an ex husband and his new wife, she would not have any contact with her son or daughter and that is not easy to decide on

johntrevor
10-04-2023, 11:44
It would be her child that is being raised by an ex husband and his new wife, she would not have any contact with her son or daughter and that is not easy to decide on

Completely agree

lizann
10-04-2023, 14:52
It would be her child that is being raised by an ex husband and his new wife, she would not have any contact with her son or daughter and that is not easy to decide on

plus rhona can't have anymore kids naturally as went into early menopause from what i remember so knowing she has a child out there she would find it hard to keep a distance

Son of Cain
10-04-2023, 15:07
plus rhona can't have anymore kids naturally as went into early menopause from what i remember so knowing she has a child out there she would find it hard to keep a distance

We do not know if Gus would be willing or unwilling for Rhona to see the child. I cannot remember the circumstances when the embryos were frozen, or what the law is relating to frozen embryos of couples who have split. But since Gus is the father of any children resulting from there use, I wonder if Rhona could have them destroyed without consulting or getting permission from Gus.

lizann
10-04-2023, 18:44
i think actress Sofia Vergara had a court case over frozen embryos with her ex husband

lizann
10-04-2023, 20:49
caleb lurking in the graveyard and eyedropping on kim's money talk will get him caught

Dennis tanner
10-04-2023, 22:03
caleb lurking in the graveyard and eyedropping on kim's money talk will get him caught

Let's hope so. I hope Rhona is not persuaded to change her mind.

Amelia and her baby is boring me to tears

flappinfanny
10-04-2023, 23:23
Very cinematic Kim standing over Frank and Chris?s grave in thick snow.

lizann
11-04-2023, 16:27
the graveyard in emmerdale is one thing i do like, sad and sicko am i

Son of Cain
11-04-2023, 16:48
I have never much liked Mary, she is always sticking her nose in other people's business, and I like her even less now. I can see why Rhona was not too happy when she turned up in the village. When Gus and Lucy came to the pub, during the family meal, all Rhona had to say was, not now, and set a date and time when she would talk to them. She did now need Mary to take over and speak for her, especially when Mary was offering her opinion and not Rhona's. With a bit of luck next time Faye goes to Equador or Venezuela, or wherever it is she goes, she will take Mary with her and stay there.

lizann
11-04-2023, 20:12
nickys eagerness will make kim and gabby suss, also doesn't home farm have cameras?

Dennis tanner
12-04-2023, 05:18
Marlon says, " I will support any decision you make "

Next day..." I think you are wrong"

johntrevor
12-04-2023, 11:52
Marlon says, " I will support any decision you make "

Next day..." I think you are wrong"

Never heard of the saying "We will have to agree to disagree"

Snagglepus
12-04-2023, 14:17
also doesn't home farm have cameras?
It seems to be only when the plot requires them.

lizann
12-04-2023, 20:31
has caleb his own snow machine or were scenes shot in different times

an just pi$$ off chas

Dennis tanner
12-04-2023, 20:56
Never heard of the saying "We will have to agree to disagree"

I have heard of the saying. I am surprised that you haven't.

Dennis tanner
12-04-2023, 20:58
So the non working Doctor, the non working Vet and the non working wrestler decide to go fishing but haven't got the equipment needed.

Next week they plan to go scuba diving.

Son of Cain
13-04-2023, 09:09
Paddy buying a new washing machine when the old one might just need a new door seal?

Son of Cain
13-04-2023, 09:18
Does the baby monitor at Home Farm only work in one direction, Nicky, upstairs, hearing what is going on in the kitchen, when I thought the purpose of it was to hear, if the baby, upstairs, was crying, while people, downstairs, were in the kitchen?

Dennis tanner
13-04-2023, 15:34
Paddy buying a new washing machine when the old one might just need a new door seal?

How does he earn a living these days ?

Son of Cain
13-04-2023, 16:38
How does he earn a living these days ?

Rhona does not seem to do much work either, so are there no sick animals in Emmerdale at the moment.

Dennis tanner
13-04-2023, 19:21
Rhona does not seem to do much work either, so are there no sick animals in Emmerdale at the moment.

If there are any, they would go to a proper place in Hotton if they had any sense

lizann
13-04-2023, 19:27
Paddy buying a new washing machine when the old one might just need a new door seal?

ryan and charity as owners should be responsible

Dennis tanner
13-04-2023, 23:16
Mandy employs an assistant when she has few customers

The one customer she does have is very unhappy with her

Amelia gets past the non existent receptionist and manages to get an immediate appointment with a doctor about a breast problem. She then acts shocked to hear that she is being refered to the breast clinic at the hospital.

Can we assume that the Rhona will now ask for the immediate destruction of the eggs ? I wont call her selfish because she has been badly advised by Mary and Marlon

lizann
14-04-2023, 01:17
was charity auditioning for rumpole of the bailey or an 80s rock band

Son of Cain
14-04-2023, 09:45
was charity auditioning for rumpole of the bailey or an 80s rock band

Was that Charity, I thought it was Brian May.

Dennis tanner
14-04-2023, 15:09
was charity auditioning for rumpole of the bailey or an 80s rock band

How did Chastity's daughter know there was a problem with the hair ?

Son of Cain
14-04-2023, 19:54
Brian May has left the building.

Dennis tanner
14-04-2023, 21:21
That Amelia is really annoying me. She claims she can do everything herself but she is always asking for help. She demand to se a doctor immediately but then moans about her treatment

Meanwhile there is a big fish in Home Farm lake with a hook in their mouth