Emmerdale - Current Episode Discussion - III

[Dennis tanner]

why did belle not ring sam or cain

She is no longer the Dingle genius she used to be.

That Ellis is as useless as his father is evil.

[Perdita]

She is no longer the Dingle genius she used to be.

That Ellis is as useless as his father is evil.

You would have thought he would have called Belle as soon as he left Priya to make sure she and Kyle were ok... cannot stand Al...

[Son of Cain]

why did belle not ring sam or cain

Did she not try to ring Cain when her phone ran out of battery?

[Snagglepus]

Knocking on the window wanting help while fireworks are going off... why didn't she smash it, it would have been more noticable.

[lizann]

Did she not try to ring Cain when her phone ran out of battery?

only ellis i think

[Dennis tanner]

only ellis i think

AKA Mr Useless.

[lizann]

so poor this festive season

[Dennis tanner]

Why didn't Paddy explain to Vanessa that he no longer had the work for himself let alone two of them.

[lizann]

Why didn't Paddy explain to Vanessa that he no longer had the work for himself let alone two of them.

does vanessa still own some?

[Son of Cain]

only ellis i think

She did try to call Cain imediately after calling Ellis, but unless you have Audio Description switched on, you probably would not know, as they only showed a very brief shot of her phone, hardly long enough to read the screen.

[lizann]

id ring everyone till someone answered

[Son of Cain]

id ring everyone till someone answered

I forgot to mention her phone ran out of battery when she tried to phone Cain.
I am surprised Kyle did not have a phone she could have used, most kids nowadays have one.

I would have went back to the fire to see if there were still any embers she could have used to get it going again.

Considering none of the characters have been dressing for the cold, many walking about with open neck shirts, and not a sign of frost anywhere, I am surprized it was cold enough to render them close to death.

[Dennis tanner]

I forgot to mention her phone ran out of battery when she tried to phone Cain.
I am surprised Kyle did not have a phone she could have used, most kids nowadays have one.

I would have went back to the fire to see if there were still any embers she could have used to get it going again.

Considering none of the characters have been dressing for the cold, many walking about with open neck shirts, and not a sign of frost anywhere, I am surprized it was cold enough to render them close to death.

I am shocked that the camera crew didn't have a phone. Although Eliis was wrong to leave them and take the keys with him. She never bothered to ask him for the keys

[alan45]

I am shocked that the camera crew didn't have a phone. Although Eliis was wrong to leave them and take the keys with him. She never bothered to ask him for the keys

Or a charging cable in the car. Mine works even if the car is switched off

[Perdita]

Never thought I would say this but I have reached saturation point with Emmerdale's contrived and utterly ridiculous storylines and that is after watching for more years than I care to remember.. started to watch omnibus and had to switch channels .. :o:

[Son of Cain]

I am finding it difficult to take Priya's story seriously. I know that people really do have eating disorders, but I find this story lacking any sense of reality. She says she knows she needs to eat extra calories to help her healing, but we do not see hee her eating ANY calories. One mouthful of a protein shake and she is running to the sink to vomit. Her skin is still good and her hair is still shiny, she seems to exist on coffee only, by now she should be so weak she can hardly stand.

[Son of Cain]

In all the villages, in all of Yorshire, Nate and Fiona end up in the same room at New Year, how likely is that? I hope we are not meant to feel sorry for him, he is completely useless. I cannot help wondering what happened to the turkeys he was rearing for Christmas as he does not seem to have been on the farm for a long time. Why does he never move into the farm when Tracey throws him out. Sooner he leaves the village the better, and takes equally useless Ellis with him.

[Snagglepus]

The stone walling around the farms seems to fare better now than in the past, Matt Skilbeck was often to be found repairing them especially those up in Top Field, with Dolly traipsing up there with a sandwich and a flask of tea for his lunch. Is this down to Matt doing a good job on them or have they been left to rack and ruin now.
We don't see much of the workings on Moira's farm, does she have much livestock, who feeds it, who slaughters it, who butchers it and packs it, or does she only supply the Wooly and that will have come to a halt now. What does Rhona do?

[Dennis tanner]

The stone walling around the farms seems to fare better now than in the past, Matt Skilbeck was often to be found repairing them especially those up in Top Field, with Dolly traipsing up there with a sandwich and a flask of tea for his lunch. Is this down to Matt doing a good job on them or have they been left to rack and ruin now.
We don't see much of the workings on Moira's farm, does she have much livestock, who feeds it, who slaughters it, who butchers it and packs it, or does she only supply the Wooly and that will have come to a halt now. What does Rhona do?

They are meant to be a farming community but nobody has time to do any farming. They waste the preious hours of daylight in the winter faffing about in the village

[Son of Cain]

The stone walling around the farms seems to fare better now than in the past, Matt Skilbeck was often to be found repairing them especially those up in Top Field, with Dolly traipsing up there with a sandwich and a flask of tea for his lunch. Is this down to Matt doing a good job on them or have they been left to rack and ruin now.
We don't see much of the workings on Moira's farm, does she have much livestock, who feeds it, who slaughters it, who butchers it and packs it, or does she only supply the Wooly and that will have come to a halt now. What does Rhona do?

Perhaps the last time Matt repaired them he used cement. Moira did occasionally have trouble with fences breaking and letting stock out, but not for a while now.

Moira used to spend a lot of time chasing contracts, but not so much recently, the farm seems to look after itself. Matty seems too busy at The Hop to help. Perhaps Pixies and Elves come out at night and do what needs to be done. I think Rhona withdrew from being active on the farm, altho' I think she still acts as it's vet. I cannot remember if she sold her shares and if so, who to. Perhaps she is just a silent partner now. They tell us farming is hard work, but not if Moira and Nate are typical examples of farming life.

[lizann]

i think nate gave his farm back to kim now he works with moira

[Dennis tanner]

i think nate gave his farm back to kim now he works with moira

That's the theory but he still spends all his time in the village

[Son of Cain]

I have just realized that altho' most of the characters have jobs we rarely see them doing them, unless they work in the pub or the cafe. They have mostly become one dimensional, in that stories concentrate on their love lives.

[lizann]

cain should be mad at al and belle too, belle is chasing ellis

[Dennis tanner]

cain should be mad at al and belle too, belle is chasing ellis

and she forgot to ask Ellis for the keys before he left them.

Cain is right about that big useless lump. He is nate to be trusted.

Did Meena still all that stuff from the shop? Liam is so gullible but where Meena is concerned they are all gullinble

[Son of Cain]

Well, now Ellis will have a chance to practise his survival skills for real. I am sure he will soon get a fire going by rubbing two sticks together, and make a pair of sandals from tree bark..

[Snagglepus]

Meena is not ill, she is a boring character with stupid voices to match Steve MacDonald.

[Dennis tanner]

cain should be mad at al and belle too, belle is chasing ellis

Belle chasing Ellis is pathetic. He's the one who deliberately abandoned her for another woman.

[lizann]

cain went too far with ellis

rishi doing more than the police about missing manpreet

[lizann]

vanessa is annoying

[Dennis tanner]

cain went too far with ellis I agree. He should have been left with a compass.


rishi doing more than the police about missing manpreet Very disappointed with Mike Swirling and his new partner who appears to have rejoined the police without even a refresher course. When someone is missing the first place you search is their home address.

[alan45]

Amazed that Meenie is so worried about the village residents hearing Manpreet yet shouts and rants at her in a maniacal voice that could be heard in Hotten.

Thank God the end is near for this pile of poo storyline.

[Snagglepus]

How come Chloe has not been in David's shop lately, she was often to be seen in there talking to Jacob much to the envy of Noah. Jacob may have been interested in the ring she is wearing... but no, the story needs to be dragged out a bit longer.

[lizann]

How come Ellis has got off Scot Free with the Survival Challenge disaster, after all he was the one that organized it?

priya and ellis organised but ben getting all the blame

[Dennis tanner]

priya and ellis organised but ben getting all the blame

Organised by Priya and Ellis and they supervised it from inside their tent.

[Snagglepus]

No one noticed the (filled in ?) screw holes on the bedroom door...

[Son of Cain]

Organised by Priya and Ellis and they supervised it from inside their tent.

I am a bit confused about Ellis and Priya's relationship with The HOP. They were not employed by The HOP, were they? Were they just hiring the use of the land? Was Ben sub contracted to Ellis and Priya? If that is the case I am puzzled why they were not investigated, and why The HOP seems to have been wholly held responsible, when they were not really involved with the organization or the running of the event. .

[Snagglepus]

Are we to take it that she has done for Manpreet now?

[Son of Cain]

priya and ellis organised but ben getting all the blame

My post that you replied to here, seems to have disappeared. I cannot see my original post, so am puzzled how you were able to quote it, when it does not seem to exist now.

[Snagglepus]

My post that you replied to here, seems to have disappeared. I cannot see my original post, so am puzzled how you were able to quote it, when it does not seem to exist now.
Did you repost it here after posting it on the Corrie thread?

[Son of Cain]

No one noticed the (filled in ?) screw holes on the bedroom door...

I was looking out for them, but they did not give us a close enough shot where we could see if Meena had painted over them. She is getting over confident now, altering Vinny's evidence board. Very contrived when he put it by the bin without noticing.

[Son of Cain]

Did you repost it here after posting it on the Corrie thread?

Silly me, I have done this before. I wish they could label them in large letters at the top of the page, so it is obvious which thread I am on.

How did you manage to reply to it here, is there a way of moving from one thread to another?

[lizann]

My post that you replied to here, seems to have disappeared. I cannot see my original post, so am puzzled how you were able to quote it, when it does not seem to exist now.

i copied from corrie thread replied here

[Dennis tanner]

No one noticed the (filled in ?) screw holes on the bedroom door...

Beat me to it !!!

Did Jacob ever comment on the ring being missing ?

Why did Noah give the ring to Samson?

I cannot believe that Sam had never taken Samson poaching before.

Come on Liam , dig up that box full of fingerprints.

Does anyone now live in the vicar's accomodation that the church pays for ?

[lizann]

Beat me to it !!!

Did Jacob ever comment on the ring being missing ?

Why did Noah give the ring to Samson?

I cannot believe that Sam had never taken Samson poaching before.

Come on Liam , dig up that box full of fingerprints.

Does anyone now live in the vicar's accomodation that the church pays for ?

is that where laurel lives as harriet has edna's house, is ethan and charles in aaron and liv flat next to the house

[Dennis tanner]

is that where laurel lives as harriet has edna's house, is ethan and charles in aaron and liv flat next to the house

I thought that Liv owns a large house which she renovated. All done with her father's money

[Perdita]

I thought that Liv owns a large house which she renovated. All done with her father's money

Did Mandy and Vinny not move into the Mill when Liv went to prison?

[lizann]

Did Mandy and Vinny not move into the Mill when Liv went to prison?

chas paddy faith and bear there now as pub burnt down guess vinny mandy back in dingle land

[Dennis tanner]

chas paddy faith and bear there now as pub burnt down guess vinny mandy back in dingle land

They believe her to be guilty but are happy to squat in her house.

[Snagglepus]

How did Meena spot Vinnie following her, what gave it away?

[lizann]

How did Meena spot Vinnie following her, what gave it away?

the dingle van, she wanted to lure vinny she wants to be caught

[Snagglepus]

the dingle van, she wanted to lure vinny she wants to be caught
Getaway.... it's not as if it stands out..

[Dennis tanner]

Vinny had no idea how to enter a barn and avoid being hit over the head. Proceed with caution and look everywhere you fool.

[Son of Cain]

i copied from corrie thread replied here

I do not seem to have access to any tools to copy and paste. How do you do this? On the odd occasion when I have managed to to so, it has been more luck than intention. If I keeping stabbing at the screen long enough, eventually it happens, but I do not seem to have any control over it.

[lizann]

I do not seem to have access to any tools to copy and paste. How do you do this? On the odd occasion when I have managed to to so, it has been more luck than intention. If I keeping stabbing at the screen long enough, eventually it happens, but I do not seem to have any control over it.

highlight copy cut paste

[Son of Cain]

highlight copy cut paste

Finally figured out how to do it. - Thanks for helping me with that.

[Son of Cain]

If Meena is going to kill Manpreet and Vinny, I wish she would just get on and do it, otherwise this story will go on for ever. While she is at it, can I ask that she adds Tracey, Vanessa and Nate to her list.

[Dennis tanner]

If Meena is going to kill Manpreet and Vinny, I wish she would just get on and do it, otherwise this story will go on for ever. While she is at it, can I ask that she adds Tracey, Vanessa and Nate to her list.

I would be happy to give Vanessa another chance but Tracey is just moan moan moan.

The lad playing Vinny is demonstrating how poor an actor he is

[alan45]

If Meena is going to kill Manpreet and Vinny, I wish she would just get on and do it, otherwise this story will go on for ever. While she is at it, can I ask that she adds Tracey, Vanessa and Nate to her list.


I would be happy to give Vanessa another chance but Tracey is just moan moan moan.

The lad playing Vinny is demonstrating how poor an actor he is

And bloody wannabe gansta AL

[lizann]

I would be happy to give Vanessa another chance but Tracey is just moan moan moan.

The lad playing Vinny is demonstrating how poor an actor he is

vanessa can do one for me, leave for good

[Dennis tanner]

vanessa can do one for me, leave for good

Personally, I have bigger fish to fry when it comes to getting rid of people .

[Son of Cain]

I seriously question that anyone, never mind someone who been drugged for a week and probably not eaten during that time, could ever cut through a cable tie, by rubbing it against a key, while their hands were tied behind their back. I find it hard enough to cut them with a knife when my hands are free.
Why is it that "Goodies" always stop hitting "Baddies" after landing a blow on them instead of finishing them off. If Manpreet had hit Meena over the head with that bit of wood instead of searching for the keys, this story would be over now.

[lizann]

did meena steal her supplies from the surgery clinic

[Son of Cain]

did meena steal her supplies from the surgery clinic

When she started to drug Manpreet, I think she ground up the sleeping tablets she got from Liam, dissolved them in water, the feed them to her in the syringe.

[Dennis tanner]

I seriously question that anyone, never mind someone who been drugged for a week and probably not eaten during that time, could ever cut through a cable tie, by rubbing it against a key, while their hands were tied behind their back. I find it hard enough to cut them with a knife when my hands are free.
Why is it that "Goodies" always stop hitting "Baddies" after landing a blow on them instead of finishing them off. If Manpreet had hit Meena over the head with that bit of wood instead of searching for the keys, this story would be over now.

On the other hand, Priya hasn't eaten for weeks and she looks like she's fit as a fiddle

[lizann]

When she started to drug Manpreet, I think she ground up the sleeping tablets she got from Liam, dissolved them in water, the feed them to her in the syringe.

wendy or whomever stock takes must not be counting

[alan45]

Im surprised this whole storyline is been shown pre watershed

[Son of Cain]

Meena is behaving like an amateur now. Why delay finishing off Manpreet and Vinny to wait until Billy arrives. She should have left the motor running and added Billy later. She should have sent out invitations to the whole village and did them all in.

[Son of Cain]

Very low of Nate to undermine Tracey like that.

[Snagglepus]

Is Priya taking her client to the same barn? She has already left so will get there before Billy.

[lizann]

Meena is behaving like an amateur now. Why delay finishing off Manpreet and Vinny to wait until Billy arrives. She should have left the motor running and added Billy later. She should have sent out invitations to the whole village and did them all in.

they will all be in the barn soon the way the writing is going

[Dennis tanner]

Meena is behaving like an amateur now. Why delay finishing off Manpreet and Vinny to wait until Billy arrives. She should have left the motor running and added Billy later. She should have sent out invitations to the whole village and did them all in.

A bit unrealistic of Billy to not say where he was going.

Cancel that. I forgot that he's a bit dim

[Dennis tanner]

Very low of Nate to undermine Tracey like that.

I have said this many times. He's nate to be trusted

[lizann]

go away again vanessa

meena survives now is scotland's problem

[Dennis tanner]

go away again vanessa

meena survives now is scotland's problem

The Meena situation is totally unsatisfactory. You should have tied her up Liam.!!!!!!!!

I cannot believe that the unqualified Tracey was offered a good job. *

Nate has never got to work. He always has time to get is hair cut. *

* Get rid of them both.

[lizann]

how could manpreet stand let alone go off on her own looking for meena

[Son of Cain]

go away again vanessa

meena survives now is scotland's problem

Vanessa is behaving like a spoilt child.

Seems to me, it is a pity that Scotland has not gone independent, and established border control, to keep people like Meena out.

[Son of Cain]

I wish they could use a little more imagination here. As expected when Rushi heard Manpreet had been run down, he imediately made threats against the driver, because it always seems to be assumed they did it on purpose, and must therefore be to blame. Just as Charles was about to admit it was him who hit Manpreet he was interrupted and then decided to stay silent. At least they did not drag it out too long before he told Rushi.

Vinny obviously never watches TV programmes like "24 Hours in Police Custody" or he would know they would not release Liv without concrete proof.

I was really hoping that Tracey would turn to Nate at the last minute and ask him to come with her. So looks like we are stuck with him a while longer.

[Dennis tanner]

I was really hoping that Tracey would turn to Nate at the last minute and ask him to come with her. So looks like we are stuck with him a while longer.

I guess it was too much to hope for.

Liam needs to get a grip again .

Manpreet will either be dead or back at work in the middle of next week

[lizann]

billy should be trying to see what ben saw that made meena kill him, has billy cottoned on that meena heard their call

[Dennis tanner]

billy should be trying to see what ben saw that made meena kill him, has billy cottoned on that meena heard their call

It would never occur to Billy that Mad Meena was a bit dodgy.

[Son of Cain]

Mandy telling Vinny to phone Liv? - Can you phone someone in prison? - And before anyone says, Harvey in Corrie .................

[Perdita]

Mandy telling Vinny to phone Liv? - Can you phone someone in prison? - And before anyone says, Harvey in Corrie .................

Liv has been on the phone in the hallway a few times, maybe the prisoners can receive calls there?

[lizann]

vinny the only one helping believing liv and she angry at him

[Son of Cain]

Liv has been on the phone in the hallway a few times, maybe the prisoners can receive calls there?

Don't think so, prisoners can phone out, but I do not think you can phone in. I believe there is a prison voicemail service, where you can leave a message, for a prisoner, but this is not a two way conversation.

[Dennis tanner]

vinny the only one helping believing liv and she angry at him

She's also angry with the only inmate who helped her and look how well that worked out.

I will never forgive Meena for not killing Mandy Dingle.

Lots of lies and secrets. Standard soap fayre

[Perdita]

vinny the only one helping believing liv and she angry at him

Fed up with her attitude...

[Dennis tanner]

The NHS situation in Emmerdale.

One doctor in extensive care

One doctor awol plotting murder

One nurse on the run

Unqualified nurse in charge

[flappinfanny]

I love the bromance between Cain and Liam, it shouldn't work, but it does.

[Dennis tanner]

I love the bromance between Cain and Liam, it shouldn't work, but it does.

I love it as well

[Son of Cain]

I do not understand how everyone thinks that Meena will come back to the village. Why would she?

I know Liam is hurting over Leanne's death, but I do not believe he would think that killing Meena would be a good thing to do.

[Son of Cain]

Why are they writing so many of the characters in such an unsympathetic ways?

I think we are meant to feel sorry for Liv, but honestly I feel no sympathy for her at all. Likewise, Vinny, Billy, Dawn, Will, Jai and Liam.

So they are not paying out on the insurance for the pub, but not for the reason they should be withholding the payment. I cannot understand how they missed the evidence that the fire was not an accident.

[Perdita]

Why are they writing so many of the characters in such an unsympathetic ways?

I think we are meant to feel sorry for Liv, but honestly I feel no sympathy for her at all. Likewise, Vinny, Billy, Dawn, Will, Jai and Liam.

So they are not paying out on the insurance for the pub, but not for the reason they should be withholding the payment. I cannot understand how they missed the evidence that the fire was not an accident.

Sure does not seem t reflect real life and also a bit too quick for a result as to how the fire started? .. Like the evidence that would be there ..

[lizann]

mandy organising a hospital prison break

[Dennis tanner]

Why are they writing so many of the characters in such an unsympathetic ways?

I think we are meant to feel sorry for Liv, but honestly I feel no sympathy for her at all. Likewise, Vinny, Billy, Dawn, Will, Jai and Liam.

So they are not paying out on the insurance for the pub, but not for the reason they should be withholding the payment. I cannot understand how they missed the evidence that the fire was not an accident.

The real situation is that the pub had 3 owners and only one of them wanted to demolish the pub to build other properties, The two are being punished for the actions of the third.

Meanwhile Mel has gone in front of the governor who has accepted her explanation of self defence.

Liv should not be moaning at Vinny. She should be talking to her solicitor.

Is Vinny positive that he did not hear Meena confess ???????????????

[lizann]

is mel liv's cellmate her attacker, home brew maker?

[Perdita]

is mel liv's cellmate her attacker, home brew maker?

Think so, as she shut the cell door ..

[Perdita]

I do not understand how everyone thinks that Meena will come back to the village. Why would she?

I know Liam is hurting over Leanne's death, but I do not believe he would think that killing Meena would be a good thing to do.

To finish what she started ... she sees Billy and Dawn planning to get married and she does not like that so probably going after both :ninja:

[lizann]

what mack helping cain and chas, having a brew with cain

[Son of Cain]

I await with bated breathe to see where this story of tampering with the brakes on Ali's car is going. Is the intention to cause him to crash and possibly be killed or is it just meant to serve as a warning? If it is meant to cause him to crash, first problem is, altho' I think it used to be possible to open a car bonnet from the outside, without releasing the catch inside first, I do not think it is possible in modern cars without a great deal of difficulty. Second problem is, the car is parked nose in, so will need to reverse out before starting on it's way. Presumably after reversing, relatively slowly, the brakes will be applied and it will immediately be obvious they are not working, without causing any major damage.

[Son of Cain]

is mel liv's cellmate her attacker, home brew maker?

Don't think she made the home brew. Think she got that from another inmate.

[Son of Cain]

To finish what she started ... she sees Billy and Dawn planning to get married and she does not like that so probably going after both :ninja:

Surely even she is not that stupid, now that she has been found out. She seemed to forget about her vendetta against David and Victoria quickl enough when she moved on to Billy. Probably engaged to the truck driver who gave her a lift by now.

[lizann]

Surely even she is not that stupid, now that she has been found out. She seemed to forget about her vendetta against David and Victoria quickl enough when she moved on to Billy. Probably engaged to the truck driver who gave her a lift by now.

them in austraila new zealand ruined that (written out temporary)

[Dennis tanner]

Surely even she is not that stupid, now that she has been found out. She seemed to forget about her vendetta against David and Victoria quickl enough when she moved on to Billy. Probably engaged to the truck driver who gave her a lift by now.

She may not be stupid be she is vain and reckless

[Perdita]

them in austraila new zealand ruined that (written out temporary)

Portugal?? David and Victoria??

[lizann]

Portugal?? David and Victoria??

i thought with diane, is she in portugal?

[Perdita]

i thought with diane, is she in portugal?

Pretty sure they went to Portugal to see Diane, Diane went to Portugal

[Son of Cain]

Did Al cut his own brakes?

[Dennis tanner]

Did Al cut his own brakes?

He was desperate enough. Chastity will believe any lies than Al tells her.

[alan45]

Did Al cut his own brakes?


He was desperate enough. Chastity will believe any lies than Al tells her.

So good to see Al getting his comeuppance. Obviously Ellis leaving Emmerdale could be used as Gavin's revenge. No doubt Cain will come good in Chas' eyes. Maybe he buys the Woolie in the upcoming auction although Kim is possibly the only one with enough dosh.

[Dennis tanner]

Manpreet does not seem anxious to clear young Olivia.

If Charity adopted Johnny, she has the same rights to him as Vanessa. If Vanessa didn't adopt him as well, Charity is the only one with legal rights.

[Snagglepus]

Shouldn't Paddy be taking some of the blame over the Woolpack, it was his stupidity that enabled Al to get involved.

[Dennis tanner]

Shouldn't Paddy be taking some of the blame over the Woolpack, it was his stupidity that enabled Al to get involved.

His stupidity and the fact that they never seemed to have any customers even though they were rarely locked down unlike the rest of the country.

Chastity knows that Bad Al is a wrong un who cannot be trusted but she and Marlon immediately believe that it was Cain who ruined their deal.

[lizann]

Manpreet does not seem anxious to clear young Olivia.

If Charity adopted Johnny, she has the same rights to him as Vanessa. If Vanessa didn't adopt him as well, Charity is the only one with legal rights.

why would vanessa adopt her birth son, do you mean vanessa adopt moses

[Dennis tanner]

why would vanessa adopt her birth son, do you mean vanessa adopt moses

When a child is adopted, the birth mother no longer as parental rights. That's why they would both need to adopt him.

[lizann]

When a child is adopted, the birth mother no longer as parental rights. That's why they would both need to adopt him.

even when it's their partner adopting?

[Dennis tanner]

even when it's their partner adopting?

Yes.

[lizann]

ryan and mack should just have told charity about irene

[Dennis tanner]

ryan and mack should just Meanwhileold charity about irene

Totally agree.

Cain should also have told everyone the truth about about his meeting with Gavin. For some rason he chooses not to.

Meanwhile, it's a good job nobody needs a vicar as he's full time in hospital trying to obstruct the police. It's a good job that nobody in the community needs a vet because they are off duty playing games.

Olivia needs to sack Vinny ( another one who is calling himself Dingle) and get a solicitor. There are surely grounds for an appeal.

[Son of Cain]

ryan and mack should just have told charity about irene

Another example of the over used Soap trope, where one character tries to tell another something, but they are not allowed to get a word in.

Now we have to look forward to Charity feeling bad when she finally learns about Irene.

[Son of Cain]

Surely now that Meena has spoken to the police, the CPS would have doubts about proceeding with charges against Liv. Even if they still thought that Liv was responsible for murdering Ben, they would realize that Meena's testimony would be enough to put doubt in the minds of the jurors and that it is unlikely they would get a guilty verdict on her. I would have thought that at least Liv would be released on bail while they try to find more evidence against her, then Vinny could stop running around over acting and telling everyone she didn't do it.

[lizann]

yes liv should be out on bail at least while still investigating

[Dennis tanner]

Surely now that Meena has spoken to the police, the CPS would have doubts about proceeding with charges against Liv. Even if they still thought that Liv was responsible for murdering Ben, they would realize that Meena's testimony would be enough to put doubt in the minds of the jurors and that it is unlikely they would get a guilty verdict on her. I would have thought that at least Liv would be released on bail while they try to find more evidence against her, then Vinny could stop running around over acting and telling everyone she didn't do it.

Liv has already faced a jury and has been found guilty. The murder was counted as detected as soon as Liv was charged.

It's no longer a decision for the Police. It's up to Liv's solicitors ( I assume she has one as we never see them) to launch an appeal.

[lizann]

Liv has already faced a jury and has been found guilty. The murder was counted as detected as soon as Liv was charged.

It's no longer a decision for the Police. It's up to Liv's solicitors ( I assume she has one as we never see them) to launch an appeal.

she could afford good solicitors if her squatters paid rent

[Dennis tanner]

she could afford good solicitors if her squatters paid rent

Very true but you can still get legal aid for serious cases.

[Son of Cain]

Liv has already faced a jury and has been found guilty. The murder was counted as detected as soon as Liv was charged.

It's no longer a decision for the Police. It's up to Liv's solicitors ( I assume she has one as we never see them) to launch an appeal.

I must have blinked and missed that bit. - I thought she was still on remand. - Did she plead guilty? - Soap justice is super quick.

[Dennis tanner]

I must have blinked and missed that bit. - I thought she was still on remand. - Did she plead guilty? - Soap justice is super quick.

I am now doubting myself. I was sure there had been a trial.

[Perdita]

I am now doubting myself. I was sure there had been a trial.

I do not remember a trial .. I think she is charged with murder but still on remand .. ?

[lizann]

yes i don't remember a trial either yet

[Son of Cain]

I do not remember a trial .. I think she is charged with murder but still on remand .. ?

Shows how riveting this story had been when some of us are not sure if Liv has been on trial or not.

[lizann]

afair liv herself doubted her own innocence as too drunk

belle and ellis should go to the cricket pavilion

[Dennis tanner]

Shows how riveting this story had been when some of us are not sure if Liv has been on trial or not.

It's not some of us. I think it's just me......eek

[Perdita]

I wonder if Ryan's brother Josh will be introduced to Emmerdale soon ..:hmm:

[Dennis tanner]

I wonder if Ryan's brother Josh will be introduced to Emmerdale soon ..:hmm:

I will then be able to say, "Gosh, it's Josh"

[Son of Cain]

belle and ellis should go to the cricket pavilion

Looks like Belle and Ellis took your advice.

[Son of Cain]

Anyone else wonder if the "new evidence" the police have found, could be evidence "against" Liv.

If so, we can look forward to more of Vinny's histionics.

[Son of Cain]

Bored with Mack and Charity's story, could not care less if they get back together or not. Wish Meena had killed one or both of them.

[lizann]

Anyone else wonder if the "new evidence" the police have found, could be evidence "against" Liv.

If so, we can look forward to more of Vinny's histionics.

the oar that killed ben, could free liv

[Dennis tanner]

If Liv is released where can she live? Will the Dingles have room for her in her house ?

[Perdita]

the oar that killed ben, could free liv

Sure Meena wore black gloves so doubt there are her fingerprints on it

[lizann]

If Liv is released where can she live? Will the Dingles have room for her in her house ?

she should be able to live in her house

[Perdita]

she should be able to live in her house
which seems to have been taken over ... not sure there is room .. of course. there will be .. soapland ..:angel:

[Dennis tanner]

Can someone remind me why Ryan needed to make such a big deal about forgiving Charity. Did he blame her for the fact that he couldn't be bothered to respond to messages from his mom.?

[Snagglepus]

Will the villagers have learned a lesson to lock their doors when they go out and not leave a key under the doormat.

[lizann]

bald david back who wasn't missed

shut up priya at manpreet

[Dennis tanner]

bald david back who wasn't missed

shut up priya at manpreet

Priya was entitled. She is the woman who married her dad to pay off her debts and has now dumped him. She is the woman who employed her mad sister when nobody else was daft enough to give her a job.

As for Charles. I don't like him and I don't like his attitude.

[alan45]

Priya was entitled. She is the woman who married her dad to pay off her debts and has now dumped him. She is the woman who employed her mad sister when nobody else was daft enough to give her a job.

As for Charles. I don't like him and I don't like his attitude.

Priya seems to have forgotten that Manpreet suffered at the hands of Meena too

[lizann]

Priya was entitled. She is the woman who married her dad to pay off her debts and has now dumped him. She is the woman who employed her mad sister when nobody else was daft enough to give her a job.
As for Charles. I don't like him and I don't like his attitude.

rishi can be mad but jai has to pay a huge fine for priyas event which she didn't over see ss too busy with ellis, manpreet suffered too and didn't want meena around from the start

[Dennis tanner]

rishi can be mad but jai has to pay a huge fine for priyas event which she didn't over see ss too busy with ellis, manpreet suffered too and didn't want meena around from the start

Priya and Ellis. The organisers have been written out of it.

If she didn't want Meena around, she should have got rid of her

[lizann]

Priya and Ellis. The organisers have been written out of it.

If she didn't want Meena around, she should have got rid of her

they should pay the fine

[Son of Cain]

I read somewhere that that Danny Millar left the cast of Emmerdale pernemently, to participate in "I'm a Celebrity", so I do not suppose we will being seeing Aaron returning, unless they recast him, which I hope they do not. It must be a relief not to have to play such a miserable depressing character again.

[Son of Cain]

Priya and Ellis. The organisers have been written out of it.

If she didn't want Meena around, she should have got rid of her

I think one murderer in the village is enough.

[lizann]

aaron could at least ring liv to check in now she out innocent cleared

[Dennis tanner]

aaron could at least ring liv to check in now she out innocent cleared

How could he do that if the actor is not in the show any more ?

[lizann]

How could he do that if the actor is not in the show any more ?

a telephone call mention no need of the actor

[Dennis tanner]

a telephone call mention no need of the actor

But Chastity said that she had spoken to Aaron ????

I am beginning to think that there wasn't an actual call.

[Dennis tanner]

If Pierce really wanted his son traced, wouldn't he give the job to someone who liked him, rather than one of his victims ?

[lizann]

If Pierce really wanted his son traced, wouldn't he give the job to someone who liked him, rather than one of his victims ?

his mother or hire a p i

[Son of Cain]

What Liam should have told Princess Priya was that she was largely to blame for the fiasco that was the "Survival Challenge". If she and Ellis had not been hiding away in a tent canoodling (love that word) the day might have passed without incident. Everything went wrong from the rope bridge, if one or both of them had been on duty there, then everything else could have been avoided. Cannot remember if anyone has confroned them about that day or if they feel in any way responsible for it.

[Dennis tanner]

What Liam should have told Princess Priya was that she was largely to blame for the fiasco that was the "Survival Challenge". If she and Ellis had not been hiding away in a tent canoodling (love that word) the day might have passed without incident. Everything went wrong from the rope bridge, if one or both of them had been on duty there, then everything else could have been avoided. Cannot remember if anyone has confroned them about that day or if they feel in any way responsible for it.

Perhaps Jai can only blame them if he also blames his sister. Or they just don't know the fuill details of their neglect. In fact people have told Eliis, " You are not to blame"

[Son of Cain]

Perhaps Jai can only blame them if he also blames his sister. Or they just don't know the fuill details of their neglect. In fact people have told Eliis, " You are not to blame"

Does not say much for the thoroughness of the Health and Safety investigation if the organizers, Ellis and Priya, were not asked where they were, while everything was "going to hell in a handcart". I do not think "Bill(ly) and Ben" even asked them.

[Dennis tanner]

Does not say much for the thoroughness of the Health and Safety investigation if the organizers, Ellis and Priya, were not asked where they were, while everything was "going to hell in a handcart". I do not think "Bill(ly) and Ben" even asked them.

I would have expected Kim to have done something other than just pay out.

[lizann]

What Liam should have told Princess Priya was that she was largely to blame for the fiasco that was the "Survival Challenge". If she and Ellis had not been hiding away in a tent canoodling (love that word) the day might have passed without incident. Everything went wrong from the rope bridge, if one or both of them had been on duty there, then everything else could have been avoided. Cannot remember if anyone has confroned them about that day or if they feel in any way responsible for it.

jai and kim in hop are blamed ben was blamed ellis i think was guilty remorseful priya was not

[Son of Cain]

Well, you certainly bore me Will, with you're terribly gags

[Dennis tanner]

jai and kim in hop are blamed ben was blamed ellis i think was guilty remorseful priya was not

How was Priya remorseful ?

Does Ryan have a job? As he ever had a job ?

[lizann]

How was Priya remorseful ?

Does Ryan have a job? As he ever had a job ?

afair ellis was guilty and remorseful, priya was not

ryan was working for kim and jai in web marketing web design IT etc.,

[Dennis tanner]

afair ellis was guilty and remorseful, priya was not

ryan was working for kim and jai in web marketing web design IT etc.,

Not remorseful enough to tell the truth to the enquiry though

[lizann]

Not remorseful enough to tell the truth to the enquiry though

yes ellis and priya gave no statements while ben did, billy not also

[Dennis tanner]

I have forgotten how Chastity had the money to buy the pub.

[lizann]

I have forgotten how Chastity had the money to buy the pub.

chas debut was as a stripper for ashley

did chas get money from carl king?

[Son of Cain]

I have forgotten how Chastity had the money to buy the pub.

Have I missed where Chastity bought the pub? I did not realize they had held the auction already. I must pay more attention.

Ignore above - I am mixing up Chastity and Charity.

[Dennis tanner]

Marcus....Is this just a cunning plan oo get Rhona to go and visit Pierce ?

[Son of Cain]

Love how Faith, a seasoned drinker, gets so drunk she falls asleep after drinking the contents of a hip flask (which was probably not full to start with), but Liv, a teenager, can drink whole bottles of Vodka, without too much effect.

[Dennis tanner]

Marcus....Is this just a cunning plan oo get Rhona to go and visit Pierce ?

No. However I am still confused as to why Marcus refers to Pierce as his Dad. 'Dad' is a term of endearment.

So Kim is still not paid for the Haulage company and Charity still doesn't have the money for the pub ?????

[Ruffed_lemur]

No. However I am still confused as to why Marcus refers to Pierce as his Dad. 'Dad' is a term of endearment.

So Kim is still not paid for the Haulage company and Charity still doesn't have the money for the pub ?????

Some people just don't use the word 'Father'.

[Dennis tanner]

Some people just don't use the word 'Father'.

Darth Vader does and that's good enough for me .

[lizann]

marcus looks old

ellis off to australia, fast no visa issues

[Dennis tanner]

marcus looks old

ellis off to australia, fast no visa issues

I'm not complaining.

[flappinfanny]

marcus looks old

ellis off to australia, fast no visa issues I think David and Victoria may have helped. :D

[Son of Cain]

ellis off to australia, fast no visa issues

Good job he is not a Serbian Tennis player. - As I understand it, It's quite difficult to move to Australa at the best of times, never mind during Covid. They operate a points system, I am not sure Ellis would qualify for entry, I think there would be plenty of Australian Nationals with the same or more skills than him. He should be asking himself, if it is wise to go all that way to work or a company that is so disorganised that it does not have staff in place a week before it opens.

[Snagglepus]

Now that Pierce has died is there a point to Marcus or was that just to introduce a new character?
Are there any spare women in Emmerdale, or, now that Aaron and Ben have gone there are no homosexuals in the village other than Ethan who is hardly featured, could Marcus be a new man for him to give him a role, otherwise he is pointless too.

[Dennis tanner]

Good job he is not a Serbian Tennis player. - As I understand it, It's quite difficult to move to Australa at the best of times, never mind during Covid. They operate a points system, I am not sure Ellis would qualify for entry, I think there would be plenty of Australian Nationals with the same or more skills than him. He should be asking himself, if it is wise to go all that way to work or a company that is so disorganised that it does not have staff in place a week before it opens.

Ellis looks like he needs a fitness instructor.

[Perdita]

I do not understand why he did not join his mother in Dubai?

[Dennis tanner]

Why would Jai be homeless? He could live in the house he half owns.

Rishi's divorce. Who divorced who. If Manpreet divorced him, what were the grounds ?

[lizann]

jai cannot sell his own house or mortgage that

gabby cannot buy the vicarage house with her tate inheritance?

[Dennis tanner]

jai cannot sell his own house or mortgage that

gabby cannot buy the vicarage house with her tate inheritance?

What Tate inheritance ? Kim is still alive

[lizann]

What Tate inheritance ? Kim is still alive

didn't diane get gabby and thomas a third of kim's money, businesses etc., ?

[Son of Cain]

didn't diane get gabby and thomas a third of kim's money, businesses etc., ?

She did, but I think it was 20%.

[Son of Cain]

Is Priya trying to give Rishi a heart attack continuing to have a go at Jai by his bedside.

[lizann]

manpreet could at least visit rishi

[Dennis tanner]

manpreet could at least visit rishi

She is far too busy with the vicar who is far too busy to be doing any vicaring

[Dennis tanner]

Are Kerry and Amy too thick to realise they are being used.

She promised not to to leave Lyle alone with Al. Promise broken immediately.

How did humble non vicar Ashley Thomas accumulate so much money ?

[alan45]

How did humble non vicar Ashley Thomas accumulate so much money ?

He took Laurel's empties back to the Offy

[Dennis tanner]

He took Laurel's empties back to the Offy

It was a useful source of a bit of cash back in the day

[Dennis tanner]

It was totally wrong for the Police to say that Meena had left the country based on zero evidence.

Silly Billy.."She would be mad to come back here". Dawn..."She is mad". Got it in one Dawn

Yorkshire's most useless vet got the chance to play the buffoon.

Poor Jai. On this occasion he has got in trouble mainly due to the actions of others and one of them was his sister. The main offender has left for Australia without a care in the world.

[Ruffed_lemur]

How stupid not to call the police after a break-in and damage to Dawn's wedding dress! Dawn was going to, then Billy decides it was her ex and not Meena. Call them whoever it was! No, Billy goes off to sort it out himself. No wonder Meena hasn't been caught yet.

[Snagglepus]

Are there any empty properties in the village, Meena must be holed up somewhere. She still has to eat, sleep and go to the toilet and get tampons from somewhere and she must still be wearing the same knickers she left in a few weeks ago.

[alan45]

are there any empty properties in the village, meena must be holed up somewhere. She still has to eat, sleep and go to the toilet and get tampons from somewhere and she must still be wearing the same knickers she left in a few weeks ago.

tmi. :)

[Perdita]

Are there any empty properties in the village, Meena must be holed up somewhere. She still has to eat, sleep and go to the toilet and get tampons from somewhere and she must still be wearing the same knickers she left in a few weeks ago.

:lol:

[lizann]

Are there any empty properties in the village, Meena must be holed up somewhere. She still has to eat, sleep and go to the toilet and get tampons from somewhere and she must still be wearing the same knickers she left in a few weeks ago.

well mack had to wee in dawn's garden

[Dennis tanner]

Are there any empty properties in the village, Meena must be holed up somewhere. She still has to eat, sleep and go to the toilet and get tampons from somewhere and she must still be wearing the same knickers she left in a few weeks ago.

She has a cloak of invisibility

[Snagglepus]

Amateur dramatics from Meena....yawn...
All that was missing was the round of applause from the children at the school panto.
Looking forward to the end of it.

[lizann]

meena was with billy for about 2 weeks, why is she not after vic and david

al should leave with kerry and chloe, no need for them, ellis is gone

[Dennis tanner]

Daft Dialogue
Laurel to Arthur, " I have told Jai to leave PERMANENTLY
Arthur " Are you splitting up?
Laurel "Er Maybe
????????

Daft Plot.
Swirling to Mackenzie, " How did you get to the scene of this incident ?
Swirling to Billy " Was anyone with you who could have seen you defend yourself?"

It was not self defence. Billy chased after him.

If he really trashed your place, why has he involved the Police? Just think for once Billy.

[lizann]

village bike take village idiot - meena wanted both david and billy

[tammyy2j]

village bike take village idiot - meena wanted both david and billy

There is too many idiots in that village

[lizann]

meena affords a long white limo

[Snagglepus]

meena affords a long white limo

The fantasy gets worse by the episode.

[Son of Cain]

meena affords a long white limo

And a "Dirty Harry" type handgun ?

[Dennis tanner]

The whole village turn out for the big wedding.

Correction....There was nobody there who hadn't got a job or who was paid to be there. Do Leyla and Priya actually get paid for their contribution ?

The service was rather shambolic and I blame the vicar. Billy doesn't know how to wear a tie.

[Son of Cain]

When Meena left the village she only had the clothes she stood up in. I don't think she had a bag or even her phone. So no money to buy food, or even a clean pair of knickers. So how can she hire a limo or buy a gun, bearing in mind she would need underworld contacts and at least several hundred pounds for the gun. Did she actually go to Glasgow? Perhaps the truck driver gave her money?

[Snagglepus]

When Meena left the village she only had the clothes she stood up in. I don't think she had a bag or even her phone. So no money to buy food, or even a clean pair of knickers. So how can she hire a limo or buy a gun, bearing in mind she would need underworld contacts and at least several hundred pounds for the gun. Did she actually go to Glasgow? Perhaps the truck driver gave her money?

To make it easy for the writers we will never get to find out.

[lizann]

did will say kim was sick in bed?

[Perdita]

oh my ... Meena cannot do wrong, can she .. I hope she is not going to be killed off, I so want her to be crazy in a court trial ... cannot see Emmerdale doing that though :(

[Snagglepus]

Pathetic.
While she had her back to them shooting at Leyla Billy and Dawn could have overpowered her.
I was expecting her to kill them all and make her escape in a helicopter she had hidden behind the trees and fly to Australia.

[Son of Cain]

Pathetic.
While she had her back to them shooting at Leyla Billy and Dawn could have overpowered her.
I was expecting her to kill them all and make her escape in a helicopter she had hidden behind the trees and flew to Australia.

Exactly! - BILLY a personnel trainer, so fit and strong, all he had to do was punch her hard in the kidney that would have brought her to her knees immediately, not even the strongest man can withstand that. I just get the feeling that someone is going to end up going over The Viaduct, lets hope it is Meena, as that would bring this story to an end.

I do hope Leyla is not dead as I do not think I could stomach another grief stricken Liam scene.

At least we know now how Meena was able to acquire the limo, Leyla hired it for the wedding.

Just when I thought the pantomine season was over, Emmerdale has proved me wrong.

[lizann]

billy also an ex con who beat aaron inside

leyla will survive but probably can't have kids is my guess

[Dennis tanner]

Exactly! - BILLY a personnel trainer, so fit and strong, all he had to do was punch her hard in the kidney that would have brought her to her knees immediately, not even the strongest man can withstand that. I just get the feeling that someone is going to end up going over The Viaduct, lets hope it is Meena, as that would bring this story to an end.

I do hope Leyla is not dead as I do not think I could stomach another grief stricken Liam scene.

At least we know now how Meena was able to acquire the limo, Leyla hired it for the wedding.

Just when I thought the pantomine season was over, Emmerdale has proved me wrong.

Have they took control of the gun ?

Hiring that Limo was a total waste of money

It was all very daft and OTT.

[Son of Cain]

Have they took control of the gun ?

Hiring that Limo was a total waste of money

It was all very daft and OTT.

The gun was lying on the ground about, maybe, six feet away. Silly Billy was too busy trying to restrain Daft Dawn to think about picking it up. If they took their eyes off her, she could easily roll over and get hold of it again, and hopefully shoot the pair of them.

[alan45]

I want to know who is the body lying on the floor in the final scene - Harriet???

[lizann]

I want to know who is the body lying on the floor in the final scene - Harriet???

yes think harriet as will could not reach her by phone and had she lucas?

[Perdita]

So .. Meena dead in same spot where she killed Leanna? Lazy scriptwriting if that is how her terror ends... she really needed to be arrested and have a trial ...

[Snagglepus]

Major incident going on... emergency services in the village... all aware of Meena's doings....
Manpreet "I think I'll go for a walk to clear my head" WTF are these writers on???

[Son of Cain]

Major incident going on... emergency services in the village... all aware of Meena's doings....
Manpreet "I think I'll go for a walk to clear my head" WTF are these writers on???

The pantomine continues. - What Manpreet should have said "I think I will go for a walk and maybe lose my head" if Meena creeps up behind her with a great big axe. - Especially after Charles had said the three of them should stay together for safety.

Was Liam doing a impression of Spartacus with that fork? - Will Manpreet now say she was looking the other way, or that she saw Mapreet jump off the bridge?

[Son of Cain]

Surely Daft Dawn could have spared a few seconds to untie Silly Billy before dashing off, if only so he could go to Leyla's aid a little sooner.

[Dennis tanner]

Surely Daft Dawn could have spared a few seconds to untie Silly Billy before dashing off, if only so he could go to Leyla's aid a little sooner.

She couldn't even call an ambulance for Harriet untill she had questioned her.

It was rather daft. I hope that Mad Meena did not get a QUICK death but it wouldn't surprise me to see her body disappear.

[lizann]

i wanted manpreet to push meena on to the pitch fork

meena didn't want to visit david and vic

[alan45]

So .. Meena dead in same spot where she killed Leanna? Lazy scriptwriting if that is how her terror ends... she really needed to be arrested and have a trial ...

But is she dead?????

[alan45]

I just want to know how she managed to do a U turn on the viaduct in that huge limo.

[Perdita]

The pantomine continues. - What Manpreet should have said "I think I will go for a walk and maybe lose my head" if Meena creeps up behind her with a great big axe. - Especially after Charles had said the three of them should stay together for safety.

Was Liam doing a impression of Spartacus with that fork? - Will Manpreet now say she was looking the other way, or that she saw Mapreet jump off the bridge?

You mean did she see Meena jump off the bridge... will be interesting to see if Meena is still alive, she should not be able to move after that fall but this is soapland so anything is possible. I shall miss Meena once she is no longer terrorising the villagers :ninja:

[Son of Cain]

You mean did she see Meena jump off the bridge... will be interesting to see if Meena is still alive, she should not be able to move after that fall but this is soapland so anything is possible. I shall miss Meena once she is no longer terrorising the villagers :ninja:

I meant, if Manpreet did see Liam push Meena off the bridge, will she dob him in to the police, or will she cover for him, and say Meena jumped, or that she did not see what actually happened. As you say this is Soapland and they will want to drag this drama out for a while yet. Maybe Manpreet's "love" for her sister will override all the terrible things Meena has done and she WILL tell the police Liam "murdered" her.

[johntrevor]

When Meena left the village she only had the clothes she stood up in. I don't think she had a bag or even her phone. So no money to buy food, or even a clean pair of knickers. So how can she hire a limo or buy a gun, bearing in mind she would need underworld contacts and at least several hundred pounds for the gun. Did she actually go to Glasgow? Perhaps the truck driver gave her money?

She didn't hire the limo. The company that owns it told Leyla that the driver had been attacked and the limo stolen.

[Son of Cain]

She didn't hire the limo. The company that owns it told Leyla that the driver had been attacked and the limo stolen.

As I recognized in my post on Tuesday 15th when Leyla used the tracker to show the limo was on The Viaduct.

[johntrevor]

I shall miss Meena once she is no longer terrorising the villagers

Me too. And like you, I too hope she has a trial, so everyone can see her guilt, after that I don't care what happens to her.

[johntrevor]

"Billy thinks Leyla is dead or she's dying. Leyla also thinks she's dying. She calls out for them to tell Jacob and Liam that she loves them, but very luckily, the bullet has gone in and then taken a turn, so it actually hit Leyla's shoulder.

"She does go into surgery but given where the bullet enters, she's very lucky that it's as minor as it could be. She's just lucky to be alive, basically. They don't know what it is until they get her into surgery."

"Leyla loves revenge! I would love for Leyla to take revenge on Meena. I think it would be a brilliant showdown. She would like to, for sure."

[Snagglepus]

All through this Meena thing I have not been able to understand what it is about. I can not equate it to anything. It has been a nonsensical fantasy that will remain unexplained because there can be no explanation. Everyone in the village would have to have been stupid. The scriptwriters need to go back to writing children's pantomimes if this is the best they can come up with.
This did not happen in Sam Pearson's day.

[lizann]

meena taunted liam, he should be honest not a long cover up, we still have malone's one, maybe meena is still alive

[Perdita]

meena taunted liam, he should be honest not a long cover up, we still have malone's one, maybe meena is still alive

If she is dead, she is another evil person getting off lightly by being killed off.. typical for soapland villains... although I cannot help thinking she is still alive, despite the injuries she should have received after that fall... however I would not be surprised if suddenly she has managed to get up and walk away.. disappear and come back in October for the big anniversary ...

[Son of Cain]

Two doctors standing by while a detective does the CPR. Liam and Manpreet getting their stories straight, feet away from DS Rogers. Surprized we did not have a role reversal and Liam with all his "Murder Mystery" experience taking over the investigation.

Cain after drinking a bottle of vodka and part of a bottle of whiskey still seemed sober enough to go and see Kyle.

It becomes more realistic and believeable with every passing episode.

[alan45]

Two doctors standing by while a detective does the CPR. Liam and Manpreet getting their stories straight, feet away from DS Rogers.

Never have I witnessed such crap in any of the soaps. It turns out that she had a cracked rib while the untrained detective was giving her CPR. He could have killed her. There was no. reason at that time for the two medically qualified GPs not to attempt to save her life. The police had no reason to suspect them of any crime at that stage. Last night she had banged he head off a rock in the fall yet no head injuries and now a few soap hours later she is wide awake and able to tell the police what happened.

I need a drink before I watch the second episode of this farce.

[Son of Cain]

These police interview techniques are so dated. They simply do not adopt this aggresive approach now. Any minute now I expect to see Liam being hit on the side of the head with a telephone directory.

[lizann]

was meena arrested, i never heard her rights read like to liam

[Dennis tanner]

These police interview techniques are so dated. They simply do not adopt this aggresive approach now. Any minute now I expect to see Liam being hit on the side of the head with a telephone directory.

I would expect the Police to go through the motions but no more than that.

[Dennis tanner]

"Please marry me Liv. I would love to part own your nice big house and Mandy would love living here."

Kyle has lived with Cain for most of his life and I just don't believe he is suddenly scared of him.

Please stop asking stupid questions Charles.

[johntrevor]

Meena, Leyla and Harriet all rushed to Hotten General at deaths door,. After about 10 minutes they are all chatting away with either friends and relatives or the police. What an incredible medical team they must have. The envy of the world.

[mrfreeman]

It turns out that she had a cracked rib while the untrained detective was giving her CPR.

ribs usually break during CPR, its actually considered a sign that you're doing it right. and coppers usually have first responder training

[Perdita]

Two doctors standing by while a detective does the CPR. Liam and Manpreet getting their stories straight, feet away from DS Rogers. Surprized we did not have a role reversal and Liam with all his "Murder Mystery" experience taking over the investigation.

Cain after drinking a bottle of vodka and part of a bottle of whiskey still seemed sober enough to go and see Kyle.

It becomes more realistic and believeable with every passing episode.

More than fed up with Cain biting every time Al baits him ... and never took to Amy when she first appeared.. her constant screaching and interfering without knowing all the facts are not helping to endear her to me ... :nono:

[lizann]

Meena, Leyla and Harriet all rushed to Hotten General at deaths door,. After about 10 minutes they are all chatting away with either friends and relatives or the police. What an incredible medical team they must have. The envy of the world.

not forgetting shot gun david

[alan45]

ribs usually break during CPR, its actually considered a sign that you're doing it right. and coppers usually have first responder training

They may have first responder training but no policeman know would attempt CPR when there were 2 doctors present

[lizann]

cain the pink superhero