Emmerdale - Current Episode Discussion - III

[lizann]

oscar is older than i expected and mouthy

[Dennis tanner]

oscar is older than i expected and mouthy

But he did not have long hair and a cap worn back to front

[Son of Cain]

If you lease a car and it is stolen, would the insurance company pay out to you, or the leasing company who actually own the car?

[Son of Cain]

Not that I am excusing Charles's behavior, but Tom was rather asking for it, he really does need to learn when to shut up. The way he kept on talking when it was obvious that Charles angry and upset, maybe that is why he became a vet, as conversational skills are not needed.

[lizann]

Not that I am excusing Charles's behavior, but Tom was rather asking for it, he really does need to learn when to shut up. The way he kept on talking when it was obvious that Charles angry and upset, maybe that is why he became a vet, as conversational skills are not needed.

tom was like charles similar with jimmy

[Dennis tanner]

If you lease a car and it is stolen, would the insurance company pay out to you, or the leasing company who actually own the car?

I would imagine that the insurance money would get the pay out and the client would need to negotiate a new deal

[Dennis tanner]

Charles is a total disgrace.

Why was his mother fretting about choosing hymns? Who would be there to sing them ?

You lost your life, as thieves often do
But I could've told you,Victor
This world was never meant for
One as naughty as you

[Son of Cain]

I would imagine that the insurance money would get the pay out and the client would need to negotiate a new deal

Thinking about this again, I imagine if Tom was still paying his monthly fee, the leasing company would give him another car, yet Tom has not had a car since it was stolen. There would certainly be no money left over for a deposit on a house. This being written as if Tom owned the car. Major forget by the writers

[Dennis tanner]

Following Charles's confession, Victor has been promoted to saint.

[lizann]

tom worried caring for manpreet, potential romance, affair

[Dennis tanner]

Claudette was rude to Manpret who should have stayed at home.

The last relative had left. By the time Clarles retuned, Victor would have been at Hotton Crem on his way to hell

[lizann]

they didn't need to show victors funeral harriets wasnt

chas could have drank free in the pub she works in and who has the liquor licence in hop hive

[Son of Cain]

they didn't need to show victors funeral harriets wasnt

chas could have drank free in the pub she works in and who has the liquor licence in hop hive

Who HAS the liquor licence at the Hop? - Now that you have asked the question, I cannot not stop wondering who it is. Is it Gabby, Amy, Matty or Jai, for some strange reason I cannot think it is any of them. Could it be Victoria, did she have a licence, when she had her mobile food truck? - Will we ever know?

[lizann]

manpreet should kick out ungrateful claudette

no sympathy or pity for chas

[Dennis tanner]

manpreet should kick out ungrateful claudette

no sympathy or pity for chas

and Chas should kick out lazy scrounging Bear.

Kirk and Mandy ....They bounce of each other well but I loath them both.

[Snagglepus]

Chas should kick out lazy scrounging Bear.

I thought he was still living with Liam.

[Snagglepus]

The sun is always shining through the windows when they are going to bed for the night.

[Dennis tanner]

I thought he was still living with Liam.

Forgot about that. is he paying anything ?

[lizann]

and Chas should kick out lazy scrounging Bear.

Kirk and Mandy ....They bounce of each other well but I loath them both.

bear lives with paddy and liam

[Dennis tanner]

bear lives with paddy and liam

I thought that Kirk had moved in with Mandy ?

[Son of Cain]

and Chas should kick out lazy scrounging Bear.

Kirk and Mandy ....They bounce of each other well but I loath them both.

Normally I am a defender of Paddy but in this case he grossly over reacted. Eve may not even have noticed anything, and if she did, they could easily have said Simon/Harry was there for some business reason, and quickly moved the conversation on. It seems that Paddy was saying to Chas that if she is not with him, she cannot be with anyone else. Personally I was sorry to see Paddy and Mandy get together - just another verse of "musical romances".,

[Son of Cain]

I thought that Kirk had moved in with Mandy ?

Characters change dwellings so frequently here, that it seems we cannot keep up with them.

[lizann]

I thought that Kirk had moved in with Mandy ?

mandy and vinny live in dingle villa with sam and co

[Dennis tanner]

Normally I am a defender of Paddy but in this case he grossly over reacted. Eve may not even have noticed anything, and if she did, they could easily have said Simon/Harry was there for some business reason, and quickly moved the conversation on. It seems that Paddy was saying to Chas that if she is not with him, she cannot be with anyone else. Personally I was sorry to see Paddy and Mandy get together - just another verse of "musical romances"., I am also happy for them to be together. They would not to suitable to be with anyone else

[lizann]

liam shouldn't pay bob for mack and chloe

[Son of Cain]

liam shouldn't pay bob for mack and chloe

He will be a mug if he does. He certainly should not pay the service charge or leave a tip. Just wait till Bernice finds out.

[Son of Cain]

I thought that Kirk had moved in with Mandy ?

When Paddy and Mandy brought Eve back to Chas, I got the impression that Mandy and Paddy had moved in together, what I cannot figure out, has Paddy moved in with the Dingles or has Mandy moved in with Paddy at Liam's.

[Son of Cain]

There is only one room in the Dingle house downstairs. But how many rooms are there upstairs? There is Sam and Lydia, Vinny, Samson, until she moved out Belle, Zack when he is home and Mandy and Paddy?. How do they all fit in? Also a bathroom somewhere.

[lizann]

There is only one room in the Dingle house downstairs. But how many rooms are there upstairs? There is Sam and Lydia, Vinny, Samson, until she moved out Belle, Zack when he is home and Mandy and Paddy?. How do they all fit in? Also a bathroom somewhere.

we saw lydia in a shower and bedroom after her attack

i assume mandy stays over nights most nights with paddy

[Son of Cain]

we saw lydia in a shower and bedroom after her attack

i assume mandy stays over nights most nights with paddy

She was living in the Dingle house before she got back with Paddy, and Vinny is also there. I thought Paddy moved into the Single house, not sure if Liam would be happy with Mandy and Eve, when she stays with them, moving in.

[Dennis tanner]

She was living in the Dingle house before she got back with Paddy, and Vinny is also there. I thought Paddy moved into the Single house, not sure if Liam would be happy with Mandy and Eve, when she stays with them, moving in.

LIam is too soft.

[lizann]

LIam is too soft.

i think liam is harder than bob according to wendy

[Dennis tanner]

i think liam is harder than bob according to wendy

Are you on about now or Pre-stent ?

[katie hunter]

Obviously not Harry, but any clues on who Cain and Caleb have locked up? I thought it might be Adam coming back but why would they lock him in?

Mandy has to be one of the most irritating characters ever.

[lizann]

Are you on about now or Pre-stent ?

both hahahaha

[lizann]

finally lydia told

tom has a temper, they may turn him like carl was in the end, violent to belle, carl attempted to rape chas

[Dennis tanner]

Mandy has to be one of the most irritating characters ever. Totally agree. All her mannerisms really irritate me.

There is a motto that says "No better friend. No worse eneny". It applies to Kim.

[Snagglepus]

There is only one room in the Dingle house downstairs. But how many rooms are there upstairs? There is Sam and Lydia, Vinny, Samson, until she moved out Belle, Zack when he is home and Mandy and Paddy?. How do they all fit in? Also a bathroom somewhere.

When Sam was living with Alice didn't they have their own part of the house, accessed up some steps outside. What happened to that place?

[lizann]

Obviously not Harry, but any clues on who Cain and Caleb have locked up? I thought it might be Adam coming back but why would they lock him in?

Mandy has to be one of the most irritating characters ever.

has debbie got herself in trouble again and cain to her rescue, harry too obvious, andy back, jamie, tom?

[Son of Cain]

When Sam was living with Alice didn't they have their own part of the house, accessed up some steps outside. What happened to that place?

Yes I remember that, I thought it was a separate room over a barn. But now when they go upstairs they use the indoor stairs, so I do not know if that still exists.

[Son of Cain]

Obviously not Harry, but any clues on who Cain and Caleb have locked up? I thought it might be Adam coming back but why would they lock him in?

Mandy has to be one of the most irritating characters ever.

Why, Obviously not Harry, my first thought it was him, am I missing something?

Totally agree about Mandy

[johntrevor]

Why, Obviously not Harry, my first thought it was him, am I missing something?

Totally agree about Mandy

Yes I thought no not him he is with Chas. But then I rembered Chas telling somone that he had gone off the grid for a while. So could be him.

[lizann]

mandy can be a bit much, ott but prefer over the likes of chas amy matty chloe sarah claudette nate tracy victoria wendy jacob leyla david and gabby

[Perdita]

mandy can be a bit much, ott but prefer over the likes of chas amy matty chloe sarah claudette nate tracy victoria wendy jacob leyla david and gabby

that leaves out pretty much all the females... :O

[lizann]

moira don't know harry, so aaron or adam?

[katie hunter]

moira don't know harry, so aaron or adam?

The only one I can think of that would need to hide would be Adam.

[lizann]

The only one I can think of that would need to hide would be Adam.

yes especially with his moves on strictly

[lizann]

that leaves out pretty much all the females... :O

they are a bad lot most of them

sarah presumably overheard mack and charity

[Son of Cain]

Why do soap characters insist that the truth must be told regardless of consequences. Not excusing Mack's behaviour but if he tells Chloe the truth, the one that suffers most would be Reuben. Charity insisting he tells her is a bit rich, when she has more Secrets than "Victoria".

[Dennis tanner]

Why do soap characters insist that the truth must be told regardless of consequences. Not excusing Mack's behaviour but if he tells Chloe the truth, the one that suffers most would be Reuben. Charity insisting he tells her is a bit rich, when she has more Secrets than "Victoria".

As a long time Charity fan, I have to agree. Sometimes the scriptwriters really let her down

[johntrevor]

The only one I can think of that would need to hide would be Adam.

Yes a possiblity but surely Moira would have exclaimed "Adam" not "You", when she looked at him in the barn.

[Perdita]

Yes a possiblity but surely Moira would have exclaimed "Adam" not "You", when she looked at him in the barn.

Not if the producer wanted viewers to wait all weekend to find out.... ;)

[Son of Cain]

Not if the producer wanted viewers to wait all weekend to find out.... ;)

Cannot help feeling this reveal will be something of a let down. It has been over damatized, in my opinion, the way the figure was just sitting still, head bowed, even though Moira and Cain were raging on the other side of the door. Too cool to be cool.

I am trying to think who it could, and come up with nothing. If it was Adam or Aaron would they need to be locked in? Aaron would have no reason to hide, and would Adam have to stay there for the rest of his life, to afraid to be seen?

The way Moira said "You" it was hard to tell if it was someone she liked or disliked, so no clues there. Guess we will just have to wait to find out.

[Son of Cain]

Had another thought, could be the guy who sold Holly drugs, cannot remember if went to jail or not.

[lizann]

Had another thought, could be the guy who sold Holly drugs, cannot remember if went to jail or not.

was that suzy?

[Perdita]

was that suzy?

No, Suzy gave Holly the cash to buy drugs but she did not sell them to her

[lizann]

why does chloe want revenge and when did she get a car? chloe slept with mack behind charity's back even if broke up sort of, just karma

[Perdita]

why does chloe want revenge and when did she get a car? chloe slept with mack behind charity's back even if broke up sort of, just karma

Chloe wants revenge because Mack slept with Charity despite telling her he loves her and only wants her... She slept with Mack when he and Charity were on a break (pathetic excuse but gets used all the time)... I sincerely hope that Mack and Charity get back together, cannot take to Chloe ever...

[lizann]

chloe has been one of the most useless soap characters ever and it's a shame and waste to have the big october super soap week around her

[Son of Cain]

why does chloe want revenge and when did she get a car? chloe slept with mack behind charity's back even if broke up sort of, just karma

Does she know that Mack slept with Charity, when did she find out?

[lizann]

Does she know that Mack slept with Charity, when did she find out?

i assume she overheard them by woolie toilets

[Perdita]

i assume she overheard them by woolie toilets

Yes, she did

[Son of Cain]

Yes, she did

I keep missing these vital moments, I saw the door open but I did not see her. I thought she was still at home, did she go to the pub and go straight to the toilet. it is sometimes difficult to follow the time line of events. I saw another post suggesting it was Sarah who was in the toilet, but she was in the bar when Mack and Charity went through the back, and would have had to past them to get there.

[Perdita]

I keep missing these vital moments, I saw the door open but I did not see her. I thought she was still at home, did she go to the pub and go straight to the toilet. it is sometimes difficult to follow the time line of events. I saw another post suggesting it was Sarah who was in the toilet, but she was in the bar when Mack and Charity went through the back, and would have had to past them to get there.

You have not seen it yet, will be shown today but https://metro.co.uk/2023/10/07/emmerdale-spoiler-video-confirms-who-overheard-charity-and-mack-19621401/#:~:text=Charity%2C%20however%2C%20wasn't,loos%2C% 20having%20overheard%20the%20chat. apparently have seen a pre-view clip and it is Chloe behind the door.

The preview clip shows Chloe heartbroken as she learns that Mackenzie and Charity were once again drawn back to each other.

This will play into her revenge plot, which will take centre stage in Super Soap Week.

After setting off for an adventure with Mack in the car, vengeful Chloe will pick up Charity, whose car has broken down, along the way, with devastation set to ensue as all three lives end up in danger after a devastating crash.

But who will Mack choose to save?

[Son of Cain]

You have not seen it yet, will be shown today but https://metro.co.uk/2023/10/07/emmerdale-spoiler-video-confirms-who-overheard-charity-and-mack-19621401/#:~:text=Charity%2C%20however%2C%20wasn't,loos%2C% 20having%20overheard%20the%20chat. apparently have seen a pre-view clip and it is Chloe behind the door.

The preview clip shows Chloe heartbroken as she learns that Mackenzie and Charity were once again drawn back to each other.

This will play into her revenge plot, which will take centre stage in Super Soap Week.

After setting off for an adventure with Mack in the car, vengeful Chloe will pick up Charity, whose car has broken down, along the way, with devastation set to ensue as all three lives end up in danger after a devastating crash.

But who will Mack choose to save?
I wish we could go back to the days before spoilers. I try to avoid them. When they show clips and write about upcoming stories, I find myself watching, waiting for these events to happen, rather than being surprised when they do.

Twist: Chloe and Charity save each other, live happily everafter, and leave Mack to his fate

[lizann]

sorry if spoiled anything honestly i couldn't care less about chloe never have

[Son of Cain]

sorry if spoiled anything honestly i couldn't care less about chloe never have

I might be the only one here who likes Chloe, well, I like her hair. I am attracted to a ginger.

[Perdita]

Aaron... is he going to be back for long or just a short visit???

[lizann]

Aaron... is he going to be back for long or just a short visit???

back to make up with chas and save her from harry i think briefly

[lizann]

i don't get chloes upset, she got with mack from an "affair" and everyone knew it is charity he loves

[Dennis tanner]

sorry if spoiled anything honestly i couldn't care less about chloe never have

I feel sorry for the poor girl. What's she done wrong ?

[Dennis tanner]

Why has Cain kidnapped the Chelsea manager and why is his voice different ?

[Son of Cain]

Well, now we know who "you" is. From the moment I saw the special effects at the start of the episode, I knew this "Stunt Week" was not going to be good. I will take bets it will be worse than "Boot Camp" week. It is sad to see Danny Miller back as Aaron, does it mean his hopes of moving on to bigger and better things has not worked out. How did Cain and Caleb manage to take a tied up Aaron through customs?

Does Mack never learn, just when he seemed to have talked Chloe round, he hugs Charity in the middle of the street, it would have been more surprising if Chloe had not just happened to walk by.

Good to see Ranveer from Eastenders has been resurrected from the suitcase.

[lizann]

I feel sorry for the poor girl. What's she done wrong ?

everything for me since she arrived

[lizann]

why was chas at wylies

[Dennis tanner]

everything for me since she arrived

Such as ?

[Dennis tanner]

Good to see Ranveer from Eastenders has been resurrected from the suitcase.

It's a promotion.

[lizann]

Such as ?

stalking sarah, too pushy with noah then dumping him, chasing nate, chasing mack, never working

[Son of Cain]

i don't get chloes upset, she got with mack from an "affair" and everyone knew it is charity he loves


Aaron... is he going to be back for long or just a short visit???

If his over melodramatic acting is going to last, a short visit I hope.

Do not understand how this attached two quotes, when I only selected the second one. When I have wanted to do this, I have never known how to. Likewise for making type bold, I cannot find how to do these things.

[lizann]

aaron is back long term permanent

[Perdita]

aaron is back long term permanent

Have to get Rob back now

[johntrevor]

aaron is back long term permanent

Yes according to his Youtube appearance he is glad he is staying. Maybe join Caleb's crew?

How did Chas find out? Caleb and Cain were both at the farm when Chas was outside the Woolpack on her phone to Harry/Simon.
How did she know were to go? When she got there she didn't seemed surprised just said to Cain "let him go now".

[lizann]

Yes according to his Youtube appearance he is glad he is staying. Maybe join Caleb's crew?

How did Chas find out? Caleb and Cain were both at the farm when Chas was outside the Woolpack on her phone to Harry/Simon.
How did she know were to go? When she got there she didn't seemed surprised just said to Cain "let him go now".

did caleb tell chas and nate to get nate off his back but nothing was shown or mentioned how chas just rocked up there

is wylies also where katie and al died

[Son of Cain]

aaron is back long term permanent

You have depressed me now.

[Dennis tanner]

aaron is back long term permanent

It's Hollywood I feel sorry for if that's the case

[lizann]

the greener grass was reality tv, he was glad to return to a good wage steady work for his family

[Son of Cain]

aaron is back long term permanent

Anyone else think that Harry looked like Sean Connery when he was sitting in his car talking to Chas.

[Son of Cain]

Is this the end of Chloe?
The way this was filmed it looked like they were actually struck by a white van or car. But what happened to it? It was not seen or mentioned again. I am sure even Amazon would allow the driver to stop and help with a crash. Did it just drive on in a damaged state. Not much sense of urgency when Mack was on the phone

Instead of talking so much if Chloe and Charity had just crawled towards Mack, they could probably both have got out. The closer they got tp the other side of the car the more their weight would shift away from the cliff edge.

At least we were spared the car bursting into flames.

[Son of Cain]

the greener grass was reality tv, he was glad to return to a good wage steady work for his family

I do not blame him for wanting a steady wage, but maybe he should have asked to see the script before coming back.

Just when I thought we had heard the last of Al and Chas it has returned to haunt us.

[lizann]

mack will die from holding that car, burst heart, internal bleeding

where was the crashed into van?

good scenes with lydia sam belle and mandy but where was samson and vinny, zak away again in scotland

[Dennis tanner]

Have to get Rob back now

No we don't. I do not approve of murderers.

[Dennis tanner]

mack will die from holding that car, burst heart, internal bleeding

where was the crashed into van? I see no point in saving poor chloe if she was leavng anyway. Plus, the accident was her fault.


good scenes with lydia sam belle and mandy but where was samson and vinny, zak away again in scotland I can't agree about Big Mandy who was just a stirer acting on a guess.

Sam twice said that he knew there was something wrong before he went to Ireland.......................... but he went anyway

[Son of Cain]

I don't think Chloe will be the one to survive. Mack was using his right hand to hold the wrist, Charity was on his right, Chloe in the front seat, to his left.

[Perdita]

I don't think Chloe will be the one to survive. Mack was using his right hand to hold the wrist, Charity was on his right, Chloe in the front seat, to his left.

The hand we saw Mack holding at the end had unvarnished short nails like Charity has, Chloe has varnished long nails. I can see a twist coming though that Mack somehow saved both seeing he must have had a lot of power training before to be able to hold on to the car for so long....

[Dennis tanner]

The hand we saw Mack holding at the end had unvarnished short nails like Charity has, Chloe has varnished long nails. I can see a twist coming though that Mack somehow saved both seeing he must have had a lot of power training before to be able to hold on to the car for so long....

TV programmes for Week commencing 16/10 state that Amy still needs condolence.

[Son of Cain]

The hand we saw Mack holding at the end had unvarnished short nails like Charity has, Chloe has varnished long nails. I can see a twist coming though that Mack somehow saved both seeing he must have had a lot of power training before to be able to hold on to the car for so long....

Now that would be a twist. Did you see Mack rip off his t-shirt and turn into Superman? I suspect that if be grabbed both of them, their weight would pull him over the edge with them. I leave others to judge if this would be a good or a bad thing.

[lizann]

could amit have pushed rishi, that look in the house

chloe has to survive long enough to tell mack she knows he slept with charity

i really don't care about chas or chloe

[katie hunter]

I thought it was quite a good ep. I wonder who the other driver is? I guess we are supposed to think that Chas has been bumped off but I doubt she has.

[lizann]

I thought it was quite a good ep. I wonder who the other driver is? I guess we are supposed to think that Chas has been bumped off but I doubt she has.

the music and flashbacks too much for me

[Dennis tanner]

could amit have pushed rishi, that look in the house

chloe has to survive long enough to tell mack she knows he slept with charity

i really don't care about chas or chloe

I care about poor Chloe Weasley. I see her as a victim in all this. It annoys me that she is at death's door while Mandy Dingle is living and breathing

[Son of Cain]

I think they are trying to tell too many tales at the same time, it is making me dizzy the way they jump from one story to another. I see no need to have a "Big Week". Glad to see they at least acknowledged the other driver, although I do not think we will hear any more about them.
I hate the special effects, no need for them, they add nothing.

[katie hunter]

I was hoping that Chloe was doomed but then remembered that she is in the miracle hospital so she will more than likely be up and about by next Tuesday.

[Dennis tanner]

I was hoping that Chloe was doomed but then remembered that she is in the miracle hospital so she will more than likely be up and about by next Tuesday.

Why do people want her to be doomed ?

[katie hunter]

Why do people want her to be doomed ?

Too much simpering for me. I find her unbearable.

[lizann]

amit was in the house before

aaron don't care if chas dies nor do i

[Dennis tanner]

Too much simpering for me. I find her unbearable.

Thanks for you comments. I am obliged to say that I so not regard too much simpering as wortthy of the death sentence

[lizann]

Thanks for you comments. I am obliged to say that I so not regard too much simpering as wortthy of the death sentence

chloe is just unlikeable, dopey and useless, well that's what i think of her

[Dennis tanner]

chloe is just unlikeable, dopey and useless, well that's what i think of her Not totally usless. She did produce a healthy baby boy.

[Son of Cain]

I think they are trying to tell too many tales at the same time, it is making me dizzy the way they jump from one story to another. I see no need to have a "Big Week". Glad to see they at least acknowledged the other driver, although I do not think we will hear any more about them.
I hate the special effects, no need for them, they add nothing.

If I was dizzy the other night, then tonight I could hardly see straight. I would much rather they had concentrated on one story with maybe some coverage of another. Presumably cutting away is meant to add drama and tension and is not just done to annoy us, well, me at least. I did not feel the reactions of Charity or Moira was very realistic. And Chas could have least have shown some gratitude to Cain and Caleb for rescuing her. Better if they had not bothered and Aaron could have kept his ill gotten gains and disappeared again.

[lizann]

overall a poor week, only saved by lydia

[Son of Cain]

overall a poor week, only saved by lydia

Always the same with a "Big Week", always a disappointment.

[katie hunter]

Always the same with a "Big Week", always a disappointment.

For me the only decent Big Week was the one with Cameron. This week had some highlights (mainly Lydia) but overall it was a bit of a damp squib.

[Dennis tanner]

Livesly, who looks like a candidate for a Jeremy Kyle show needs a serious slap. Harry needs to
sort him out

Was I wrong to think that Craig's secretary was pleased to see him arrested? another complaint perhaps ?

[lizann]

Livesly, who looks like a candidate for a Jeremy Kyle show needs a serious slap. Harry needs to
sort him out

Was I wrong to think that Craig's secretary was pleased to see him arrested? another complaint perhaps ?

id say the secretary was another victim

[Son of Cain]

Livesly, who looks like a candidate for a Jeremy Kyle show needs a serious slap. Harry needs to
sort him out

Was I wrong to think that Craig's secretary was pleased to see him arrested? another complaint perhaps ?

Sorry to say but The Jeremy Kyle show is no more.

If he did something to the Secretary that would help with the fact that Lydia has no evidence

[johntrevor]

Sorry to say but The Jeremy Kyle show is no more.

If he did something to the Secretary that would help with the fact that Lydia has no evidence

Yes I have a feeling there is more to come from the secretary.

[lizann]

would craig's office have cctv or wiped, samson could retrieve as he tech savvy

[tammyy2j]

Harry was happy to just accept 30,000 Euros

[johntrevor]

Harry was happy to just accept 30,000 Euros

Surely a guy like Harry is going to want revenge on Aaron for mowing him down.

[Son of Cain]

would craig's office have cctv or wiped, samson could retrieve as he tech savvy

Data can only be retrieve if it has not been overwritten. All the data in a file is not always stored on the same place on a hardrive, that's why files sometimes take a while to open. Sometimes parts of a file can be recovered but other parts cannot. Doubt Samson would be allowed access to the office CCTV.

[Dennis tanner]

Why did Nico serve Livesy with that food when he had no intention to pay.

Damn you Vinny. You persuaded him to stay. Where did he get that car from.?

Will Charity approve of Chastity giving all her money away ?

I rang up the ITV helpline about Livesy but I don't think they took me seriously

[lizann]

will charity and ryan approve aaron robbing the pub till

[Dennis tanner]

will charity and ryan approve aaron robbing the pub till

I doubt if it will be mentioned. In any case Chastity would threaten to resign if Charity complained.

[lizann]

I doubt if it will be mentioned. In any case Chastity would threaten to resign if Charity complained.

the dingles don't seem worried about charity

[Dennis tanner]

the dingles don't seem worried about charity

untill they want a free drink

[Son of Cain]

Aaron must have been reading "How to Make Friends and Influence People" on the way back from Italy. Anyone here know someone in Hollywood who could give him a call and offer him a part in a film as a Neanderthal.

Don't know if I can bear it if he is back permanently.

[johntrevor]

Aaron must have been reading "How to Make Friends and Influence People" on the way back from Italy. Anyone here know someone in Hollywood who could give him a call and offer him a part in a film as a Neanderthal.

Don't know if I can bear it if he is back permanently.

Looks like you will have to. he told Vinny he was staying

[Dennis tanner]

Aaron must have been reading "How to Make Friends and Influence People" on the way back from Italy. Anyone here know someone in Hollywood who could give him a call and offer him a part in a film as a Neanderthal.

Don't know if I can bear it if he is back permanently.

Totally agree.

[Perdita]

Looks like you will have to. he told Vinny he was staying

All good guys in a soap turn evil at one point, this one will turn back to be his loveable old self in next to no time ;)

[Son of Cain]

All good guys in a soap turn evil at one point, this one will turn back to be his loveable old self in next to no time ;)

Either you or I must have been only have been half watching, as I do not remember Aaron ever being "loveable".

[Dennis tanner]

All good guys in a soap turn evil at one point, this one will turn back to be his loveable old self in next to no time ;)

Sean Tully has never been evil. He's always been one of the good guys

[Perdita]

Sean Tully has never been evil. He's always been one of the good guys

Give it time!!!

[lizann]

Sean Tully has never been evil. He's always been one of the good guys

selfish arrogant hypocrite gossip judgemental

[lizann]

i get aaron's anger at chas, deserved, she chose al over him, her actions lead to liv's death

[Perdita]

selfish arrogant hypocrite gossip judgemental

But still a good guy!

[Son of Cain]

But still a good guy!
And fun.

[lizann]

And fun.

sean from corrie?

[Dennis tanner]

selfish arrogant hypocrite gossip judgemental

I do try my best not to be.

[katie hunter]

Strange that the Dingles were toasting Faith but not one of them mentioned Liv?

[Dennis tanner]

Strange that the Dingles were toasting Faith but not one of them mentioned Liv?

None of those there were related to her

[lizann]

Strange that the Dingles were toasting Faith but not one of them mentioned Liv?

vinny gabby and aaron at least acknowledged liv nothing for harriet

[Perdita]

vinny gabby and aaron at least acknowledged liv nothing for harriet

Harriet did not have a funeral in the show either...

[Son of Cain]

Surely a guy like Harry is going to want revenge on Aaron for mowing him down.

You would think so, but he may only have been a vehicle in the story to bring Aaron back. If he is as bad a gangster as they tell us, no way would he let Aaron get away with it, and surely if he is big time he would be able to earn ?30,000 in no time. I am keeping my fingers cross that he will be back for revenge.

[lizann]

Harriet did not have a funeral in the show either...

and victor did

[katie hunter]

How has Adam managed to sign over his share of the scrapyard while he is on the run? Did he just drop in to his local Solicitors to do the paperwork and then go back into hiding?

[lizann]

How has Adam managed to sign over his share of the scrapyard while he is on the run? Did he just drop in to his local Solicitors to do the paperwork and then go back into hiding?

aaron afaik signed everything to vinny but aaron is in contact with adam

[Dennis tanner]

Harriet did not have a funeral in the show either...

But she did have a wake where ONE of her colleagues attended

[Dennis tanner]

How has Adam managed to sign over his share of the scrapyard while he is on the run? Did he just drop in to his local Solicitors to do the paperwork and then go back into hiding?

Or was he just lying.

[Son of Cain]

How has Adam managed to sign over his share of the scrapyard while he is on the run? Did he just drop in to his local Solicitors to do the paperwork and then go back into hiding?

Has Vinny been been sending profits to Adam all this time?

[johntrevor]

How has Adam managed to sign over his share of the scrapyard while he is on the run? Did he just drop in to his local Solicitors to do the paperwork and then go back into hiding?

He actually told Vinny that Adam had given him his shares

[lizann]

Has Vinny been been sending profits to Adam all this time?

what profits as vinny was away in ireland

[Son of Cain]

What a boring episode, after the high drama and excitement of "The Big Week". I hate episodes that concentrate on "relationships", I do not care if Charity and Mack get back together. Nor about the problems Nicki and Suni are having. Only two gay men in the village, so of course they have to put them together, though now that Aaron is back can we expect a "menage a trois. Now we have to wait to see if Chloe remembers that Mack saved Charity.

Glad they have found something for Nate to do, standing there menacing, like a US Secret Service bodyguard, though Caleb certainly does not have the diplomacy to be a President.

[Son of Cain]

What ever happened to Nicky's mum, he was worried she would have no home if Caleb did not get his hands on Kim's money, and not a word since.

[lizann]

What ever happened to Nicky's mum, he was worried she would have no home if Caleb did not get his hands on Kim's money, and not a word since.

did caleb lie about the house so nicky would go along with him

i was hoping she'd rock up in the dales and be tina dingle

[Dennis tanner]

I am disgusted the Livesy is allowed to go in the shop demanding tearsticks.

I am confused as to how Vinny would have got hold of that fireplace.

Poor Nicky went down far too easy.

Sam's son is not as clever as he thinks he is.

[Son of Cain]

did caleb lie about the house so nicky would go along with him

i was hoping she'd rock up in the dales and be tina dingle

I guess we will never know now.

[johntrevor]

The highlight of Thursday's episode for me was seeing Amit knocked onto his backside, Now if he will simply leave.

[Son of Cain]

The highlight of Thursday's episode for me was seeing Amit knocked onto his backside, Now if he will simply leave.

I doubt it. I think he could turn out to be more dangerous than Caleb thinks.

[Son of Cain]

I am confused as to how Vinny would have got hold of that fireplace.

I imagine it was ripped out of a house and was going to be scrapped, or that Vinny found it dumped somewhere. Although I am surprised that whoever owned it did not realize it's value. I thought everyone knew the value of recycling and architectural salvage nowadays. Cast iron fireplaces are worth hundrerds of pounds.

[Dennis tanner]

I doubt it. I think he could turn out to be more dangerous than Caleb thinks.

I guess that he could hire a bit of muscle.

[lizann]

so now we have chloe's revenge again

[katie hunter]

so now we have chloe's revenge again

No doubt this will be the jolly Christmas storyline.

[Dennis tanner]

so now we have chloe's revenge again

She needs to get a grip. He couldn't have saved both of them.

[lizann]

No doubt this will be the jolly Christmas storyline.

waste of a stunt and big week ultimately

[Son of Cain]

She needs to get a grip. He couldn't have saved both of them.

That's why she is angry and feels betrayed, he could only save one, but he chose Charity.

[Dennis tanner]

That's why she is angry and feels betrayed, he could only save one, but he chose Charity.

Simple answer...Charity's hand was nearer.

[Son of Cain]

Simple answer...Charity's hand was nearer.

Don't think Chloe saw it like that, she saw it as a choice.

[Perdita]

Simple answer...Charity's hand was nearer.

I think he could have reached Chloe's hand if he really had wanted to ...

[Snagglepus]

Only two gay men in the village,

You are forgetting Ethan and the upcoming Arthur.

[Son of Cain]

You are forgetting Ethan and the upcoming Arthur.

I had forgotten them, they have become so insignificant they are almost invisible.

[Dennis tanner]

You are forgetting Ethan and the upcoming Arthur.

Plus Nicky, Sun Hill and Livesy makes it the gayest village in Yorkshire

[lizann]

Plus Nicky, Sun Hill and Livesy makes it the gayest village in Yorkshire

charity is bisexual also

[lizann]

chloe home already, hotten miracle but i just don't care about her

[Dennis tanner]

chloe home already, hotten miracle but i just don't care about her It is a miracle and I have no problem with Chloe. Sbhe's right ablout Mack. He does love her. Problem is that he loves Charity as well.

Deleted scene.....
Belle " Your mom died a few days ago. Why have you kept it a secret? "
Tom "We are in a soap. It's what we are supposed to do"
Belle " Get a grip"

[Perdita]

chloe home already, hotten miracle but i just don't care about her

Glad to see that none of her nails broke when she was flying around in the car....

[Son of Cain]

Glad to see that none of her nails broke when she was flying around in the car....

I am surprized she did not break her neck, never mind a nail. Falling from a cliff in a car and out of hospital already, did they treat her with fairy dust to be able to go home already.
-
The insurance company have outdone the hospital, replacing her car so soon. I have never, ever, heard of a insurance company settling so quick, especially as she was to blame. She will not be fit to drive it for months but will have to tax and insure it as it is parked on the public highway. Who filled in the claims forms?

[lizann]

when did chloe get a car, she also had no money no job ever

[Son of Cain]

If I was Tom I would be running for the hills, Belle's insistence that it is "good to talk" must be driving him mad. Not everyone wants or needs to talk. Mind you I still think there is something not quite right with him, but Belle should be patient and let him come to terms with his mother's death in his own way.

Likewise Amy trying to run Chloe's life for her, it is not as if she is perfect. Frank has now definitely been consigned to the dustbin of history.

[Son of Cain]

when did chloe get a car, she also had no money no job ever

She did have a car when she was living in her father's house, could she still have that one? Or possibly was it Kerry's car?

[lizann]

She did have a car when she was living in her father's house, could she still have that one? Or possibly was it Kerry's car?

kerry was broke too alao lived and worked in the vilage

afair chloe was let take nothing when she left or was thrown out with kerry

[Dennis tanner]

when did chloe get a car, she also had no money no job ever

It's a real mystery. like her survival

[johntrevor]

I am surprized she did not break her neck, never mind a nail. Falling from a cliff in a car and out of hospital already, did they treat her with fairy dust to be able to go home already.
-
Of course she's out of The Hotten General Miracle Hospital. Whydid you have any doubts... lol

[lizann]

ryan should tell charity and noah about oscar

[lizann]

vic already getting rid of her son for a bit of how's your father with her former nearly step son, sick, sick, sick

[Dennis tanner]

ryan should tell charity and noah about oscar

They will have to when Sophie dies any day soon

[lizann]

the craig investigation was fast done and over, was his staff interviewed, cctv sought off the office, the building

[Son of Cain]

vic already getting rid of her son for a bit of how's your father with her former nearly step son, sick, sick, sick

I wonder if they have a chart in the Emmerdale office showing all the relationships the characters have had with each other? Looking at the chart they see Jacob and Victoria have not been paired yet, hence the latest screen romance

[lizann]

I wonder if they have a chart in the Emmerdale office showing all the relationships the characters have had with each other? Looking at the chart they see Jacob and Victoria have not been paired yet, hence the latest screen romance


It's riveting revolting

[Dennis tanner]

Has Paddy Kirk appeared since Big Brother started?

Didn't think so.. wink

[lizann]

how did jacob arrange all that and david getting harry now so more sexy time for the disgusting victoria and jacob

it will probably end up being the secretary that quit who does craig in

[Dennis tanner]

how did jacob arrange all that and david getting harry now so more sexy time for the disgusting victoria and jacob

it will probably end up being the secretary that quit who does craig in

Or it could be one of people in his audience who will not be caught.

[Perdita]

If I was Tom I would be running for the hills, Belle's insistence that it is "good to talk" must be driving him mad. Not everyone wants or needs to talk. Mind you I still think there is something not quite right with him, but Belle should be patient and let him come to terms with his mother's death in his own way.

Likewise Amy trying to run Chloe's life for her, it is not as if she is perfect. Frank has now definitely been consigned to the dustbin of history.

Maybe Tom is talking to his sister Anya about his mom passing away rather than Belle.... weird how siblings no longer part of the show never get mentioned even when close family members die...

[katie hunter]

I wonder if they have a chart in the Emmerdale office showing all the relationships the characters have had with each other? Looking at the chart they see Jacob and Victoria have not been paired yet, hence the latest screen romance

Random Couple Generator 🎡

[Son of Cain]

Still trying to figure out what Vinny meant when he said "You don't need a van to dispose off a body". Does he think that if Sam did need to dispose of a body, he would sling it over his should and carry it off.

[Son of Cain]

Has Ryan's hair become more blonde, or am I imagining it?

[Perdita]

Has Ryan's hair become more blonde, or am I imagining it?

No, you are not imagining it, I think he has had some highlights

[johntrevor]

it will probably end up being the secretary that quit who does craig in

Well she certainly knows somethning, she was giving Craig evil looks during the argument with Belle. Perhaps also been a victim.

[lizann]

Has Ryan's hair become more blonde, or am I imagining it?

yes it's lovely

[Dennis tanner]

Sophie is a dead wopman walking.

As for Craig, could it possibly be an Orient Express solution.

[Son of Cain]

I am just going to make my bladder gladder. Will I ever have the nerve to say this.

[Son of Cain]

yes it's lovely

Yes, I like it better, it looks much softer. Wishing I had that much hair.

[lizann]

**** of the north, new for me

[Dennis tanner]

**** of the north, new for me

A popular pub name and a military tune.

[Perdita]

**** of the north, new for me

???? :hmm:

[Son of Cain]

**** of the north, new for me

Surely Sam meant to say "**** of the Walk" ?

[johntrevor]

Surely Sam meant to say "**** of the Walk" ?

Both are correct I think the "north" one is a geordie or scouse sayimg used a lot in Auf Wiedersehen, Pet

[Perdita]

Both are correct I think the "north" one is a geordie or scouse sayimg used a lot in Auf Wiedersehen, Pet

Referring to what????

[johntrevor]

Referring to what????

An arrogant person who thinks hes above eveyone else

[Dennis tanner]

An arrogant person who thinks hes above eveyone else

Sammy was right all along.

[lizann]

tom the angry jilted abuser probably killed craig

[Dennis tanner]

The 'investigation' in the pub was somewhat silly.

Why is Lydia bothered about who killed Craig ?

Why are any of them bothered? If one of them confesses will they make a citizen's arrest and take them off to Hotton Police Station?

Of course not !!! It would just mean there are loads of people needing to keep a secret.

Lydia knows that Ceaig was guilty. Why does she need him to admit it to her.

[Son of Cain]

Going to be heavy going this week, if they are all going to spend it in the pub, taking turns in giving their alibis.

[lizann]

Going to be heavy going this week, if they are all going to spend it in the pub, taking turns in giving their alibis.

a long dingle flashback week

[katie hunter]

The 'investigation' in the pub was somewhat silly.

Why is Lydia bothered about who killed Craig ?

Why are any of them bothered? If one of them confesses will they make a citizen's arrest and take them off to Hotton Police Station?

Of course not !!! It would just mean there are loads of people needing to keep a secret.

Lydia knows that Ceaig was guilty. Why does she need him to admit it to her.

I agree. What is the point unless Lydia intends handing them over to Hottens finest - which of course she won't. Unclear why Chas is there, can't remember her ever being in the same room as Craig?

[Son of Cain]

I agree. What is the point unless Lydia intends handing them over to Hottens finest - which of course she won't. Unclear why Chas is there, can't remember her ever being in the same room as Craig?

Chas and Charity are now senior matriarch figures in the Dingle family.

[lizann]

I agree. What is the point unless Lydia intends handing them over to Hottens finest - which of course she won't. Unclear why Chas is there, can't remember her ever being in the same room as Craig?

because chas needs redeeming and pushed as part of the dingle clan still and was missing around his death time

charity through craig out of her pub and is a rape abuse survivor victim

it's farcical the whole thing

[Son of Cain]

Did they tell us how Craig died? Was he shot, stabbed, strangled, blunt force trauma or die of natural causes?

Why would Billy phone Lydia to tell her?

[lizann]

Did they tell us how Craig died? Was he shot, stabbed, strangled, blunt force trauma or die of natural causes?

Why would Billy phone Lydia to tell her?

billy found the body in home farm field like a flat scarecrow lying down, no mention of how he was killed

[Perdita]

Did they tell us how Craig died? Was he shot, stabbed, strangled, blunt force trauma or die of natural causes?

Why would Billy phone Lydia to tell her?

He was laid on his back in a field with a lot of blood around his head so looks like blunt force trauma.. maybe Billy phoned Lydia because he was aware of what happened between Lydia and Craig??'

[lizann]

the affair begins for tracy and caleb

[Son of Cain]

Now we have another episode on "Confessions with the Dingles" to look forward to. I am beginning to wish it was Aaron's body that was found in the field. I do wish he would stop sniffing.

[katie hunter]

Tracey and Caleb, oh well at least it's not Cain.

How many times has Lydia said 'we don't have much time before the police arrive'? Surely they will look more guilty if they are all found in the pub together?

[Dennis tanner]

Now we have another episode on "Confessions with the Dingles" to look forward to. I am beginning to wish it was Aaron's body that was found in the field. I do wish he would stop sniffing.

Chubby Cheeks thinks it's top acting.

Lydia is deluded. Livesy is a bully and Vinny is a fool.

How can anyone have an alibi untill they know the time of death ?

[Son of Cain]

He was laid on his back in a field with a lot of blood around his head so looks like blunt force trauma.. maybe Billy phoned Lydia because he was aware of what happened between Lydia and Craig??'

Billy probably did phone Lydia because he knew what happened with her and Craig. But I would have thought that after his experience with Alex, he would not want to be see doing anything suspicious if the police start checking phones, it could look like he was warning Lydia. It would also have spared us the is Dingle family therapy session in the pub if he had not called her.

[Son of Cain]

Tracey and Caleb, oh well at least it's not Cain.

How many times has Lydia said 'we don't have much time before the police arrive'? Surely they will look more guilty if they are all found in the pub together?

Tracey and Caleb, have the writers been consulting the relationship chart again?

[katie hunter]

Tracey and Caleb, have the writers been consulting the relationship chart again?

Yes. It's either a chart or a tombola.

[lizann]

Tracey and Caleb, have the writers been consulting the relationship chart again?

tbf i think the seeds of this was set, starting from when he helped her about starting her creche business idea

[johntrevor]

Now we have another episode on "Confessions with the Dingles" to look forward to. I am beginning to wish it was Aaron's body that was found in the field. I do wish he would stop sniffing.

Yes that constant sniffing gets up my nose too.

[Son of Cain]

Another secret told, Mandy promised not to tell David or Brenda that Eric was ill, but then tells the whole Dingle family.

[Son of Cain]

Yes that constant sniffing gets up my nose too.

Must be contagious.

[Son of Cain]

Woz it the Secretary, wot done for Craig?

[Son of Cain]

Must have been the longest the Dingles ever sat in a pub without a drink

Chas was acting a bit weird, sitting there smirking and smiling at times.

[katie hunter]

The pub scenes are far too long and Lydia is getting more and more annoying. My sympathy for her is waning.

Sad that this will be Chris Chittell leaving the show. I wonder if its connected to David leaving?

[Dennis tanner]

Another secret told, Mandy promised not to tell David or Brenda that Eric was ill, but then tells the whole Dingle family.

Mandy Dingle...awful character.

Why does she need a till? She has no paying customers.

More nonsense from Lydia.

[Snagglepus]

Another secret told, Mandy promised not to tell David or Brenda that Eric was ill, but then tells the whole Dingle family.

I don't think she told them about Eric's illness.
Like the others, she skirted around bits of her story.

[lizann]

too many storylines this week, the rape aftermath at the bottom of them, badly done

[lizann]

omg what a silly ending, horse killed

[Son of Cain]

Unless any of the Dingle actors were leaving the series it was unlikely that any of them could have killed Craig. So this week's attempt at drama and suspence. has been wasted. Bit of a damp squib, appropriate really for this time of year. The moment Kim mentioned the horse it was obvious he was the culprit.

[katie hunter]

What a nonsense week. Was Lydia's plan to shop the culprit to the Police? Why hasn't it occurred to anyone that Sam might not have killed him?

The only storyline that has come out of this week that is remotely interesting is Eric's. Well that, and the wellbeing of the poor horse.

[Snagglepus]

Billy always phoned Lydia exactly when nothing was going on, she was never interrupted by a call.

[Dennis tanner]

What a nonsense week. Was Lydia's plan to shop the culprit to the Police? Why hasn't it occurred to anyone that Sam might not have killed him?

The only storyline that has come out of this week that is remotely interesting is Eric's. Well that, and the wellbeing of the poor horse.

Lydia has never had what it takes to be a proper Dingle.

[lizann]

cain can't let sam go down, the body will have horse hoof marks as well as a beating from sam

why did craig not stay on the road and billy knew more than the coppers when updating lydia

good to see that detective inspector back

[Son of Cain]

Billy always phoned Lydia exactly when nothing was going on, she was never interrupted by a call.

They obviously have a telepathic communication.

[johntrevor]

cain can't let sam go down, the body will have horse hoof marks as well as a beating from sam

why did craig not stay on the road and billy knew more than the coppers when updating lydia

good to see that detective inspector back

Judging by the state of Craig's face after the pummeling Sam gave him, there is bound to be Sam's dna on Craig, and i would think Sam's knuckles will be showing obvious signs.

[Son of Cain]

Judging by the state of Craig's face after the pummeling Sam gave him, there is bound to be Sam's dna on Craig, and i would think Sam's knuckles will be showing obvious signs.

Soap forensics are never very thorough, if they find one hoof print, they will probably not look any further. Despite what we see on TV and in films, punching someone in the face or on the skull is more damaging than they show us. Damaging to the punchers hands that is, even trained boxers can fracture bones in their hands when punching with bare knuckles. That's why boxers have so much padding in their gloves and use so much tape on their hands.

[Perdita]

Should Belle not have a wound on her forehead where she hit her head ???

[lizann]

Should Belle not have a would on her forehead where she hit her head ???

yes unless heavy make up covered

[Dennis tanner]

Sammy should have prepared a bowl full of washing up so he could be wearing his rubber gloves .

[Son of Cain]

Should Belle not have a wound on her forehead where she hit her head ???

It could be that it is hidden under her hair, she has worn it down since the injury. Either that or the make up department is running short of fake blood. Sam's left hand was hardly ever in camera shot after the he beat Craig unti the police the police asked about his skinned knuckles.

Is Sam left handed?

[lizann]

did cain really think sam would get away with all the dna on him and craig