Emmerdale - Current Episode Discussion - III

[Son of Cain]

How did Chastity's daughter know there was a problem with the hair ?

Think she just found it scary, although her scream was not very convincing, whether or not she knew there was a problem did not really matter. Personally I thought it looked quite nice.

[johntrevor]

Think she just found it scary, although her scream was not very convincing, whether or not she knew there was a problem did not really matter. Personally I thought it looked quite nice.

Me too

[Dennis tanner]

Think she just found it scary, although her scream was not very convincing, whether or not she knew there was a problem did not really matter. Personally I thought it looked quite nice.

The only problem I saw was that it was different lengths at the back.

I think she was just told to scream and I agree that it was very strange

[Son of Cain]

Mack was leaving it a bit late to buy the wedding rings. Very little chance of finding them by throwing handfuls of hay out of the barn. What they need is a metal detector.

[lizann]

Mack was leaving it a bit late to buy the wedding rings. Very little chance of finding them by throwing handfuls of hay out of the barn. What they need is a metal detector.

charity has gone ott paranoia and yes a metal detector would find the fell of the back of a lorry rings

[Dennis tanner]

charity has gone ott paranoia and yes a metal detector would find the fell of the back of a lorry rings

Charity was like a female Steve MacDonald. Totally irrational

[Son of Cain]

Wouldn't it be a novel twist if just for once a Soap wedding went ahead without a hitch. That really would be a surprise. Why bother with wedding planning, might as well just turn up on the day and say "whatever".

[johntrevor]

Wouldn't it be a novel twist if just for once a Soap wedding went ahead without a hitch. That really would be a surprise. Why bother with wedding planning, might as well just turn up on the day and say "whatever".

True... and then living happily ever after or is that a tad too far.?

[Dennis tanner]

True... and then living happily ever after or is that a tad too far.?

It's vey difficult to write for happy ever after in a soap.

[Son of Cain]

True... and then living happily ever after or is that a tad too far.?

That would definitely be more than a tad too far.

[Perdita]

Wouldn't it be a novel twist if just for once a Soap wedding went ahead without a hitch. That really would be a surprise. Why bother with wedding planning, might as well just turn up on the day and say "whatever".

Viewers would complain!

[Dennis tanner]

Viewers would complain!

I certainly wouldn't

[Son of Cain]

I certainly wouldn't

Neither would I - I would be so shocked that I would be rendered incapable of speech or movement.

[lizann]

did we meet nickys boyfriend gabby in a throuple

swirling another a team fan

[hward]

I haven't seen it yet - does charity know about mack and and Chloe?

[johntrevor]

I haven't seen it yet - does charity know about mack and and Chloe?

Not yet

[lizann]

I haven't seen it yet - does charity know about mack and and Chloe?

i thought she did and was going to reveal but looks no

[Dennis tanner]

did we meet nickys boyfriend gabby in a throuple

swirling another a team fan

Mr S.

The bogus vicar was very unprofessional rushing the service and harping on about the time during the service.

Is he really that busy? He could have easily done the funeral and then come back and done the wedding

[Son of Cain]

Charity was laying it on a bit thick, cooing over the baby and asking Chloe to move in. It is not as though Chloe is related to her.

[Snagglepus]

Ryan looked like Wild Bill Hickok.

[lizann]

charity has gone very maternal with esther and now reuben, is she wanting mack to crack fess up?

[Dennis tanner]

charity has gone very maternal with esther and now reuben, is she wanting mack to crack fess up?

Yes it's all very suspicious.

[Perdita]

Charity was laying it on a bit thick, cooing over the baby and asking Chloe to move in. It is not as though Chloe is related to her.

Maybe she thinks that it will put Mack off wanting to have a baby?

[Son of Cain]

Ryan looked like Wild Bill Hickok.

Exactly what I thought when I saw him. - Better not play poker then. If he draws aces and eights leave the table immediately.

[Son of Cain]

Maybe she thinks that it will put Mack off wanting to have a baby?

I don't think Charity knows, I think it was a contrived way to show that Mack is finding it difficult to suppress his feelings about the baby. I wonder if when it does come out if Mack will end up going off with Chloe to Scotland?

[johntrevor]

I don't think Charity knows, I think it was a contrived way to show that Mack is finding it difficult to suppress his feelings about the baby. I wonder if when it does come out if Mack will end up going off with Chloe to Scotland?

Yes I think that was Mack's problem. He's said previously he has always wanted a child, and now he's got one he can't acknowledge it.
Maybe it will all get to much for him and he will scoot off to Scotland

[Dennis tanner]

Yes I think that was Mack's problem. He's said previously he has always wanted a child, and now he's got one he can't acknowledge it.
Maybe it will all get to much for him and he will scoot off to Scotland

Perhaps the fact that he has a child will be enough for him.

[lizann]

i don't think chloe is going back to scotland

[Son of Cain]

i don't think chloe is going back to scotland

Maybe not, but when charity finds out, and surely she will, what will Mack do then? Suppose it depends on whether Lawrence Robb is staying on in the role. Only in Soaps do so many partners of broken relationships continue to live in close proximity to each other. Surprised really there are not more murders.

[lizann]

charity might surprise us and keep husband mack and welcome baby mack, forgive sarah who knew

[Dennis tanner]

charity might surprise us and keep husband mack and welcome baby mack, forgive sarah who knew

I agree. It saves her the problem of being pregnant again.

[lizann]

did isaac take the telescope from lucas

[lizann]

who would bring that flash blue car to cain's village garage

[Dennis tanner]

who would bring that flash blue car to cain's village garage

One of the better paid production team.

[Son of Cain]

How on earth did Nicky think he could get away with lying about how he got his black eye, in a village like Emmerdale, where everyone knows everybody else's business.

[Son of Cain]

Larel has always been a bit of a busybody, involving herself in other people business. But maybe it is just my mind, but I am getting some weird vibes about Laurel and Marshall's relationship. I do hope they are not heading where I think they could be.

[Son of Cain]

I am getting bored of the Caleb a Kim story, cannot wait for it to be over.

[Snagglepus]

How many bedrooms does Laurel have, for a while there was only her, Arthur and Dottie. Now Marshall has a room and I imagine Archie has one too.

[Perdita]

Larel has always been a bit of a busybody, involving herself in other people business. But maybe it is just my mind, but I am getting some weird vibes about Laurel and Marshall's relationship. I do hope they are not heading where I think they could be.

That went through my mind too...

[Son of Cain]

That went through my mind too...

Time will tell whether we are both super observant or have nasty minds. It was Laurel sitting on the bed that did it for me.

[alan45]

That went through my mind too...


Time will tell whether we are both super observant or have nasty minds. It was Laurel sitting on the bed that did it for me.

I hope you are both totally wrong

[lizann]

marshall is gay with arthur after him, doubt laurel would go there

[Perdita]

marshall is gay with arthur after him, doubt laurel would go there

I know, it just made me feel a bit uncomfortable watching her with him.

[Son of Cain]

did isaac take the telescope from lucas


I know, it just made me feel a bit uncomfortable watching her with him.

Is he gay? - I thought he said he was not sure and still to make up his mind. - He could be bi.

[lizann]

Is he gay? - I thought he said he was not sure and still to make up his mind. - He could be bi.

he told cathy and april he was gay

[Son of Cain]

he told cathy and april he was gay

Maybe I am getting confused, but I seem to remember he pull away when Arthur tried to kiss him, saying he was still unsure or confused. To be honest I could not care one way or the other as I find, Arthur and Marshall, both boring.

[Dennis tanner]

Poor Bob. He hasn't got a clue. He knew that 2 bottles had been stolen but doesn't bother to recover 2 bottles. Laurel ignores the fact that Marshall was drinking stolen vodka.

[Dennis tanner]

Yet another fool in a drunken stupor put a strain on the NHS

Why is Cathy fretting about exams. You don't need qualifications to work at The Hop.

[lizann]

will chas make a move on caleb half brother or not, very excited to have him move in

[Dennis tanner]

Poor Cathy. No wonder she's upset. It looks like she has lost her job on the tele.

[johntrevor]

will chas make a move on caleb half brother or not, very excited to have him move in

I mentioned that a few weeks ago.....it could happen, an Emmerdale first.

[Dennis tanner]

I mentioned that a few weeks ago.....it could happen, an Emmerdale first. But not a Dingle first

[Dennis tanner]

I am disappointed but not shocked that Faye is a bad un.

I was hoping to get rid of Mary.

Nobody knows Cathy in the Lakes but they soon will

[Son of Cain]

I am disappointed but not shocked that Faye is a bad un.

I was hoping to get rid of Mary.

Nobody knows Cathy in the Lakes but they soon will


Like you Dennis, I am disappointed but not shocked.The moment a Charity Fund Raising Event was mentioned, I thought scammer, or as Mary would say Grifter. Serves me right for thinking we were going to get rid of bossy busybody Mary, we will now have to put up with her for a while longer.

Wonder it when Cathy returns, she will be a new slimline version with a different head.

[Dennis tanner]

Like you Dennis, I am disappointed but not shocked.The moment a Charity Fund Raising Event was mentioned, I thought scammer, or as Mary would say Grifter. Serves me right for thinking we were going to get rid of bossy busybody Mary, we will now have to put up with her for a while longer.

Wonder it when Cathy returns, she will be a new slimline version with a different head.

It will be strange when a different Cathy returns and Heath( Her real brother ?) remains even though he never seems that bothered to be there.

Faye gets to walk away free as a bird.

Marshall and Arthur..............Boring !!!!!

Should Sarah be refering to Mckenzie as Granddad ?

[lizann]

how much did faye get, all mary's money too?

[Dennis tanner]

how much did faye get, all mary's money too?

Between ?15K and ?20K plus a camera

[Dennis tanner]

Kirk continues to be a thoughtless selfish git. He needs to get a grip.

rant over

[Son of Cain]

Kirk continues to be a thoughtless selfish git. He needs to get a grip.

rant over

Or you could say that the others need to stop going into a blind panic every time he is out of sigh for more than a few minutes.

[lizann]

Kirk continues to be a thoughtless selfish git. He needs to get a grip.

rant over

reuben sickness has brought up more grief over grace how is he selfish

[johntrevor]

reuben sickness has brought up more grief over grace how is he selfish

You are quite right, unfortunately some peoples hate for a character overides common sense.

[Dennis tanner]

Or you could say that the others need to stop going into a blind panic every time he is out of sigh for more than a few minutes.

Yes. I would agree with that.

[Dennis tanner]

You are quite right, unfortunately some peoples hate for a character overides common sense.

I totally agree as I am merely someone who loaths him rather than hates him.

[Son of Cain]

I totally agree as I am merely someone who loaths him rather than hates him.

Oh dear Dennis ! Now you have me sitting here, trying to decide which is the strongest emotion of dislike, loathing or hating?

[lizann]

caleb is mad for his pints even though broke

[lizann]

I totally agree as I am merely someone who loaths him rather than hates him.

i hate chas and amy and wendy and matty and david

[Dennis tanner]

i hate chas and amy and wendy and matty and david

Why Wendy? She's one of the few decent ones in the village of the damned

[Dennis tanner]

Oh dear Dennis ! Now you have me sitting here, trying to decide which is the strongest emotion of dislike, loathing or hating?

Your choice. I loath him because he's loathable.

[flappinfanny]

I quite enjoyed the coronation segment in the B&B. Strange no celebrations in the Woolie, perhaps it's a Yorkshire thing? Or the producers could not be arsed using their budget up with the bunting. Saving the money for Stunt week in October.I did smile at Vinny saying Mandy would get kicked out of Yorkshire for ruining decent tea. Too right.

[lizann]

Why Wendy? She's one of the few decent ones in the village of the damned

wendy the busy body fake nurse who defended her rapist son

[Dennis tanner]

wendy the busy body fake nurse who defended her rapist son

She's an excellent nurse, fake or not. She defended her son because she couldn't believe he was guilty.

[Son of Cain]

She's an excellent nurse, fake or not. She defended her son because she couldn't believe he was guilty.

Being a busybody is good enough reason for me to DISLIKE her.

[Perdita]

Being a busybody is good enough reason for me to DISLIKE her.

But aren't all the characters busybodies to some extent or other? :hmm:

[Son of Cain]

But aren't all the characters busybodies to some extent or other? :hmm:

Yes, except perhaps for Cain, and I dislike quite a lot of them too, not just for being busybodies. Top of my list would be Will and Amy. Probably be easier for me to list those I actually like.

[johntrevor]

But aren't all the characters busybodies to some extent or other? :hmm:

I think they would have to go a long way to find another busybody as good as the excellent Edna Birch.

[Perdita]

I think they would have to go a long way to find another busybody as good as the excellent Edna Birch.
Or Betty Eagleton !

[Dennis tanner]

Being a busybody is good enough reason for me to DISLIKE her.

But she was in Early Doors and I love Early Doors.

You couldn't accuse Kirk of being a busy body. He's never at work.

[lizann]

But aren't all the characters busybodies to some extent or other? :hmm:

true but wendy really irks me and i liked the actress in casualty

[Dennis tanner]

true but wendy really irks me and i liked the actress in casualty

We must remember that busybodies in soaps do it for the benefit of us viewers

[Son of Cain]

true but wendy really irks me and i liked the actress in casualty

I agree, there is just something about Wendy I find unlikable. Betty Egleton and Edna Birch, were first class, professioal premier league busybodies, but I found them enjoyable and entertaining, even though I might not have liked their characters in real life.

[Dennis tanner]

Wendy has been reading this thread and decided not to appear tonight.

[Son of Cain]

Wendy has been reading this thread and decided not to appear tonight.

Job done!

[Dennis tanner]

Job done!

It never works with Kirk.

[Son of Cain]

It never works with Kirk.

Some of us would say, as the Americans do "Good Job !".

[Dennis tanner]

I see that Justin from Corrie is now Belle's boyfriend.

[lizann]

ryan back with shiny cut locks

good acting by emma as charity but a bit pointless, she must really have fallen in love and let mack in, betrayed by sarah and ryan

[flappinfanny]

Emma Atkins as Charity take a bow, superb tonight.

[Dennis tanner]

Emma Atkins as Charity take a bow, superb tonight.

She sure was. One of her many top performances.

[Son of Cain]

ryan back with shiny cut locks

good acting by emma as charity but a bit pointless, she must really have fallen in love and let mack in, betrayed by sarah and ryan
It becomes a difficult situation when you becomes aware of a secret involving people you know. Should Sarah and Ryan have told Charity, and destroyed her happiness, or hoped that Chloe would move to Scotland and she would never know, and therefore remain happy. Years ago I worked in a place where the Assistant Manager, who was married with children, was having an affair with one of the Supervizors. Sometimes after work we would all stay behind and have a drink and a get togther. On occasion the Supervisors husband, who was a really nice guy, would join us, making a embarrassing situation. Should I or someone else have told him what was going on? Or kept the secret? This is the problem when you become aware of a secret you had no desire to know.

[johntrevor]

It becomes a difficult situation when you becomes aware of a secret involving people you know. Should Sarah and Ryan have told Charity, and destroyed her happiness, or hoped that Chloe would move to Scotland and she would never know, and therefore remain happy. Years ago I worked in a place where the Assistant Manager, who was married with children, was having an affair with one of the Supervizors. Sometimes after work we would all stay behind and have a drink and a get togther. On occasion the Supervisors husband, who was a really nice guy, would join us, making a embarrassing situation. Should I or someone else have told him what was going on? Or kept the secret? This is the problem when you become aware of a secret you had no desire to know.

Very true. I would think the best way to handle it would be to try and make the best and most honest decision you possibly could and stick to it. But of course what ever the outcome some people would always blame you for either telling the secret or keeping the secret. At the end of the day you would always be wrong in some peoples eyes.

[Dennis tanner]

It becomes a difficult situation when you becomes aware of a secret involving people you know. Should Sarah and Ryan have told Charity, and destroyed her happiness, or hoped that Chloe would move to Scotland and she would never know, and therefore remain happy. Years ago I worked in a place where the Assistant Manager, who was married with children, was having an affair with one of the Supervizors. Sometimes after work we would all stay behind and have a drink and a get togther. On occasion the Supervisors husband, who was a really nice guy, would join us, making a embarrassing situation. Should I or someone else have told him what was going on? Or kept the secret? This is the problem when you become aware of a secret you had no desire to know.

Good posting and I agree with it all.

I have to agree with Colonel Nathan R. Jessep who said, " You can't handle the truth"

[lizann]

ryan only knew he cheated but not with who or the baby

[Dennis tanner]

ryan only knew he cheated but not with who or the baby

He still knew that his mom had been betrayed.

[lizann]

He still knew that his mom had been betrayed.

true and ryan is meant to be smart

[Dennis tanner]

Why would Tom want to work at a Vets with very few customers. Does he think he will get paid ?

Sell the field Moria. You will have far less fences to look after

[lizann]

more noah charity scenes needed, they are finally in a good place, ship sarah back to debbie

[Dennis tanner]

more noah charity scenes needed, they are finally in a good place, ship sarah back to debbie

I disagree about Sarah. She didn't know what to do for the best.

[Dennis tanner]

Charity still loves her husband but feels obliged to make him suffer so she doesn't lose face.

Back to normal please Charity.

[Son of Cain]

I disagree about Sarah. She didn't know what to do for the best.

She is young, not yet turned 18, this was a huge decision and responsibility for a young person to make.

[lizann]

sarah could have spoke with moira or debbie for advice, sarah owed nothing to mack or chloe, al and chas affair secrecy should have made her speak up

[Son of Cain]

sarah could have spoke with moira or debbie for advice, sarah owed nothing to mack or chloe, al and chas affair secrecy should have made her speak up

Sarah was hoping that Chloe would move to Scotland and that Charity would never find out about Mack and Chloe. So her happiness would not be destroyed. Discussing it with Debbie or Moira would have increased the chance of the secret ceasing to be a secret. There is saying " It is very difficult to keep a secret but is even more difficult not to." I am sure most of us have been in the situation where someone has come to us and said " I really should not tell you this, as it was told to me in confidence, but ............" I think Sarah did the right thing.

[katie hunter]

I thought it was just the field that Caleb was trying to buy but it seems like he has managed to destroy Moiras entire business. Is he meant to have sabotaged the meat and damaged the machinery all while Moira and Nate were having a coffee break?

[Snagglepus]

Is he meant to have sabotaged the meat and damaged the machinery all while Moira and Nate were having a coffee break?

I wonder how he managed to open the packaging to put the bolts in without making it look disturbed.

[Dennis tanner]

Sarah was hoping that Chloe would move to Scotland and that Charity would never find out about Mack and Chloe. So her happiness would not be destroyed. Discussing it with Debbie or Moira would have increased the chance of the secret ceasing to be a secret. There is saying " It is very difficult to keep a secret but is even more difficult not to." I am sure most of us have been in the situation where someone has come to us and said " I really should not tell you this, as it was told to me in confidence, but ............" I think Sarah did the right thing.

I agree with this.

My question is. "Does Moira run a farm or a meat factory?".

Keep your vehicle locked Moira !!!!

[lizann]

for me i think sarah was more helping chloe than her gran charity, even faking an illness attack

where will cain moira and the kids move?

[Dennis tanner]

for me i think sarah was more helping chloe than her gran charity, even faking an illness attack

where will cain moira and the kids move?

Kim would not want the house. Just the land

[Son of Cain]

for me i think sarah was more helping chloe than her gran charity, even faking an illness attack



I still do not think she she was trying to help Chloe, she was trying to protect Charity. This is what happens when you learn a secret you did not want to know. It impacts on your life in a way that there is no right or wrong way to react. No matter what you do someone will be hurt.

[Son of Cain]

I wonder how he managed to open the packaging to put the bolts in without making it look disturbed.

And no one though it looked suspicious that the screws were sitting on top of the -burgers instead of being press into the meat or loose in the tray. Cain did look as if he did suspect that something was not quite right.

[Son of Cain]

Wendy has returned in full nosey busybody mode. If I was Liam I would tell Wendy and Bear to sod off, maybe less polite that that.

[johntrevor]

I still do not think she she was trying to help Chloe, she was trying to protect Charity. This is what happens when you learn a secret you did not want to know. It impacts on your life in a way that there is no right or wrong way to react. No matter what you do someone will be hurt.

True Sarah was more for protecting her gran than anything else.

[Dennis tanner]

Wendy has returned in full nosey busybody mode. If I was Liam I would tell Wendy and Bear to sod off, maybe less polite that that.

Liam is not going to tell his next girlfriend to sod off

[Son of Cain]

Liam is not going to tell his next girlfriend to sod off

Please no, that means it will be Bob and Bernice next.

[lizann]

it took bob long to get wendy in bed, but dr sexpot writer liam will do quickly

[lizann]

Kim would not want the house. Just the land

she'd love to get one over on cain, kick them out

cain did refuse to sleep with kim

[lizann]

I still do not think she she was trying to help Chloe, she was trying to protect Charity. This is what happens when you learn a secret you did not want to know. It impacts on your life in a way that there is no right or wrong way to react. No matter what you do someone will be hurt.

we will just have to disagree as we see it differently

i do think charity and mack can get through it as obviously both still love each other but can charity accept reuben

[Son of Cain]

we will just have to disagree as we see it differently

i do think charity and mack can get through it as obviously both still love each other but can charity accept reuben

I agree to disagree about Sarah. But I am now going to disagree about Charity and Mack, sorry, I would prefer to see Mack an Chloe move away together, as I do not think Charity could ever accept Reuben if Chloe stays in the village, and I do not think Mack could give up on him.

[Son of Cain]

it took bob long to get wendy in bed, but dr sexpot writer liam will do quickly

Nicola should get The Council to pass a law saying no one in the village is allowed to have a relationship with anyone else who lives in the village. This will be Liam's third villager

[Son of Cain]

What happened to Alex, last I remember he was in hospital, is he still there?

[lizann]

What happened to Alex, last I remember he was in hospital, is he still there?

scary charles threatened him so i guess gone away hiding

[lizann]

I agree to disagree about Sarah. But I am now going to disagree about Charity and Mack, sorry, I would prefer to see Mack an Chloe move away together, as I do not think Charity could ever accept Reuben if Chloe stays in the village, and I do not think Mack could give up on him.

mack needs to be there for his son, chloe annoys me, see no future for her with mack as he loves charity but she might take anything she can get from him

[Dennis tanner]

we will just have to disagree as we see it differently

i do think charity and mack can get through it as obviously both still love each other but can charity accept reuben

Why not? It's a proper Dingle name unlike Mandy or Paddy

[lizann]

caleb will even destroy his son to get tate money

[Dennis tanner]

caleb will even destroy his son to get tate money

I can't see Kim losing everything.

Question. How does Bear normally trim his beard?

[lizann]

you'd think kim would have strict security on her laptop and cameras all around home farm

[katie hunter]

you'd think kim would have strict security on her laptop and cameras all around home farm

Didn't she have cameras in the house when she caught Jamie trying to poison her?

Caleb and Nicky are having too many conversations in Home Farm, they are hardly being discreet 🙄

[Dennis tanner]

Didn't she have cameras in the house when she caught Jamie trying to poison her? Yes she did


Caleb and Nicky are having too many conversations in Home Farm, they are hardly being discreet 🙄 They are all for the benefit of us viewers,

I now realise why I have never banked on line

[lizann]

that carry on emmerdale wasn't funny

[Son of Cain]

Wendy has become very forward, is there something in the water in Emmerdale?

[Dennis tanner]

Wendy has become very forward, is there something in the water in Emmerdale?

She is merely upgrading

[lizann]

Wendy has become very forward, is there something in the water in Emmerdale?

she was prudish when with bob at first

[Dennis tanner]

she was prudish when with bob at first

She was never prudish when she worked for Ken at The Grapes.

[lizann]

bernice gaydar right about nicky

[lizann]

She is merely upgrading

the photocopier is it

[Dennis tanner]

bernice gaydar right about nicky

She had her daughter's share as well

[Son of Cain]

These episodes just get funnier and funnier, seminar - cinema, ha ha, razor rash on neck, ha ha, and mushroom vol-au-vent that tastes like glue, ha ha. No one noticed that Liam and Wendy used the exact same words, always a giveaway for police when checking all his.

Did Liam and Wendy both sleep on that examination couch?

Where is the surgery, I thought it was in the village, but Wendy arrived home by taxi?

[katie hunter]

Liam and Wendy = zero chemistry. For me they are nearly as bad a pairing as Laurel and Marlon 😔

[Dennis tanner]

Liam and Wendy = zero chemistry. For me they are nearly as bad a pairing as Laurel and Marlon 😔

Never the less they do enjoy playing Doctors and Nurses

[lizann]

Never the less they do enjoy playing Doctors and Nurses

i thought the practice was in the village but wendy came in a taxi back

[Snagglepus]

Is Pearl still living in the caravan?
No one mentions her.

[Son of Cain]

Is Charlotte the new Edna Birch?

[lizann]

some sexual tension sparks with tom and moira

[Dennis tanner]

some sexual tension sparks with tom and moira

Good job that Tom had no other jobs.
Lucky that there were only 2 other patients in A&E
Surely the accident was Nico's fault but she wasn't given a breath test.

Manpreet should have stayed with Yoda

[Perdita]

Is Charlotte the new Edna Birch?

Claudette sure is a feisty character!!! I think she could give even Edna Birch or Betty a lesson in rudeness :lol:

[Dennis tanner]

Claudette sure is a feisty character!!! I think she could give even Edna Birch or Betty a lesson in rudeness :lol:

She refused to move in the Cafe so Brenda should have refused to serve her

[Son of Cain]

I do not remember Liam ever being this horny when he was with Leyla. Is he prescribing something for himself?

[johntrevor]

Is Charlotte the new Edna Birch?

OMG I hope not. Edna did it with style, Charles's mother is just plain ignorant, should get on well with Naomi.

[johntrevor]

I do not remember Liam ever being this horny when he was with Leyla. Is he prescribing something for himself?

Best comment of the week, love it.

[lizann]

will angelica lose the leg?

[Son of Cain]

OMG I hope not. Edna did it with style, Charles's mother is just plain ignorant, should get on well with Naomi.

That explains Naomi, it must be genetic. Will Charlotte be another who comes for a visit and stay indefinitely?

[johntrevor]

That explains Naomi, it must be genetic. Will Charlotte be another who comes for a visit and stay indefinitely?

I hope not with every ounce of my being.

[Dennis tanner]

OMG I hope not. Edna did it with style, Charles's mother is just plain ignorant, should get on well with Naomi.

She was right about her son being an adulterer who stolen poor Rishi's wife.

[lizann]

That explains Naomi, it must be genetic. Will Charlotte be another who comes for a visit and stay indefinitely?

hopefully she takes charles and his family away with her soon

manpreet can join liam in a medical trouple with wendy

[Dennis tanner]

hopefully she takes charles and his family away with her soon

manpreet can join liam in a medical trouple with wendy

By naming her son Charles, we know who wore the trousers in her marriage

[Perdita]

That explains Naomi, it must be genetic. Will Charlotte be another who comes for a visit and stay indefinitely?

Have I got it wrong but I think Charles's mum is Claudette?

[Dennis tanner]

Have I got it wrong but I think Charles's mum is Claudette?

Perhaps his middle name is Claude

Shut up Nico.

You were rushing because you were late. You pulled out pulled out on to a major road without due care and attention.

[lizann]

I'd say nico caused the accident not moira

[alan45]

Surely the accident was Nico's fault but she wasn't given a breath test.



Normal practice is for both parties to be breathalysed

[Dennis tanner]

Normal practice is for both parties to be breathalysed

I agree but I reckon Nico was let off because she was doing all the complaining

[johntrevor]

I'd say nico caused the accident not moira

Next week Angel exposes Nicola as the one who caused it.

[johntrevor]

Have I got it wrong but I think Charles's mum is Claudette?

Yes it is Claudette.

[Son of Cain]

Have I got it wrong but I think Charles's mum is Claudette?

No, no, it is me that has got it wrong again. Sorry. I am still having to log in every time I visit, turn a page, thank or try to post. All this logging in take my mind off what I am posting. I have reported this to the administrators but get no response. I suspect they are hoping I will get fed up and leave the site, which I am seriously considering.

[Perdita]

No, no, it is me that has got it wrong again. Sorry. I am still having to log in every time I visit, turn a page, thank or try to post. All this logging in take my mind off what I am posting. I have reported this to the administrators but get no response. I suspect they are hoping I will get fed up and leave the site, which I am seriously considering.

Please stay, I look forward to your comments because they usually make perfect sense

[Perdita]

Please stay, your comments as a rule always make sense

[lizann]

No, no, it is me that has got it wrong again. Sorry. I am still having to log in every time I visit, turn a page, thank or try to post. All this logging in take my mind off what I am posting. I have reported this to the administrators but get no response. I suspect they are hoping I will get fed up and leave the site, which I am seriously considering.

ill ask norman about this for you

[Son of Cain]

Please stay, your comments as a rule always make sense

Thank you for your kind remarks, glad you look forward to my comments. Trying to decide what is best "usually make perfect sense" or "as a rule always make sense.

[Son of Cain]

ill ask norman about this for you

Thanks I would really appreciate that. This has been happening for several months now. It is only on SoapBoards I have a problem.

[johntrevor]

Thank you for your kind remarks, glad you look forward to my comments. Trying to decide what is best "usually make perfect sense" or "as a rule always make sense.

I will clarify for you....Your comments ALWAYS make sense to me.

[Perdita]

Thank you for your kind remarks, glad you look forward to my comments. Trying to decide what is best "usually make perfect sense" or "as a rule always make sense.
Always make sense

[Dennis tanner]

Nico really annoys me.

Why can't she just accept that it was an accident instead of trying to get Moira prosecuted ???

Ryan's friend became really really interested when she learnt that he owned half the pub

[lizann]

wendy buys all the magazines, charges them to liam in the practice, what a pile of crap this wendy liam nonsense

[Dennis tanner]

wendy buys all the magazines, charges them to liam in the practice, what a pile of crap this wendy liam nonsense

Not quite. She paid for them herself and claimed the money back from Liam ( expenses)

[Son of Cain]

Judging by all the magazines Wendy was buying, patients must have to spend an awful long time waiting to see a doctor.

[Son of Cain]

Nico really annoys me.

Why can't she just accept that it was an accident instead of trying to get Moira prosecuted ???



Maybe it is guilt. The way the accident was filmed it is hard to see who was at fault. But Nicola did not seem to be driving "with due care and attention". Approaching the junction she was arguing with Angel in the back seat frequently turning round taking her eyes of the road. I cannot remember if Nicola was driving during the time when she was suffering PTSD and was probably not sleeping well.

[Dennis tanner]

Judging by all the magazines Wendy was buying, patients must have to spend an awful long time waiting to see a doctor.

Probably because there is only ever one of them working.

[Son of Cain]

Even though Manpreet was proved right her attitude to Claudette (got it right this time) was not very sympathetic for a doctor. It was fairly obvious that there was more to Claudette turning up on their doorstep than met the eye..

[Dennis tanner]

Even though Manpreet was proved right her attitude to Claudette (got it right this time) was not very sympathetic for a doctor. It was fairly obvious that there was more to Claudette turning up on their doorstep than met the eye..

Probably homeless

[Perdita]

Charles is getting on my nerves...

[Son of Cain]

Charles is getting on my nerves...

"Getting on your nerves ?" - Charles has always got on my nerves".

[Perdita]

"Getting on your nerves ?" - Charles has always got on my nerves".

Naomi is going soon .. will Claudette go with her? Please ... and then Charles and Ethan... :D

[Dennis tanner]

Naomi is going soon .. will Claudette go with her? Please ... and then Charles and Ethan... :D

Agree with all that. If you are homeless why would you think it would be a good tactic to lie to your son and be obnoxious to his partner and all his neighbours ?

[Perdita]

Agree with all that. If you are homeless why would you think it would be a good tactic to lie to your son and be obnoxious to his partner and all his neighbours ?

Being honest and telling the truth is just not a soapland trait ...

[Son of Cain]

Naomi is going soon .. will Claudette go with her? Please ... and then Charles and Ethan... :D

I have a terrible feeling that if Naomi goes will be left with Claudette INSTEAD of her. If it has to be one or the other, I think I would rather we kept Naomi.

[Perdita]

I have a terrible feeling that if Naomi goes will be left with Claudette INSTEAD of her. If it has to be one or the other, I think I would rather we kept Naomi.

I think you might be right but maybe Claudette's attitude will change once she knows she is safe with the vicar and the woman he lives with over the brush....

[Dennis tanner]

Carl could possibly lodge with Rishi

[Son of Cain]

I think you might be right but maybe Claudette's attitude will change once she knows she is safe with the vicar and the woman he lives with over the brush....

Even Edna Birch had her softer moments. - Thinking about it, we do need someone to put the gossip known as Brenda in her place now and again, and maybe Nicola too.

[Son of Cain]

Judging by Moira's tan, it must be sunnier in Yorkshire than I thought it was. As a busy farmer she could not possibly have time to visit a tanning salon.

[lizann]

Naomi is going soon .. will Claudette go with her? Please ... and then Charles and Ethan... :D

where is ethan

[Perdita]

where is ethan

I am wondering too

[Dennis tanner]

where is ethan

Ethan is in the Ether.

[johntrevor]

Naomi is going soon .. will Claudette go with her? Please ... and then Charles and Ethan... :D

Yes please all the above ...Please go.

[Snagglepus]

where is ethan
He is asking Pearl to come back to the Village and can Claudette rent her caravan.

[lizann]

belle is telling tom everything fast

please go away chloe

[katie hunter]

Moira said the farm sale was due to go through next week. If Caleb is caught next week, could the sale fall through?

[katie hunter]

belle is telling tom everything fast

please go away chloe

I don't like how Mack and Chloe are being pushed together. I would like to see Charity and Mack reunited but I fear the writers might want to pair him up with Chloe so Charity is free when Vanessa returns 🙄

[Dennis tanner]

I don't like how Mack and Chloe are being pushed together. I would like to see Charity and Mack reunited but I fear the writers might want to pair him up with Chloe so Charity is free when Vanessa returns 🙄

CHarity should take him back and tell him he is allowed a supervised visit to Reubin once a week

[tammyy2j]

Moira said the farm sale was due to go through next week. If Caleb is caught next week, could the sale fall through?

Is contracts documentation signed or just a casual handshake deal?

[Son of Cain]

Is contracts documentation signed or just a casual handshake deal?

I don't think Kim does casual handshake deals.

If Moira does sell the farm, I am struggling to think what her role in the village would be.

[Dennis tanner]

I don't think Kim does casual handshake deals.

If Moira does sell the farm, I am struggling to think what her role in the village would be.

Working in a Dingle owned pub

[lizann]

Working in a Dingle owned pub

which rarely has paying customers not dingles

[Son of Cain]

I don't like how Mack and Chloe are being pushed together. I would like to see Charity and Mack reunited but I fear the writers might want to pair him up with Chloe so Charity is free when Vanessa returns 🙄

I still think Mack and Chloe will leave the village together and go to Scotland.

[Perdita]

I still think Mack and Chloe will leave the village together and go to Scotland.

ugggh hope not .. hope Chloe leaves with Reuben never to be seen again ..

[Son of Cain]

ugggh hope not .. hope Chloe leaves with Reuben never to be seen again ..

Personally I would rather see Amy go, never to be seen again. Perhaps both will go, never to be seen again, then we will both be happy.

[Dennis tanner]

Personally I would rather see Amy go, never to be seen again. Perhaps both will go, never to be seen again, then we will both be happy.

I would much prefer to see the back of Paddy Kirk and Mandy Dingle

[flappinfanny]

I loved the hen night in the Woolie and especially Kim.

[alan45]

I would much prefer to see the back of Paddy Kirk and Mandy Dingle

NO!! Keep Paddy and get shot of Mandy

[johntrevor]

NO!! Keep Paddy and get shot of Mandy

Completely agree

[Dennis tanner]

NO!! Keep Paddy and get shot of Mandy

Why keep him. The buffoon is neither use nor ornament

[lizann]

id say kim knows

[Dennis tanner]

I don't understand why Caleb is so desperate for the wedding to go ahead. Isn't he just being greedy ???

[Son of Cain]

Why keep him. The buffoon is neither use nor ornament

Who else would Marlon play Zombie games with?

[Son of Cain]

"It's really not my bag, all this wordy stuff" says Charles. Good job vicars do not have to write sermons.

[Dennis tanner]

"It's really not my bag, all this wordy stuff" says Charles. Good job vicars do not have to write sermons.

But we have never seen an Emmerdale vicar or any soap vicar do a sermon or any part of a sermon

[Son of Cain]

But we have never seen an Emmerdale vicar or any soap vicar do a sermon or any part of a sermon

Probably because "words are not their bag".

Although I think we have seen Charles at weddings and funerals.

[Dennis tanner]

Probably because "words are not their bag".

Although I think we have seen Charles at weddings and funerals.

Yes but these are easy. It's the same words every time which can be read from a book.

[katie hunter]

For the first time in a long time, I am excited to find out what happens tomorrow night. Hopefully there isn't too much of simpering Chloe 😴 to spoil it

[Dennis tanner]

Now that she has rejected Bear, who is going to be Mandy's customer ?

[alan45]

For the first time in a long time, I am excited to find out what happens tomorrow night. Hopefully there isn't too much of simpering Chloe 😴 to spoil it

So delighted to see Cain appear at the door instead of PC Swirling. I wonder how long Cain has been aware of Caleb double crossing Kim and how she will reward him.

[lizann]

well i did not expect kim and cain teaming up, caleb did help kyle

[Dennis tanner]

well i did not expect kim and cain teaming up, caleb did help kyle

Yes he did but he also wanted the farm. Perhaps Kim will give them a bit of help.

[Son of Cain]

One illegitimate son exposed, now a jailbird father turns up to join a homeless mum. This has certainly been a time for secret relatives. I don't think God is smiling on Charles.

[Son of Cain]

I am still confused as go whether Caleb has money or not, he still has a Bentley and was able to hire a firm of top class criminal lawyers. So is he a successful businessman or not?

[Dennis tanner]

I am still confused as go whether Caleb has money or not, he still has a Bentley and was able to hire a firm of top class criminal lawyers. So is he a successful businessman or not?

Perhaps he owes a lot of money.

I always knew that Charles was a bad un.

A good episode apart from the Kirk and Mandy bits

[katie hunter]

I am still confused as go whether Caleb has money or not, he still has a Bentley and was able to hire a firm of top class criminal lawyers. So is he a successful businessman or not?

I agree. I guess the car could be leased but that still doesn't explain how he paid for Kyle's defence?

[Dennis tanner]

I agree. I guess the car could be leased but that still doesn't explain how he paid for Kyle's defence?

Borrowed money to be paid back when he won.

I still don't see why he needed to involve Nicky. That was just unnecessary greed.

[lizann]

I am still confused as go whether Caleb has money or not, he still has a Bentley and was able to hire a firm of top class criminal lawyers. So is he a successful businessman or not?

yes some holes in the story

did caleb say faith left him a letter, did faith know about kim and frank? which is why the balcony push

[lizann]

jack victoria and debbie missing sarah's 18th

[Son of Cain]

I agree. I guess the car could be leased but that still doesn't explain how he paid for Kyle's defence?

I thought that, but it would still cost over 2K a month to lease it. But then Nicky was talking about his mother becoming homeless. They introduce these stories without filling any of the background details which would make them credible. Has Cain now lost his long lost brother or will Caleb "return" ?
Guess now we will have some incredible tales of Charles past.

[johntrevor]

I am still confused as go whether Caleb has money or not, he still has a Bentley and was able to hire a firm of top class criminal lawyers. So is he a successful businessman or not?

I got the impression he was being bankrolled by Adrian, I thought he said to Nicky once that Adrian was asking when he would get his money back.

[Son of Cain]

I got the impression he was being bankrolled by Adrian, I thought he said to Nicky once that Adrian was asking when he would get his money back.

Thanks - must have missed that bit. I thought Adrian was just supplying tech to hack the lap top. To be honest we saw so little of him, I have to admit, I never really noticed him. Perhaps the tale is not over yet, and it will continue, although there is a habit in Soaps, that stories end rather suddenly and are rarely mentioned again.

[lizann]

daddy of charles could be charles brother as look close in age

[Dennis tanner]

On Sunday, Charles will be preaching about forgiveness......hypocrit.

[lizann]

naomi is an idiot, anyone can see the granny is scared

chas was never in dingle court over what she did to paddy, cheating with al, liv's death

[Dennis tanner]

naomi is an idiot, Agreed but she understands that Charles is not a Christian


chas was never in dingle court over what she did to paddy, cheating with al, liv's death

Dingle court ??? What a farce.

[Dennis tanner]

Victor claims that he has paid his debt to society. Where did he get the money from ?

He now claims there are easier ways to make money than armed robbery. What did he have in mind ?

[lizann]

Victor claims that he has paid his debt to society. Where did he get the money from ?

He now claims there are easier ways to make money than armed robbery. What did he have in mind ?

he is probably planning robbing somewhere in the village but where as no where makes money

did gabby not trade with kim her shares for the hide and hop so she is the boss not kim

caleb and charity work for me, there is chemistry

[katie hunter]

We heard Caleb tell Nicky many times that Nicky's mother would lose her home if he didn't get Kim's money. Now he can afford to buy two flats?

Despite the long list of suspects I still think it is Nicky who has pushed Caleb.

Chloe is obviously trying to secure a future for her and her baby but she is deluded if she thinks Mack is over Charity🙄

[Dennis tanner]

We heard Caleb tell Nicky many times that Nicky's mother would lose her home if he didn't get Kim's money. Now he can afford to buy two flats? Good question and I can only assume it is borrowed


Despite the long list of suspects I still think it is Nicky who has pushed Caleb. Could well be


Chloe is obviously trying to secure a future for her and her baby Security with a man who has never had a proper job ?


but she is deluded if she thinks Mack is over Charity🙄 Agreed

[flappinfanny]

Enjoyable double bill tonight, highly camp but amusing, who has done it ........ if we are to believe the suspects are the ones we saw at the end entering through the door, my money's on Leyla. Soap of the night.

[lizann]

coincidence caleb took a walk in the woods to scream

think it was nicky who pushed him

i really wanted caleb to start on chas

[johntrevor]

Enjoyable double bill tonight, highly camp but amusing, who has done it ........ if we are to believe the suspects are the ones we saw at the end entering through the door, my money's on Leyla. Soap of the night.

The way it was set up for the viewers we are meant to believe it was one of those entering. Which makes me think it won't be. I stick by my original guess of Nicky.

[johntrevor]

coincidence caleb took a walk in the woods to scream

think it was nicky who pushed him

i really wanted caleb to start on chas

Yes seemed a bit rich of Chas lecturing Charity about Caleb. She has soon forgotten about what dhe did with Al.

[Son of Cain]

The way it was set up for the viewers we are meant to believe it was one of those entering. Which makes me think it won't be. I stick by my original guess of Nicky.

Unfortunately, I am pretty sure Caleb will not be dead. So we wiil have more of his tedious antics to endure. How many times have we seen this scenario, or variations of it, before? Character goes round insulting and upsetting various other characters. Then goes off for a walk in the woods, or somewhere else, on their own and comes to sticky end, or in this case, probably not quite an end. - Memories of Al. - Such imagination. - Caleb is a character who has been introduced, purely to fit this story of ripping of Kim, and upsetting his family, but there is no substance to him. He is supposedly rich and successful in some field of business but never actually does any work. He has now bought Vinny's house, as a cash buyer, but has he actually given Vinny the money, or has he promised to when some deal goes through? Part of his reason for stealing from Kim, was to buy a house for Nick's mother, his wife?
Who he does not seem very close to. He is now going about upsetting people, is this because of feelings of guilt, and he wants to be punished by getting beat up? But I think not, as he seems ready to fight back.

Did I hear someone say Kim had introduced Wolves to the woods, in a rewilding programme? Hope so, tonight's episode opens with only bones left.

[katie hunter]

How many times have we seen this scenario, or variations of it, before? Character goes round insulting various other characters. Then goes off for a walk in the woods, or somewhere else, on their own and comes to sticky end, or in this case, probably not quite an end. - Memories of Al. - Such imagination. -



I thought the scene was very similar to when Cain argued with various villagers in the pub (Jai, Charity, John, Moira, Chas) and was then hit over the head by an unknown assailant who turned out to be Zak.

[Son of Cain]

So no wolves then, Pity.

[Dennis tanner]

Unfortunately, I am pretty sure Caleb will not be dead. So we wiil have more of his tedious antics to endure. How many times have we seen this scenario, or variations of it, before? Character goes round insulting and upsetting various other characters. Then goes off for a walk in the woods, or somewhere else, on their own and comes to sticky end, or in this case, probably not quite an end. - Memories of Al. - Such imagination. - Caleb is a character who has been introduced, purely to fit this story of ripping of Kim, and upsetting his family, but there is no substance to him. He is supposedly rich and successful in some field of business but never actually does any work. He has now bought Vinny's house, as a cash buyer, but has he actually given Vinny the money, or has he promised to when some deal goes through? Part of his reason for stealing from Kim, was to buy a house for Nick's mother, his wife?
Who he does not seem very close to. He is now going about upsetting people, is this because of feelings of guilt, and he wants to be punished by getting beat up? But I think not, as he seems ready to fight back.

Did I hear someone say Kim had introduced Wolves to the woods, in a rewilding programme? Hope so, tonight's episode opens with only bones left.

The only reason he acts like he does is because it's in the script and the script rarely has to be logical.

[lizann]

angel is a mini nico

[Dennis tanner]

angel is a mini nico

Good call.

Mack and Chloe are well on their way to a stable and secure relationship.

[Son of Cain]

Good call.

Mack and Chloe are well on their way to a stable and secure relationship.

Sarcasm? - Or a desire to see a happy couple?

[lizann]

mack wants charity back but using chloe, parading her around like a prize donkey isn't going win her back

[Dennis tanner]

Sarcasm? - Or a desire to see a happy couple?

sarcasm but there again I like almost everyone to be happy