Emmerdale - Current Episode Discussion - III

[lizann]

mack features less and less, more ross with charity

[Snagglepus]

If it is discovered that Joe has stolen Caleb's kidney, can he be made to give it back?

[lizann]

ross was good with steph when she was telling about anthony

[Dennis tanner]

If it is discovered that Joe has stolen Caleb's kidney, can he be made to give it back?

Good question and I doubt that caleb could get it back

[Son of Cain]

If it is discovered that Joe has stolen Caleb's kidney, can he be made to give it back?

Exactly the question I was going to ask. If I was Caleb I would insist he he does. Now that would make a very interesting story line. But I do not think I will hold my breath waiting for them to tackle it.

[Son of Cain]

How on earth did the police manage to arrest Knifey Shaun so quickly, did he give himself up ? How did Joe manage to hire such an idiot? None of that plan made any sense. Presumably the plan was not to actually stab Caleb, but when he did, why did he not throw him in the back of his car instead of doing a runner?

Are Joe and Caleb in the same hospital, or is Joe still in the private clinic? Even so, when the case of Caleb's stolen kidney makes it into the media, surely the clinic will put two and two together.

[johntrevor]

How on earth did the police manage to arrest Knifey Shaun so quickly, did he give himself up ? How did Joe manage to hire such an idiot? None of that plan made any sense. Presumably the plan was not to actually stab Caleb, but when he did, why did he not throw him in the back of his car instead of doing a runner?

Are Joe and Caleb in the same hospital, or is Joe still in the private clinic? Even so, when the case of Caleb's stolen kidney makes it into the media, surely the clinic will put two and two together.

Of course not, lol.....Then it will turn into Carry on Regardless, or Carry on Carrying On.

[lizann]

joe took caleb to what looked like a large shed, joe told kim and dawn he was gone chicago, i think as ross saw the doc with him, he will ask more on manpreet, let him with steph solve it fast

[ccahill2]

I didn't know Ross during his previous appearances, because I hadn't yet started to watch this show, but I am really liking his character. I like how he cares about April, and I absolutely loved how he managed Steph's confession yesterday. They are a cute couple and probably my favorite current couple.

I don't know why they are making Liam into this judgmental person, but I am not liking him very much with the way he's treated Ella. I've been hoping to like him and Chas, but I just think they bring out the worst in each other.

[ccahill2]

I am a little confused with the story. At first Crowley said that he couldn't take the damaged kidney from Caleb because if he harvested the healthy one, he would die.

But then he put it into Joe and said that the knife just missed hitting the kidney. So which is it? Does Joe have a now-damaged kidney inside of him (karma) or is it a healthy kidney?

I love the idea of them getting caught and the kidney given back to Caleb, but I don't know whether Joe's antibodies would have damaged it to the point where it would be harder for Caleb to get it back without anti-rejection drugs.

If they can't re-harvest it, I'm hoping that there is a rejection and Joe loses the kidney and sepsis then takes over.

I loved the fanfic that Joe takes Steph's kidney, thinking her to be Caleb's daughter, and then he dies.