Emmerdale - Current Episode Discussion - III

[lizann]

They are certsinly piling on the misery in "The Village of the Damned". Are there any happy stories at the moment.

piper alive is the best thing

[Dennis tanner]

This story makes no sense, even less sense than most stories that make no sense. Although Tom said he and Rhona were working on Piper all night, we did not hear her confirm this, so was Rhona there all night or not, and if so what were they doing since as it turns out Piper was not badly injured. When Tom handed Piper over to the new owners, she did not seem badly hurt, if indeed she was hurt at all. Yet when Belle saw her at the vet's she seemed to be at death's door, she did not turn her head to look at Belle. Had Tom tranquilized her? The strangest part was when Belle accused Tom, in the street, of killing Piper, Rhona did not say that Piper was OK, as she must have been because we saw her being given to the new owners and she was, unless she had suddenly made a miraculous recovery. In order to make Tom even more nasty, the writers are going too far, so far that they are contradicting themselves.

Wait! Yes it does all make sense - Piper is dead, and Tom has found a doppelganger.

Yes makes no sense. Tom was lucky that Belle did not want to see inside the 'coffin'

[Son of Cain]

Yes makes no sense. Tom was lucky that Belle did not want to see inside the 'coffin'

I am surprised that Belle did not ask Rhona if Piper had suffered, in which case Tom's lie would have been found out. Since it now seems that Piper was not badly hurt, was Rhona really there all night, even though it was shown to us, she was helping Tom. If you are going to lie then you should tell a lie that will stand up to some scrutiny. Personally I think Belle would have spent the night at the Vet's instead of going home for the night. I feel this story showed a lack of respect to us viewers and is an insult to our intelligence.

[Perdita]

I am surprised that Belle did not ask Rhona if Piper had suffered, in which case Tom's lie would have been found out. Since it now seems that Piper was not badly hurt, was Rhona really there all night, even though it was shown to us, she was helping Tom. If you are going to lie then you should tell a lie that will stand up to some scrutiny. Personally I think Belle would have spent the night at the Vet's instead of going home for the night. I feel this story showed a lack of respect to us viewers and is an insult to our intelligence.

Vets usually advise pet owners to go home and wait for a result of a surgery, I had to wait over night for my two girls after they were spayed before I could pick them up. The vet phoned me after both surgeries were completed to let me know all went well and they were sleeping. As soon as the vet was open I was there to collect my very happy dogs, they did not even have a cone of shame, I was told that if they start messing with the stitches they would provide me with them.. did not need them ..

[lizann]

piper might return home by herself but will anyone believe belle if she says it

[lizann]

has dawn got rose and they want to punish will so lying about evan

[ccahill2]

And in the meantime pretty much broke up Kim's marriage although Kim was amazing to her. Really nice.

[Dennis tanner]

I haven't a clue what has happened to Rose.

[Son of Cain]

Vets usually advise pet owners to go home and wait for a result of a surgery, I had to wait over night for my two girls after they were spayed before I could pick them up. The vet phoned me after both surgeries were completed to let me know all went well and they were sleeping. As soon as the vet was open I was there to collect my very happy dogs, they did not even have a cone of shame, I was told that if they start messing with the stitches they would provide me with them.. did not need them ..

When it is routine surgery I am sure vets will say that, but knowing how much Belle loved Piper I think she would have insisted on waiting at the vet's. Although Piper had a "Cone of Shame", l never knew they were called that, as far as we could see Piper had no injuries, no shaved patches, no sign of stitches, at least they could have used some food dye to look like iodine. If Piper had been so badly injured that it had two vets working on her all night, would she be in a fit state to be given to a new owner so soon.

[Son of Cain]

And in the meantime pretty much broke up Kim's marriage although Kim was amazing to her. Really nice.

Rose did her a favour, Kim is well shot of dozy Will.