Emmerdale - Current Episode Discussion - III

[alcapo11]

Katie's death was clearly an accident though she only died due to the floor collapsing Robert could not of foreseen that happening, Robert was just trying to lock her in the barn that day so she wouldn't storm his wedding.

But the difference is with Ross is... Robert stopped himself going too far on both occasions he stopped the hitman in his tracks realising it was a despicable act & yesterday he had all the motive to kill Ross & yet didn't touch him Ross on the other hand spent almost an entire episode pleading with Andy to agree to murder 2 people between them & he then DID pull the trigger.

I have no sympathy with either Ross or Andy here losing Debbie or the kids both should be counting themselves lucky they got away with it are not in prison. And nobody in the village that knows has brought up the fact both men sat back and did nothing while an innocent person (Aaron) was nearly sent down for their crime.

I think your forgetting the reason Robert called off the hitman, it was because Chas had changed her mind about telling Chrissie about the affair. Had she not Robert would of been responsible for 2 deaths. Also eve if he didn't mean to kill Katie he still meant to hurt her and was pushing her around and making threats. One last thing, it isn't Ross' fault that Aaron was thick and picked up the gun and hid it in a shockingly bad place instead of just getting rid of it.

[alcapo11]

Katie's death was clearly an accident though she only died due to the floor collapsing Robert could not of foreseen that happening, Robert was just trying to lock her in the barn that day so she wouldn't storm his wedding.

But the difference is with Ross is... Robert stopped himself going too far on both occasions he stopped the hitman in his tracks realising it was a despicable act & yesterday he had all the motive to kill Ross & yet didn't touch him Ross on the other hand spent almost an entire episode pleading with Andy to agree to murder 2 people between them & he then DID pull the trigger.

I have no sympathy with either Ross or Andy here losing Debbie or the kids both should be counting themselves lucky they got away with it are not in prison. And nobody in the village that knows has brought up the fact both men sat back and did nothing while an innocent person (Aaron) was nearly sent down for their crime.

I think your forgetting the reason Robert called off the hitman, it was because Chas had changed her mind about telling Chrissie about the affair. Had she not Robert would of been responsible for 2 deaths. Also eve if he didn't mean to kill Katie he still meant to hurt her and was pushing her around and making threats. One last thing, it isn't Ross' fault that Aaron was thick and picked up the gun and hid it in a shockingly bad place instead of just getting rid of it.

[lizann]

cain didn't even get to say goodbye to debbie

[flappinfanny]

I do not think that is entirely accurate, I read an interview with Steve Halliwell and he said he was pleased with the storyline. He liked Zak doing something different falling in love with another woman. Lisa Dingle is a bore and a miserable cow. I can see why Zak dumped her for Joanie.

Thats ok then. Well done Zak.

I stand by what I said, I don't believe Zak would have cheated on Lisa even if she is 'bore and a miserable cow.'

It is funny how we read different story's on the web, mags and in the red tops and it makes you wonder who is right? Jane Cox's concerns I read were on DS.

I am so pleased the Dingles have disowned Zak, I wonder if this will lead to his depression re surfacing and it is not only Ross that needs a bullet to the head. Is there one left for Ms Oates, or has she already left by taxi?

I dread to think what she will do when she arrives in Weatherfield.

[mariba]

I just don't understand ' disowning ' someone in your own family unless they have done something really bad.Even then, it feels so ridiculous to demand that everyone turns their backs to that person and have nothing to do with them!!? Does anyone actually do that in real life?? If anyone, Charity should have been disowned and for good!! She has done some bad stuff..

[Splashy]

I just don't understand ' disowning ' someone in your own family unless they have done something really bad.Even then, it feels so ridiculous to demand that everyone turns their backs to that person and have nothing to do with them!!? Does anyone actually do that in real life?? If anyone, Charity should have been disowned and for good!! She has done some bad stuff..

I've disowned a relative as they lie cheat & steal from everyone to get what they want Recently it was £25,000 from a relative with dementia bank account, I managed to stop £75,000 following it, but its messy. The person who transferred the money was duped into acting on the power of the will, the relative isnt dead!!! No one has the power of attorney so this act is criminal theft, a situation I cant make the transfer er compute, they could potentially go to prison especially as the dosh was sent abroad.

Because I stopped the £75k going it became twisted back on me and I was shunned for a month? But I am powerless as if I kick off someone here not abroad cold be in real problems with the police.

Anywho, didnt they boot Marlon at one point? Its a shame Belles taking sides, the relationships end, grow up lady, Cain is reacting like he is as it reminds him of history.

[Splashy]

I just don't understand ' disowning ' someone in your own family unless they have done something really bad.Even then, it feels so ridiculous to demand that everyone turns their backs to that person and have nothing to do with them!!? Does anyone actually do that in real life?? If anyone, Charity should have been disowned and for good!! She has done some bad stuff..

I've disowned a relative as they lie cheat & steal from everyone to get what they want Recently it was £25,000 from a relative with dementia bank account, I managed to stop £75,000 following it, but its messy. The person who transferred the money was duped into acting on the power of the will, the relative isnt dead!!! No one has the power of attorney so this act is criminal theft, a situation I cant make the transfer er compute, they could potentially go to prison especially as the dosh was sent abroad.

Because I stopped the £75k going it became twisted back on me and I was shunned for a month? But I am powerless as if I kick off someone here not abroad cold be in real problems with the police.

Anywho, didnt they boot Marlon at one point? Its a shame Belles taking sides, the relationships end, grow up lady, Cain is reacting like he is as it reminds him of history.

[sarah c]

and how is joanie so interesting and not boring?

and Zak is so scintillating too??!!

at least Lisa works to provide for her family, Zak bums around doing Jack, and Joanie 'sings' for a living

sometimes doing 'real life' as Lisa does, does bring you down a bit

[sarah c]

Yes-Robert has done so much and far worse than Andy. Andy planned the plot, but he didn't do his part-he wasn't right in his head and it was stupid from Ross to go ahead with the plan.
Robert killed Katie. Is there much worse than that?!
I can fully understand that he's upset for losing his kids too after everything! Why is it that when a man cries, they are being ridiculed and laughed at??

no Robert covered up Katie's death he didn't actually kill her

Andy beat his wife black and blue?

[Splashy]

no Robert covered up Katie's death he didn't actually kill her

Andy beat his wife black and blue?

He certainly had no intent to kill but he did physically throw/push her leading to her demise. He may have got away with that had he called an ambulance. But following the cover up and the now known motive he had, I wouldnt rate his chances in court. Its Belles case all over again kinda an accident but in Bells case Lisas demented cover up did for her.

Marlon judging Zak, what a hypocrite