Lucy Beale

[sarah c]

Lauren was a prime suspect. What alibi did she give to DI Keeble and how did DI Keeble follow it up...or did the police stop investigating when Emma was taken off the case?

she said she was at Roxy's party didnt she?

which when the fat-boy video came out showed she was missing

[Kissinger]

Blimey us lot are certainly checking out all the albis and dotting the i's and xing the t's.
Hope the producers are well sorted with their story!!!

[nettapet]

Lauren was a prime suspect. What alibi did she give to DI Keeble and how did DI Keeble follow it up...or did the police stop investigating when Emma was taken off the case?

Lauren told Keeble she was at Roxy's party but had left early to go home. It was only when the video was discovered on Fatboy's phone that anyone knew she'd gone to the Beale's house, only one's that knew about the video were Fatboy, Lee & Emma.

[Dazzle]

I am still interested in why Jane sent Beth the music box as a Christmas present. Some are saying it was Emma but Jane would of hidden it because its a murder weapon and how would Emma even get it in the first place.

Ian said he'd given the music box to the charity shop so anyone could have bought it. I still think it was most likely to have been Emma as she was watching everyone suspiciously Christmas Day. It's credible that she put it under the tree to see people's reactions.

I also hope this isn't the end of Jane - I'd like to see her in the show and how the future will be affected and if she reveals all, will Ian understand?

More importantly if Ian finds out about Bobby, will he keep quiet too? o.O

I think Ian will keep quite and I don't think Jane's going anywhere. The story about how the Beale family deals with this is going to be ongoing from what I've heard.

[owenlee4me]

Ian said he'd given the music box to the charity shop so anyone could have bought it. I still think it was most likely to have been Emma as she was watching everyone suspiciously Christmas Day. It's credible that she put it under the tree to see people's reactions.



I think Ian will keep quite and I don't think Jane's going anywhere. The story about how the Beale family deals with this is going to be ongoing from what I've heard.

I'm curious as to why it showed Lucy opening the window shortly before she started writing her note/letter?
I know we have not seen how she died yet, but how on earth did she end up in the wood area?
Hardly likely, Jane moved the body on her own, so she must have had an accomplice?

[owenlee4me]

Ian said he'd given the music box to the charity shop so anyone could have bought it. I still think it was most likely to have been Emma as she was watching everyone suspiciously Christmas Day. It's credible that she put it under the tree to see people's reactions.



I think Ian will keep quite and I don't think Jane's going anywhere. The story about how the Beale family deals with this is going to be ongoing from what I've heard.

I'm curious as to why it showed Lucy opening the window shortly before she started writing her note/letter?
I know we have not seen how she died yet, but how on earth did she end up in the wood area?
Hardly likely, Jane moved the body on her own, so she must have had an accomplice?

[lizann]

My guess would be that after looking at photographs of the layout of the square (which we saw Emma looking at after she received the video of Lauren visiting the Beale house) that she realised Jane had given Lauren a false alibi. Jane said she saw Lauren from the Masood's window & she never entered the Beale house, but looking at maps of the square there's no way you can see the front door of the Beale's house from the Masood house.

emma had a light bulb moment too in the pub why?

[sarah c]

no it cannot have been Emma that 'gave' the music box to Beth - if as a police officer she knew it was the murder weapon she would never have compromised it by giving it away?

[Dazzle]

no it cannot have been Emma that 'gave' the music box to Beth - if as a police officer she knew it was the murder weapon she would never have compromised it by giving it away?

That's a fair point but maybe she didn't know anything for sure at that time and she did it to see who'd react? She hadn't even gone to the police after she'd talked to Jane (presumably) in the park so she wasn't in any rush to do anything official. She was probably about to go to the police when she was killed. (Remember she was no longer a police officer by this time.)

Cindy was possibly in on it as there's been a lot of looks between her and Jane this week. She may have helped Jane move the body. Why she'd put the music box under the tree I can't imagine though.

The best explanation I can think of why anyone would put the box there is to provoke a reaction and I can't think of anyone else who'd want to do that (unless somebody else guessed, but that's all getting too convoluted!).

[parkerman]

Now we know who killed Lucy, there's more questions than before we knew!