The X Factor - General Discussion

[*-Rooney-*]

yeah gary barlow would be a good judge

[Abbie]

yeah gary barlow would be a good judge

yeah he would

[tammyy2j]

Gary Barlow or Robbie Williams would be good choices as judges

get rid of Cheryl and Dannii

[*-Rooney-*]

no not robbie

[Trinity]

I think that Dannii is a good judge, she may not be quite such a good mentor though - her choice of songs etc. And I think that she gives Brian too much of a free rain with his 'interpretation' of songs.

Gary Barlow would be excellent. Thorough knowledge of music - experience of song writing (successfully) as well as performing.

Robbie Williams - unreliable egoist - this show is supposed to be about nurturing and producing talent, it shouldn't be so much about the judges.

Sharon Osborne was the same Me! Me! Me!

[Bryan]

As much as I fail to see why Dann is there, with her being a useless musician, she is actually a fairly ok judge, better than Cheryl in my opinion. She does give constructive criticsm, and tends to care about her asks. I think I just get annoyed at the fact that she's in that position when she hasn't got much experience of the music industry, she's no Kylie Minouge at the end of the day.

I expected better things of Cheryl if I'm honest, in the auditions it seemed she'd be great, but she's been a bit of a let down.

Good lord, Gary Barlow as a judge, no way, I'd swicth off. I reckon the panel will stay the same next year if i'm honest. The show needs to focus on the acts and not the ego-centric judges.

[CrazyLea]

I was just chatting with my mum and she just made me fume kinda.

I think the reason the people who don't like Dannii; whether that be as a person, or as a judge is simply because... "She is not Kylie".

Whether you like her or not, she has got a good voice and she is a good judge.. but people can't see passed the whole. "She's Kylie's sister... she's not as good".... of course she isn't as good as Kylie... neither is Cheryl or Simon at singing.. does that make them not good judges. NO. It doesn't.

I now feel sorry for Dannii as she is constantly compared to Kylie. She HAS got a good voice. Bet 90% of the people on this board alone who don't like her, can't sing as well as her?? I know I can't sing as well as her...

If she wasn't Kylie's sister then hardley any of the people who do say bad things about her would say it... I think personally..

From a quick glance up.. even Bryan mentioned Kylie...

She is her own person, and I think she should not have to follow in her sister's shadow that is wrong.. would you want to follow in your sister's shadow???

[Abi]

I was just chatting with my mum and she just made me fume kinda.

I think the reason the people who don't like Dannii; whether that be as a person, or as a judge is simply because... "She is not Kylie".

Whether you like her or not, she has got a good voice and she is a good judge.. but people can't see passed the whole. "She's Kylie's sister... she's not as good".... of course she isn't as good as Kylie... neither is Cheryl or Simon at singing.. does that make them not good judges. NO. It doesn't.

I now feel sorry for Dannii as she is constantly compared to Kylie. She HAS got a good voice. Bet 90% of the people on this board alone who don't like her, can't sing as well as her?? I know I can't sing as well as her...

If she wasn't Kylie's sister then hardley any of the people who do say bad things about her would say it... I think personally..

From a quick glance up.. even Bryan mentioned Kylie...

She is her own person, and I think she should not have to follow in her sister's shadow that is wrong.. would you want to follow in your sister's shadow???

Even if you don't compare her to Kylie, she still hasn't been that successfull. I can't even name one song that she has released, let alone one that got to number one.

[*-Rooney-*]

I was just chatting with my mum and she just made me fume kinda.

I think the reason the people who don't like Dannii; whether that be as a person, or as a judge is simply because... "She is not Kylie".

Whether you like her or not, she has got a good voice and she is a good judge.. but people can't see passed the whole. "She's Kylie's sister... she's not as good".... of course she isn't as good as Kylie... neither is Cheryl or Simon at singing.. does that make them not good judges. NO. It doesn't.

I now feel sorry for Dannii as she is constantly compared to Kylie. She HAS got a good voice. Bet 90% of the people on this board alone who don't like her, can't sing as well as her?? I know I can't sing as well as her...

If she wasn't Kylie's sister then hardley any of the people who do say bad things about her would say it... I think personally..

From a quick glance up.. even Bryan mentioned Kylie...

She is her own person, and I think she should not have to follow in her sister's shadow that is wrong.. would you want to follow in your sister's shadow???

Even if you don't compare her to Kylie, she still hasn't been that successfull. I can't even name one song that she has released, let alone one that got to number one.

minogue or not she hasnt been a success - lets be honest, she had a short lived soap career in home and away and then was a singer for a little while (not very successfull), if it wasnt for her being kylies sister she wouldnt be known today

[Trinity]

I was just chatting with my mum and she just made me fume kinda.

I think the reason the people who don't like Dannii; whether that be as a person, or as a judge is simply because... "She is not Kylie".

Whether you like her or not, she has got a good voice and she is a good judge.. but people can't see passed the whole. "She's Kylie's sister... she's not as good".... of course she isn't as good as Kylie... neither is Cheryl or Simon at singing.. does that make them not good judges. NO. It doesn't.

I now feel sorry for Dannii as she is constantly compared to Kylie. She HAS got a good voice. Bet 90% of the people on this board alone who don't like her, can't sing as well as her?? I know I can't sing as well as her...

If she wasn't Kylie's sister then hardley any of the people who do say bad things about her would say it... I think personally..

From a quick glance up.. even Bryan mentioned Kylie...

She is her own person, and I think she should not have to follow in her sister's shadow that is wrong.. would you want to follow in your sister's shadow???

Even if you don't compare her to Kylie, she still hasn't been that successfull. I can't even name one song that she has released, let alone one that got to number one.

minogue or not she hasnt been a success - lets be honest, she had a short lived soap career in home and away and then was a singer for a little while (not very successfull), if it wasnt for her being kylies sister she wouldnt be known today