Any Dream Will Do.

[Abi]

Its just because some of them are really good singers, but they're pop star singers. Untill they start singing songs from any musical, i think its hard to tell whose the best. Would be good if they did it alternate weeks or something- one week its from a musical, next its not etc.

[Katy]

I also think they should sing a female song from a musical to see how well they portray emotion. That's quite common when you audition for parts these days./

[Luna]

keith was brilliant the other night, i wasnt a big fan of him to start off with but he is just going from strengh to strengh. KEITH TO WIN!!

[pookie1968uk]

I personally didn't think Keith was that brilliant last night..
I think he sang it well, and everything, I just thought it was quite bland and I wasn't particularly entertained watching it.

I thought the judges were pretty hard on Lee, I thought that he sang it fairly well considering it's not exactly an easy song to sing - they complained that he was shouting but it's difficult not to with a song like that.

Also, I know that the point of them singing different types of song is to see how adaptable they are, but it is kind of irritating when they give them pretty stupid songs to sing (because, like the one Lee sang, they don't really show off their voices), and then complain that they can't sing that type of song very well, when all they are going to have to sing in the show is Joseph songs.
I wouldn't want the competition to be just about singing Joseph songs all the time, I just think they should give them songs that they can actually sing properly.

I think Ben was quite bad this week and, even though I like him, his defiance is starting to annoy me because there is no denying (IMO) that he is a pretty weak singer (probably the worst there, in fact).
I think then end is nigh for him, and next week I want him or Keith to go, although I doubt Keith will.

Ben was the most animated i have seen him - if he doesn't get this job he could always be the next Robbie.

Don't you think one is enough?!

i agree with you about the suitibility of songs. they give them pop songs that their voices dont suit then critisise when they struggle with them. they need to be singing more songs from musicals as they are not wanting to win the x factor, they want to do theatre!
i still like daniel and lee even though they had badish weeks.

[Abigail]

Its just because some of them are really good singers, but they're pop star singers. Untill they start singing songs from any musical, i think its hard to tell whose the best. Would be good if they did it alternate weeks or something- one week its from a musical, next its not etc.

Lee and Daniel will be the better ones out of the group when it comes to singing songs from musicals considering they already have theatre experience.
I reckon once they get down to 6 they'll start singing two songs each to fill the time slot so one will be a musical and the other a pop song.

Next week I think Ben or Craig will go. IMO they're the weaker singers and I don't think Ben is strong enough to stand on stage 8 times a week and perform.

ALW's blog on Saturday night's performance http://www.andrewlloydwebber.com/sec...php?article=66

[DaVeyWaVey]

What a brilliant show tonight! I thought all the Josephs were excellent tonight and all of their performances were of a very high standard, there was not a weak Joseph within them at all.

I felt sorry for Rob, but one person did have to go tonight, and as all of the performances were of a very high standard, it must have been a tough call for Andrew Lloyd Webber to choose between him and Lewis.

My favourite performance was from Keith tonight. He performed such an emotional performance and his acting comes across really well on stage, and he put across that he can be really mature in what he does.

[Abigail]

Excellent performances from everybody tonight. I felt Rob didn't do himself justice and he deserved to go. I think Craig was brill, it's the first time he's shown some talent IMO.

Lee was just amazing. He really brings out the meaning from the song and he's a great actor. He puts so much effort and emotion into his performance. He's my Joseph, although Keith may give him a run for his money.

Keith... what a guy. He's a dark horse. Brilliant performance and I thought he was really good as showing vulnerability during the video with John. Most guys would have got up and gone and cried somewhere where they couldn't be seen. It must have taken guts to lie on the floor and cry in front of the other contestants. Top guy

My weakest performers tonight were Lewis, Ben and Rob.

[Chloe O'brien]

This has to be one of the best week for the Joseph's so far. All singers perfomed brilliantly but sadly one had to go. Disapointed that Rob was the one to go. I thought he performed better than Lewis. Keith again was amazing he has to go all the way, the judges have to look past his age and give him a chance.

[Footie_Chick]

Got to agree about all the comments about Keith he was amazing, even had Denise crying during his song. His last two weeks have been the best, he can really pull emotional songs out of the bag.

As for Craig it's the first time i've seen him and i've actually really liked him performance, he was so emotional and i think thats what made it better as a viewer.

I didn't really like Lewis and Rob tonight so I thought the bottom two were correct.

[Chloe O'brien]

If craig can survive the sing off next week then I think it will be Lee and Lewis in the bottom two as both got negative coments last week and they have been hovering in the bottom half of the scores the last couple of weeks. If Keith keeps performing the way he does his may competition is Daniel although Zoe did not rate him tonight.