Emmerdale - Current Episode Discussion - III

[lizann]

how stupid is will, rose poured the drinks

kim should kick them out, all of them or maybe keep billy for some fun and romance

[Son of Cain]

Another car crash we did not see. This is becoming boring and repetitive.

[Dennis tanner]

It is a pity that we did not see the court scene where Matty is released. As things stand there still seems to be a discrepancy between Marty's account and what Samson has now told the police. Samson says he took the bottle and waved it around a bit, so presumably he said Matty stabbed him in self dendense. But surely Matty told them Samson was pushed or fell onto the knife. Did the police not question Josh's role even though Samson said he was nowhere near them.

Ratboy Josh said that he had been re-interviewed by the Police but he conformed Samson's new evidence............ even though he didn't know what it was

[lizann]

Ratboy Josh said that he had been re-interviewed by the Police but he conformed Samson's new evidence............ even though he didn't know what it was

yes he did not know what samson had said

[lizann]

Another car crash we did not see. This is becoming boring and repetitive.

emmerdale has love on now for car crashes off screen, how many car crashes accidents have happened this year alone

[Son of Cain]

yes he did not know what samson had said

Ratboy Josh said that he had been re-interviewed by the Police but he conformed Samson's new evidence............ even though he didn't know what it was

I got the impression that Josh was interviewed after Matty had been released, which would mean that the decision was made before Josh was seen by the police. Have all charges been dropped against Matty because as things stand he may still have deliberately stabbed Samson, even though it could have been in self defense? Did Matty know Josh pushed Samson, or did he think Samson was lunging at him? Was Matty always scheduled to be in court that day or was it because Samson changed his statement? In the real world it takes months if not years to get a court date. Where did this Josh suddenly came from, just conjured up for a bit of drama, does not seem to me to be a very realistic character?

[Perdita]

I got the impression that Josh was interviewed after Matty had been released, which would mean that the decision was made before Josh was seen by the police. Have all charges been dropped against Matty because as things stand he may still have deliberately stabbed Samson, even though it could have been in self defense? Did Matty know Josh pushed Samson, or did he think Samson was lunging at him? Was Matty always scheduled to be in court that day or was it because Samson changed his statement? In the real world it takes months if not years to get a court date. Where did this Josh suddenly came from, just conjured up for a bit of drama, does not seem to me to be a very realistic character?

Josh was indeed cast just for the Samson exit storyline, but they could have made a much better job of introducing him. Samson has not always been a kind person but still seems unlikely to have been buddy with someone like Josh... I do hope that Josh gets to spend time in the chokey and will disappear from our tv screens for ever.

[Son of Cain]

Just realized that I did not see the first 30 minutes of Wednesday's episode. I started watching at 7.30 just as the commercial break was ending, not realizing it had started at 7.00. Does make a little more sense now, but still a bit of a mess.

[johntrevor]

Missed bits of last episode.... what is the bottle with clear liquid that Rose got from a strange man? What is she meant to do with it?

It was drugs to put in wills drink, presumably to render Will passed out so she could get him in a compromised position where Kim would find them so ending the marriage, all as per Ruby's plans to bring Kim down for Caleb, so he could get his hands on Kim's estate, that he believes should be his. Glasses of the wine got mixed up and Dawn ended up drinking it, without knowing, causing her to pass out while driving, so causing the car accident with Ella.

[johntrevor]

how stupid is will, rose poured the drinks

kim should kick them out, all of them or maybe keep billy for some fun and romance

Yes incredible that no one questioned who brought the bottle of wine, and handed it out