Surgery door slams on Enders' Dr. May

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by sarah42000

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Lizzie Brookes

No, of course its not ok. What May did was wrong - yes I acknowledge that but under these circumstances it could be blamed on her mental health i.e. how far was she responsible for her actions etc? And i don't think despite this she would have harmed the baby or killed Dawnor anything. It's sad to see her arrested though despite the fact that she undoubtedly did wrong. Surely there must have been another way.

---

Although unspoken, her intentions were clearly to take the baby and leave Dawn to bleed to death.I dont know how you can justify not wanting May arrested. She is pure evil and im glad she got what she deserves, although I wanted to see Dawn belt her one as well as Rob.

---

Thanks for saying that Sarah,, as I said earlier I can not understand the mentality of any one who could see May was to be forgiven or did not deserve to be arrested or whatever ..May and Rob were both in the wrong, and hee hee you are right I wish Dawn had slugged her before the cops came ..:D

Sorry Lizzie, but really cannot see how its not justifiable, May being arrested. And Rob deserves his just desserts too. Did Beverly Allitt not deserve to be arrested because she suffered from Munchausens and thats why she killed the babies in her care on the maternity ward? Does the kidnapper of Maddie McCann not deserve to be arrested and brought to justice when/if they are eventually found. Why is this so different - because Dawn initially said that she would allow herself to become a surrogate instead, because she was scared of becoming a mother.

There are surrogacy laws in place for a reason - these have to be adhered to for all parties concerned, and just because someone is desperate to have a child, it doesn't give them the right to steal someone elses. Not under any circumstances. I'm assuming you aren't a parent - if you were, I honestly don't feel that you would feel this way about May or Rob.

May definetly deserved to be arrested - she was mad! She handcuffed Dawn to the bed and tried to cut the baby out of her stomach - there is no way May could get away with that by just apologising! Justice was definetly done in my opinion with May being arrested!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by JoJo

Sorry Lizzie, but really cannot see how its not justifiable, May being arrested. And Rob deserves his just desserts too. Did Beverly Allitt not deserve to be arrested because she suffered from Munchausens and thats why she killed the babies in her care on the maternity ward? Does the kidnapper of Maddie McCann not deserve to be arrested and brought to justice when/if they are eventually found. Why is this so different - because Dawn initially said that she would allow herself to become a surrogate instead, because she was scared of becoming a mother.

There are surrogacy laws in place for a reason - these have to be adhered to for all parties concerned, and just because someone is desperate to have a child, it doesn't give them the right to steal someone elses. Not under any circumstances. I'm assuming you aren't a parent - if you were, I honestly don't feel that you would feel this way about May or Rob.

---

Munchausens? What's that?

Of course in real life people deserve punishment for crimes but this is not real life. I do have sympathy with May though and I can't help liking her despite all this just as Rob always loved her.Hopefully if it is established that she is ill she will get a shorter sentence. I am not a parent that is true and yes all May did was wrong but I can't help having sympathy for her just the same and i never really liked Dawn. I agree that Rob's an iot who doesnot deserve either woman.

Munchausen syndrome is a psychiatric disorder in which those affected feign disease, illness, or psychological trauma in order to draw attention or sympathy to themselves.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Lizzie Brookes

Munchausens? What's that?

Of course in real life people deserve punishment for crimes but this is not real life. I do have sympathy with May though and I can't help liking her despite all this just as Rob always loved her.Hopefully if it is established that she is ill she will get a shorter sentence. I am not a parent that is true and yes all May did was wrong but I can't help having sympathy for her just the same and i never really liked Dawn. I agree that Rob's an iot who doesnot deserve either woman.

---

Nope, its not real life, you are right, but EE are supposed to portraying a true to life story, in which case, she deserves everything she gets.