Surgery door slams on Enders' Dr. May

Rob's a bit of an idiot but he did not chai n her to the bed etc - that was May. Should people be arrested for being idiots?

I am not saying that what May did was right - of course it wasn't but I'm sorry to see her arrested. I mean if someone is out of their mind - but I don't think she would harm the baby, she was just desperate and when people are desperate, well...I hope at ;least it will be a short sentence - its not like she kiled anyone or anything. I can't help pitying her all the same and I really hope she'll be backat some point. Amanda plays her brilliantly.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Lizzie Brookes

Rob's a bit of an idiot but he did not chain her to the bed etc - that was May. Should people be arrested for being idiots?

---

Erm, no not for being an idiot, but how about for kidnapping, and holding somebody against their will. :hmm:

Maybe but it was May who handcuffed her to the bed not rob. All Rob did was take her there and she did go with him of her own free will.

I'm so sorry May was arrested - that was a cruel trick, keeping her there till the police came. I think her sentence would be shorter though because it is obvious that she is not well and from what she said she was going to go away and leave Dawn alone - all she wanted to do was give her the clothes and toys, apologise and then say goodbye. If it were me I would probably not have pressed charges despite the bad treatment simply because i pity her and I realise that she is a desperate and very unhappy woman. But May's right about one thing - she should have left her husband. He was the one who created this mess in the first place. Both women are better off without that loser.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Lizzie Brookes

Maybe but it was May who handcuffed her to the bed not rob. All Rob did was take her there and she did go with him of her own free will.

---

Are you joking? She went of her own free will!!! Are you saying she knew May was going to be there and that she would be handcuffed to the bed?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Lizzie Brookes

All Rob did was take her there and she did go with him of her own free will.

.

---

She was tricked into going with him....erm, didnt she think she was going to live with him and his parents?....There's NO way she would have gone there if she had known May was waiting, or what she planned to do, ie cut the baby out of her, but Rob knew this was the plan (maybe not about the C section, but about May planning on taking the baby from Dawn).

Thus Rob was an accomplice, he aided May.

Also he could have uncuffed Dawn, but he did nothing to release her, or let her go. He helped keep her imprisoned in that room. So yep, he is guilty of being more than an idiot IMO!

No of course she did not know May was there or what was going to happen but I still don't think May needed to be arrested - after all she did apologise - and as for Rob, well yes he could have released her but he did feel bad aboiut the whole thing.

so its ok to have mad women running around the place, kidnapping a women, threatening to cut someone open and stealing the baby

Hmmmmmm ok then!

OF COURSE SHE HAD TO BE ARRESTED!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Lizzie Brookes

No of course she did not know May was there or what was going to happen but I still don't think May needed to be arrested - after all she did apologise - and as for Rob, well yes he could have released her but he did feel bad aboiut the whole thing.

---

So apologising makes it all okay? :eek: She could have killed Dawn. And Rob couldnt have felt bad enough about the whole thing, otherwise he would have released her!

Im glad she was arrested, but I liked the character and the actress who played her, shame she had to leave, but I guess after what she did that was going to be the only right conclusion to the storyline.

No, of course its not ok. What May did was wrong - yes I acknowledge that but under these circumstances it could be blamed on her mental health i.e. how far was she responsible for her actions etc? And i don't think despite this she would have harmed the bay or killed Dawn or anything. It's sad to see her arrested though despite the fact that she undoubtedly did wrong. Surely there must havebeen another way.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Lizzie Brookes

No, of course its not ok. What May did was wrong - yes I acknowledge that but under these circumstances it could be blamed on her mental health i.e. how far was she responsible for her actions etc? And i don't think despite this she would have harmed the baby or killed Dawnor anything. It's sad to see her arrested though despite the fact that she undoubtedly did wrong. Surely there must have been another way.

---

Although unspoken, her intentions were clearly to take the baby and leave Dawn to bleed to death.I dont know how you can justify not wanting May arrested. She is pure evil and im glad she got what she deserves, although I wanted to see Dawn belt her one as well as Rob.