If you had to axe one judge from the panel..

[Chris_2k11]

who would it be and why??!?

also name a celebrity you would replace them with

[Bryan]

I'd replace Danni and bring back Sharon! :D

[Layne]

I'd get rid of Danni, she annoys me. And i'd replace her with Sharon Osbourne :p Or maybe like John Barrowman - for a laugh :lol:

[Debs]

LOUIS!! i havent watched much of this year but have watcjed last 2 weeks while at mums and he annoys me!!! he squirms around in hi chair like a over excited 3 year old, hes such a child, i cant bear to watch him!!

[Trinity]

Cheryl - the stress is obviously too much for her. It must be awful cosying up to Simon - it has obviously put her off her food. If she is there for much longer she will fade away to nowt.

She has nothing to add to the show - she is an airhead who gets away with it because she isn't blond.

[Abbie]

I'd replace Danni and bring back Sharon! :D

Ditto! :cheer: :cheer:

[Abi]

I'd replace Dannii with Gary Barlow.

[Bad Wolf]

i would axe the leprechaun louis and replace with sir gary barlow

[Chloe O'brien]

I'd get rid of Dannii. Man she does my head in the way she turns on the tears and tries to play the poor girl act. She manipulated the show last year getting Simon to get rid of Sharon, she thought she was so smug. Now Cheryl is on board she is no longer Mr Cowell's favourite girl she once again is trying to get everyone to feel sorry for her. Did you see the crocodille tears on Saturday night. Give me a break you stupid witch and grow up. Cheryl might be an air head but at least she has been through what the contestants are feeling Dannii is only famous because of her big sister. Get rid of her and bring in Kylie, Sharon, Sinitta or anybody but her.

[LostVoodoo]

i would axe the leprechaun louis and replace with sir gary barlow

ditto, Louis is such a bratty child and doesn't care about any of his acts.

[no1abbafan]

Louis - and I am Irish - he is getting on my wick this year - so vindictive and sly. I would replace him with Michael Ball or Donny Osmond - both know what they are talking about and easy on the eye.:cheer: :cheer:

[Katy]

CHheryl i really cannot stand that woman, she adds nothing!

[Abigail]

Louis, I've never really liked him. He always has to argue with Simon.

I'd either leave the panel at three or bring Sharon back.

[sindydoll]

i would get rid of cheryl..i cant stand her:angry:

[Siobhan]

Get rid of cheryl and replace her with Dr Fox

[lizann]

I'd axe Cheryl and Dannii and bring back Mrs O

[Chris_2k11]

She manipulated the show last year getting Simon to get rid of Sharon, she thought she was so smug.When did she try to get rid of Sharon? :searchme:

[Perdita]

Voted for Dannii as she always plays the martyr and she is getting on my wick. :thumbsdow . Also not too keen on Cheryl, but she has grown on me slightly. I really would like Sharon O to come back :thumbsup:

[Xx-Vicky-xX]

Get rod of Danni and either bring Sharon back, or put Pete Waterman in, i can see him, Simon & Louis arguing alot, though saying that i like Foxy, so maybe him...oh i dont know :lol:

[Chris_2k11]

Poor Dannii, she gets all the stick :(

[DaVeyWaVey]

DANNII Minogue is Britain’s favourite X Factor judge, according to OK.co.uk readers.

Those of you who voted in our homepage poll last week believe Dannii has what it takes to judge Britain's best voices.

The former pop star, who took 48% of the votes, has beaten fellow judges Simon Cowell, Louis Walsh and Cheryl Cole to the title - despite being constantly criticised by the press.

The results quash rumours that the 37-year-old will be stepping down from her position for next year's series.

Co-judge Cheryl, who we thought the nation had fallen in love with, came in a close second with 37% of your votes, but her safe judging tactics won't cut it with OK.co.uk readers.

He may be the highest paid judge but Simon's nasty opinions aren’t sitting well with you, as he only took 12% of your votes.

But it's Louis' arguments and constant criticisms of firm favourites that have really riled you, leaving him with only 3% of your votes - a shocking result next to Dannii's 38%.


-----

Good news for Dannii. :) I think she's fab!

[Perdita]

Obviously, most people posting on here do not agree with OK readers :lol:

[Abbie]

Obviously, most people posting on here do not agree with OK readers :lol:

Yeah you can say that again, but we all have different opinions dont we

[miccisy]

I would put them in this order.

1. The Best - Dannii
2. Simon
3. Louis
4. The Worst - Cheryl.

[Abbie]

My order would be:

1. The best- Cheryl
2. Simon
3. Louis
4. The worst- Danni

[Trinity]

I would put them in this order.

1. The Best - Dannii
2. Simon
3. Louis
4. The Worst - Cheryl.

I would agree with that 100%

[Kirsty :]]

I would put them in this order.

1. The Best - Dannii
2. Simon
3. Louis
4. The Worst - Cheryl.

I would agree with that 100%

Definately!!

At the start of the show I would've voted Danni off.. but as the show has gone on, Cheryl has become very very catty and also very biased. I know her group is the girls.. but seriously. Knowing when to stop and be professional is key.
Who would I replace her with? Hmmmm :hmm: I don't really know.. Get Peter Kay on the panel! After his facade as Geraldine... I bet he knows more about the show then Cheryl does!

[Perdita]

My panel would consist of:

The best: Simon
2. Louis
3. Sharon Osbourne
4. Lulu

[DaVeyWaVey]

I wouldn't mind if Will Young replaced Cheryl on the panel. He can actually sing and he's been very successful through the reality show format. It was rumoured that Simon was looking for a younger male judge, so I think someone like Will would perfectly fit the bill. His masterclass with the contestants was also very impressive too.

[Perdita]

I like the panel of two males and two females - to keep hormone levels in balance :lol:

[Abbie]

I like the panel of two males and two females - to keep hormone levels in balance :lol:

Yeah, I like it in that format too, I just feel like it should be equal sometimes, its nice and keeps a balance

[CrazyLea]

I love how no one has picked Simon :wub: He's the best :wub:. And he's so lush.

[Chris_2k11]

you can't possibly get rid of Simon :D he is the x factor