Umbrella!

[CrazyLea]

There have been quite a few covers of this now. So including the original (Rihanna), which is your favourite?

Mandy Moore
Biffy Clyro
Mcfly
Rihanna
Other??? If there is another???


I love all of them except the Rihanna one. My favourite is Mandy followed by Mcfly then Biffy. Although I don't like the Rihanna one, I don't think any of them would be able to top Rihanna's chart success with the song!

[.:SpIcYsPy:.]

Erm the Chris Brown one, confused a bit to the question as I never heard of the others but yeah.. :) x

[Chris_2k11]

Rihanna of course :p but i really like the Biffy Clyro version aswell. i haven't heard the Mandy one. most singers could pull it off, its just an amazing song.

[Bree]

Mand Moores is great i like her just as much as Rihannas not to keen on the Mcflys one tho!!

[CrazyLea]

For you Spicy..

And everyone else who has no idea what I'm talking about :lol:.

YouTube - Rihanna - Umbrella (2007) - Rihanna

YouTube - Mandy Moore - Umbrella - Mandy Moore (have to wait a while for this to start unless you download it)

YouTube - Biffy Clyro cover umbrella - Biffy Clyro

YouTube - Mcfly: Umbrella (Studio Version) - Mcfly

None of these are the proper vids btw..

[Chris_2k11]

With the Biffy Clyro version you see a totally different side to the song which i think is good.

[CrazyLea]

It is a really amazing song though like Chris said. So I have to give Rihanna credit for that! If only she had a good voice!

[Chris_2k11]

yuk i dont like Mcflys version.

[Chris_2k11]

If only she had a good voice!Lea she has! lol whats so bad about it? remember shes from Barbados and not english or american.

[CrazyLea]

It's not the best :p I know I said it was my second fave. But I'm biased :lol:. I love Mcfly, and it was the first time I heard it.

What you think of Mandy's version :p. That's my fave! ;)

[CrazyLea]

If only she had a good voice!Lea she has! lol whats so bad about it? remember shes from Barbados and not english or american.

I just find it really screechy. Maybe it's just me who hears that lol!?
Like she strains her voice to get some notes out. Doesn't sound natural enough for me.

[Chris_2k11]

Just listened to the version by Mandy, really nice. i actually wouldnt mind seeing Rihanna do a version like this.

[Chris_2k11]

YouTube - best umbrella version( rihanna ) why is there such weirdos out there? :hmm: lol

[CrazyLea]

LMFAO That's so wrong!!!!!

[.:SpIcYsPy:.]

Rihanna is far by the best.. Dislike the McFly version by far..

Other 2 are too slow for my liking.. All hail Rihanna! :lol:

[Katy]

I like the rhianna and mcfly ones, never heard the other ones till now, never htought that one song could have so many covers.