View Full Version : one big fix?
just spoken to my sister in law and i dont know how true this is but we will soon find out but....
her friend knows one of the members from that band that made the final 14,cant remember there name.apparently its already fixed that shayne wins the x factor,this week andy will go,followed by brenda the following week and journey south and shayne in the final but shayne wins.itsa already fixed apparentley which rings true as did you notice cowells slip up the other night when he said 'when you win and get your record contract' (along those lines) then simon quickly corrected himself.think we are all being taken for mugs,if it is true i for one am quite angry.
really ? we'll have to wait and see
it will be interesting if it comes true and they go out inb that order
pookie1968uk
05-12-2005, 16:15
i wouldnt be suprised if this turns out to be true.
if itis then the contestants obviously know this already so really the whole thing is pointless for them as well as us and the contestants are sort of betraying us as the public voters.very good acts they all put on at the end when they already know who is going.makes me not want to watch now but il have to,to see if it al happens in that order
Jessie Wallace
05-12-2005, 16:20
Oh well, as long as Shayne wins i don't mind. But i don't think that that is true, just another one of the rumors to yet us all talking about it again!
if itis then the contestants obviously know this already so really the whole thing is pointless for them as well as us and the contestants are sort of betraying us as the public voters.very good acts they all put on at the end when they already know who is going.makes me not want to watch now but il have to,to see if it al happens in that order
i think it if does turn out to nbe a fix they should give all the money to charity!!! the amount that they make with all the texts and calls!!!
i am going to watch it to see if it does go in that order though!!! but no more voting!!!!
Jessie Wallace
05-12-2005, 16:23
That's the order i've said they'd go out anyway
i dont think shayne should win as he hasnt actually got the best voic hes just go a ok voice and the looks to sell records,thats why they want him to win as they know he can sell records best voice or not where as brenda and andy would be one hit wonders like michelle mcmanus.journey south would do good if they won but they all know shayne would appel more to younger people the ppl who buy the records.
i think it if does turn out to nbe a fix they should give all the money to charity!!! the amount that they make with all the texts and calls!!!
i am going to watch it to see if it does go in that order though!!! but no more voting!!!!
oh god please remember that if it doesnt happen that way dont shoot the messenger lol.
it does ring true to me though,i think it will happen
i think you are right!!! its just a funny feeling i have!!
I think Brenda should win - she has a fantastic voice!
Jessie Wallace
05-12-2005, 16:35
Oh i don't like Andy's voice, Brenda is good, but no she won't sell enough records - well long geverty(sp?) anyway. She be great as the lead in musicals and stuff.
But Shayne's got it all the voice the looks and attitude and everything else.
Oh i don't like Andy's voice, Brenda is good, but no she won't sell enough records - well long geverty(sp?) anyway. She be great as the lead in musicals and stuff.
But Shayne's got it all the voice the looks and attitude and everything else.
Shayne has got tenny bopper appear, not unlike Garath Gates (what is he doing these days?) Brenda could be another Whitney, or at least follow Will Young's foot steps
Oh i don't like Andy's voice, Brenda is good, but no she won't sell enough records - well long geverty(sp?) anyway. She be great as the lead in musicals and stuff.
But Shayne's got it all the voice the looks and attitude and everything else.
Shayne has got tenny bopper appeal, not unlike Garath Gates (what is he doing these days?) Brenda could be another Whitney, or at least follow Will Young's foot steps
i hate the pukey and cringeworthy way shayne is with sharon.
he also trys to play mr nice but hated it the other day when simon said ' im not sure if you have done enough to stay in the competition tonight' and he promptly gave a filthy look and then shouted to the audience 'do you think i have done enough' then he remembered he is suppose to be mr nice and tried to back track.you can tell hes a arrogant so in so.
i hate the pukey and cringeworthy way shayne is with sharon.
he also trys to play mr nice but hated it the other day when simon said ' im not sure if you have done enough to stay in the competition tonight' and he promptly gave a filthy look and then shouted to the audience 'do you think i have done enough' then he remembered he is suppose to be mr nice and tried to back track.you can tell hes a arrogant so in so.
Yep, you're right. Sharon O is old enough to be his mother - it is pretty gross the way they flirt, especially as it is a family show.
I heard that the Conways were fixed to win it so that wasn't right... you will never know.. hope Brenda gets it
i don't really think any of them are that fantastic really!!!
I hope this isn't true... no way should he win
xXxJessxXx
05-12-2005, 17:00
I dont think it is a fix. I mean Chico went out didnt he that tells us something! lol. I could be wrong though, But if what you say is true then brenda will have to be in the final and not just journey south and shayne.
I think Shayne deserves to win because he has develped the most. The others are all great but i think he will end up selling the most records and not just because of his looks.
No matter how much i love Andy i think he will be going next week. I think Brenda will come third and JS 2nd and Shayne to win, just how you said it will be fixed. I hope bredna is out nest week though. If it isnt a fix and Shayne does in then i dont think that is particular fair because people will say its all a fix ect. He deserves to win as much as the others and has just the same chance of wining to. Surely if it is a fix then the other contestants would have walked by now because i know if i was one of the others i wouldnt want to stay. Guess we will have to wait and see what will ahppen but if it does end up in shayne winning, JS 2nd, Brenda 3rd and andy 4th still dont mean its a fix! I really dont think that they will make it a fix knowing that a lot of the other acts who have won things like this seem to drop after a while i think they'd want public to have a say as they are the ones who make an artist big.
xXxJessxXx
05-12-2005, 17:05
Shayne has got tenny bopper appeal, not unlike Garath Gates (what is he doing these days?) Brenda could be another Whitney, or at least follow Will Young's foot steps
I dont think Shanye does have a teeny bopper appeal. Ok a lot of teen girls will like him but then again so will a lot of old grannies! lol. Even middle aged people might like him. its about talent not looks. i think he appeals to almost all people.
Brenda how ever does have the whitney sound to her voice but never will she be anything like her at all. Not evena little bit, she isnt that good! I agree with simon that she is not a recording artist. She reminds me a bit of Michelle from pop idol and i think if she were to win she'd end up the same way. She'd try to sing big songs like whitney but just flop because she isnt half as good. She's shown me she can only sing one type of song where as Shayne can sing all different. So can Andy and JS.
xCharliex
05-12-2005, 17:39
Wasnt this the case back in the Gareth Gates day? Everyone said he was fixed to win, which was not true at all, the right person won that competition.
And why would them contestants put themseves through a show knowing it was fixed? They wouldnt especially the likes of Brenda and Andy! They have more pride than that!
Brenda should win or Andy, Brenda is just getting better and better each week, shes amazing! Shayne will get a deal whether he wins the show or not!
pookie1968uk
05-12-2005, 18:29
i hate the pukey and cringeworthy way shayne is with sharon.
he also trys to play mr nice but hated it the other day when simon said ' im not sure if you have done enough to stay in the competition tonight' and he promptly gave a filthy look and then shouted to the audience 'do you think i have done enough' then he remembered he is suppose to be mr nice and tried to back track.you can tell hes a arrogant so in so.
that is very true, he has an appeal to the teeny boppers but not to us who know better!! i really dont want him to win but im sure he will
Wasnt this the case back in the Gareth Gates day? Everyone said he was fixed to win, which was not true at all, the right person won that competition.
And why would them contestants put themseves through a show knowing it was fixed? They wouldnt especially the likes of Brenda and Andy! They have more pride than that!
Brenda should win or Andy, Brenda is just getting better and better each week, shes amazing! Shayne will get a deal whether he wins the show or not!
prob cus they are getting paid each week more then they did there average jpbs and they get to be on the tv at the same time and they are hoping that the media attention from the show will push them further and get them a record contract,prob paid to keep there gobs shut.
omg. thats bad. you wouldn't have thought it is a fixable thing but maybe it is and if it is, then its really unfair
In the end pop idol was fixed for will to win as you couldnt get through on gareths phone line, gareth is currently finishing off his new album which should be out next year.
i really dont want shayne to win as he is really annoying me!
just spoken to my sister in law and i dont know how true this is but we will soon find out but....
her friend knows one of the members from that band that made the final 14,cant remember there name.apparently its already fixed that shayne wins the x factor,this week andy will go,followed by brenda the following week and journey south and shayne in the final but shayne wins.itsa already fixed apparentley which rings true as did you notice cowells slip up the other night when he said 'when you win and get your record contract' (along those lines) then simon quickly corrected himself.think we are all being taken for mugs,if it is true i for one am quite angry.
omg i hope this isnt true! well soon know if they go in that order wont we!!!
In the end pop idol was fixed for will to win as you couldnt get through on gareths phone line, gareth is currently finishing off his new album which should be out next year.
i really dont want shayne to win as he is really annoying me!
will was the right man though,hes still about now where as gareth isnt and dont think his album will do to well either
Brenda should win... she has been consistent throughout.. never had a bad performance where the others have... she is brilliant
no1abbafan
06-12-2005, 10:28
I don't like Shayne, his voice is ok, not brilliant but he is what sells records these days - Louis telling us he can be the next Robbie, Justin whatever, how about being an original not a copycat. I like Andy but I am afraid he will go this week, I can't see what direction he is taking with his singing. Journey South are brilliant - no gimmicks, no backing singers, just their own voices which are fab. Brenda has a good voice but I wouldn't buy her records, too like Whitney, Maria Carey etc..
I don't like Shayne, his voice is ok, not brilliant but he is what sells records these days - Louis telling us he can be the next Robbie, Justin whatever,
funny you should say that!! my little girl loves Justin and everytime she sees shane she tells me Justin in on telly again singing...
i_luv_dennis
06-12-2005, 11:10
it might be true
Chloe O'brien
06-12-2005, 14:37
I hope it's not true as Journey south deserve to win more than shayne but I think andy might go this week because his nerves have got the better of him over the last two weeks but hopefully he will surive to the final as i would like to see him and journey south down to the last two
tammyy2j
06-12-2005, 14:38
Shayne will do good even if doesn't win, rumour has it Louis has signed him already so i hope Journey South, Andy or Brenda wins.
Maria has already got a recording contract so i think they will all do well this time around compared to last years show.
.:SpIcYsPy:.
06-12-2005, 17:08
o0o0o0o this sounds really interesting!! :p
do you really think that theyd string everyone along. I dont really believe it but i expect we will have to wait and see.
do you really think that theyd string everyone along. I dont really believe it but i expect we will have to wait and see.
why not?
just realised that the final is next week,i reckon this could be so each mentor has a contestant each in the final,meaning andy or brenda will go tonight,what do you think?
that could happen, i dont think they have the winner sorted already though. It will make it a bit fairer if they all had one act in the final.
.:SpIcYsPy:.
10-12-2005, 14:22
oo0o0o0oo So Andy should be leaving now :eek:
i hope he doesnt if he does ill be well annoyed hes like the best one.
he is a good singer but i dont think he'd do too well in the charts.he is a bit of a one trick pony i think,can only do slow oldie sogs well.
i wish in law hadnt of told me that now cus its spoiling it for me,hope andy doesnt go tonight just so that info is wrong and i can enjoy the prog again
pookie1968uk
10-12-2005, 23:34
oh well, it didnt happen as some thought as brenda went instead! it could still have already been decided shayne wins though! vote journey south, thats what i say!!
he is a good singer but i dont think he'd do too well in the charts.he is a bit of a one trick pony i think,can only do slow oldie sogs well.
Exactly.
You know you he's like.... Steve Brookstein :thumbsdow :sick:
.:SpIcYsPy:.
18-12-2005, 15:11
Shane's won then!!... So does everyone still think it was a fix or what?
Exactly.
You know you he's like.... Steve Brookstein :thumbsdow :sick:
i saw a piccie of him the other day and he actually looked a bit like steve!!
or it might have just been me!!!
Yeah i still think its a fix!!
i dunno if it was a fix or not,shayne should have won out of andy and shayne but i think js south should have been 2nd and it was fixed for andy to be.
i agree out of andy and shayne, shayne should have won. but out of the 3 JS should have. but thats just my opinion
xXxJessxXx
19-12-2005, 18:28
I dont think it was a fix. I think it was the right outcome. JS deserved to come third after saturdays performance. Andy was better then them on the night and Shayne even better than Andy.
Andy was the best on sat, shanye looked as if he couldnt be bothered and that he knew he had already had it in the bag.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.3 Copyright © 2025 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.