View Full Version : Chenai or Nicholas
We had this last week so I decided to do it again. Who would you have said goodbye to? We know Chenai went this week and I would have sent her home. Do you agree?
xxx
CrazyLea
05-11-2005, 21:50
nah i would have sent nicholas home... he sang that song well badly!!! and chenai has been good throughou.. i think nickolas is just a bad version of a bad craig david
feelingyellow
05-11-2005, 22:00
chenai, she has such a good voice and nicholas is cool, good but a bit boring!
xxvikkixx
05-11-2005, 22:04
I would have sent Nicholas home, I like him, but I liked Chenai better, she had a great voice and really wanted it more than the others I think.
xXxJessxXx
05-11-2005, 22:27
I agreed with Simon. Chenai sang better on the night but only just. I knew it would be them in the bottom. But i think over the four weeks Nicholas has been far better and based on that he would have been better in the coming weeks. So i would have based it on that and sent her home. even though i thought she was slightly better tonight.
Its all down to Louis i think. He's too cocky and aragont
Jessie Wallace
05-11-2005, 22:36
Nicholas so should have gone, he can't even sing.
Bad Wolf
05-11-2005, 23:07
i thinnk cheni should have been saved- totally agree with sharon
i would have sent chenai home, nicholas is so much better than her!!!
Jessie Wallace
05-11-2005, 23:09
Simon contradicted himself, he always say's that he'll choose the one who did the best performance of the evening and he said that was Chenai and then he went and choose Nicholas, so he is a prat and a lier! :angry: :mad: :wall:
i missed both performances
but i will watch it on itv 2 tomorrow
Bad Wolf
05-11-2005, 23:12
Simon contradicted himself, he always say's that he'll choose the one who did the best performance of the evening and he said that was Chenai and then he went and choose Nicholas, so he is a prat and a lier! :angry: :mad: :wall:
sharon got to pick first and saved cheni - he was just making sure that louis had the difficult decision
Jessie Wallace
05-11-2005, 23:12
i missed both performances
Nicholas was out of key, and it didn't sound very good - compaire to what he nomally sounds.
Chenia - Sounded, at one of her best tonight.
Jessie Wallace
05-11-2005, 23:14
sharon got to pick first and saved cheni - he was just making sure that louis had the difficult decision
Yeah i know, but what a prat, you can't say something one week and then change your mind the next, infact i think he even said it in todays show!:angry:
Nicholas was out of key, and it didn't sound very good - compaire to what he nomally sounds.
Chenia - Sounded, at one of her best tonight.
i will have a listen toorrow then give my verdict, honestly
Nicholas should have been sent home
Jessie Wallace
06-11-2005, 00:08
Nicholas should have been sent home
Totally, Nicholas, wasn't very good this time.
i havent liked him from the start
Jessie Wallace
06-11-2005, 00:11
i havent liked him from the start
He is ok, but Chenai was and is way better.
Johnny Allen
06-11-2005, 08:07
Nicholas isn't that much of a singer, and doesn't have the look Chenai had both although she always appeared very nervous to me, but I would have sent home Nicholas.
Jessie Wallace
06-11-2005, 09:20
Excatly, Chenia has an amazing look, i loved her.
nicolas killed that song and deserved to go home! but no! louis had to go and save him! :angry: why didnt he just ask for it to go to public vote rather than vote for one of his acts
exactly bb i dont understand why he didn't do that.....if it was sharon she would never have picked one of her own
Jessie Wallace
06-11-2005, 12:11
She has said that she will if it comes to it next time, some thing to do with she knows the rules and knows that she has to do it! But we will have to wait and see if she can actually do it or not.
xXxJessxXx
06-11-2005, 12:23
She has said that she will if it comes to it next time, some thing to do with she knows the rules and knows that she has to do it! But we will have to wait and see if she can actually do it or not.
She was in that situation last year wastnt she? I know one of them was and i cant remeber if they picked between them or let it go to a public vote. Sharon said she knows the rules and she would ahve to make the decision.
Even if Louis let it go to a public vote Chenai still could have gone home.
Jessie Wallace
06-11-2005, 12:26
She could have gone, but i don't think she would have, i certainly would have voted to Nicholas on last nights performance.
On ITV2 last night Sharon said that she knows the rules now, and knows she has to make a decision. But as i said it remains to be seen as to if she will or not!
feelingyellow
06-11-2005, 12:28
both louis and sharon were in that situation last year, louis could picked between his acts but sharon didn't so they had to turn to the public vote. i think if the same thing happened this year she still wouldn't be able to choose.
Jessie Wallace
06-11-2005, 12:31
We will just have to wait and see if that situation comes up, whivh it is looking like it will at the moment, as she's still got all 4 of her act's, so it could end up as her 4 in the final, and then she'd have to choose!, now that could be interesting!
xCharliex
06-11-2005, 14:04
Definately Chenai, i didnt really like her voice, its not really strong enough and theres something i dont like about her.
I think Nicholas has a great vouce, he reminds me of Paris from Fame Academy i really like the guy id love to hear him sing a Lemar song, im glad he stayed he has much more potential
I thought that neither of them should have been in the bottom 2 last night, i was really shocked! But out of the 2 of them i think they made the right decision to let Chenai go- even tho her performance was better yesterday i think Nicholas is better overall and should do really well!
Potato1992
06-11-2005, 17:17
it had to be nicholas to keep as he is better consistantly
pookie1968uk
06-11-2005, 23:03
i think chenai sang better on the night but overall nicholas has far more potential. some of the weeks he has sang have been grilliant and he sings effortlessly.
Chenai really annoyed me the last few weeks... Chico was great this week again.. beginning to like him a lot
xXxJessxXx
07-11-2005, 20:02
C Chico was great this week again.. beginning to like him a lot
When he first started i was like "What is he doing!!" :eek: he was singing in such a high voice i thought if he goes any higher only dogs will be bale to hear him! It started to get better when he went to his own (or hearable) voice. lol. I still dont think he's a good singer but he's a great entertainer and makes me laugh. But i think he's had his fun now and he needs to go. I agrred with simon that it will be dull with out him, but i think he needs to give the other acts who have wicked voices a chance as i dontthink he'd ever make money relasig cds as i think you have to watch him and on a cd you cant and you'll notice hos bad singing more. all he's capable of is performing, enterating and probably being a presenter.
pookie1968uk
07-11-2005, 22:45
When he first started i was like "What is he doing!!" :eek: he was singing in such a high voice i thought if he goes any higher only dogs will be bale to hear him! It started to get better when he went to his own (or hearable) voice. lol. I still dont think he's a good singer but he's a great entertainer and makes me laugh. But i think he's had his fun now and he needs to go. I agrred with simon that it will be dull with out him, but i think he needs to give the other acts who have wicked voices a chance as i dontthink he'd ever make money relasig cds as i think you have to watch him and on a cd you cant and you'll notice hos bad singing more. all he's capable of is performing, enterating and probably being a presenter.
yes, chicco needs to go, yes i will admit he is a good entertainer but as for singing noone can tell me has has a good voice. the others left in the competition are far better singers, so i wish people would stop voting him to stay in a singing competition!!!!!
no1abbafan
08-11-2005, 10:32
Really hard to decide, but I went for Nicholas, He is a really crap singer, all this rubbish about "raw talent", sorry I dont see it. Having said that, Chenai although a good singer, to me sings with a speech impediment. IMHO I don't think she did herself any favours with the public when she came out with that remark, that the other girls were 15 years older than her, and then that spat with Brenda in the house.
yes, chicco needs to go, yes i will admit he is a good entertainer but as for singing noone can tell me has has a good voice. the others left in the competition are far better singers, so i wish people would stop voting him to stay in a singing competition!!!!!
It is a public vote and they seem to like him alot... having said that the times he was in the last 2 and was kept, imho i think it was to get rid of the competition.. think about it.. if you had a choice between someone who had no chance in hell of winning and a great singer that could be very tough competition for you.. who would you chose??
The worse one so that you can save your own acts!!!!!
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.3 Copyright © 2025 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.