PDA

View Full Version : X Factor singers second rate


Debs
02-11-2005, 13:42
Girls Aloud have hit out at reality TV show The X Factor.

The group, formed in 2002 from fellow TV talent show Popstars: The Rivals (http://g.msn.co.uk/1ETGBEN0/124980.4?http://search.msn.co.uk/results.aspx?FORM=SRHBDY&q=The Rivals&&HL=keywordInt), criticised The X Factor's singers as second rate.

Nicola Roberts, 20, said: "I don't think the talent is that good this time round.

"I mean, look at Chico - what is that?

"That's what you get when you try and make good TV rather than a talent show," she told OK! magazine.

Girl band Cheryl Tweedy (http://g.msn.co.uk/1ETGBEN0/124980.4?http://search.msn.co.uk/results.aspx?FORM=SRHBDY&q=Cheryl Tweedy&&HL=keywordInt), Sarah Harding (http://g.msn.co.uk/1ETGBEN0/124980.4?http://search.msn.co.uk/results.aspx?FORM=SRHBDY&q=Sarah Harding&&HL=keywordInt), Kimberley Walsh (http://g.msn.co.uk/1ETGBEN0/124980.4?http://search.msn.co.uk/results.aspx?FORM=SRHBDY&q=Kimberley Walsh&&HL=keywordInt), Nadine Coyle and Nicola are managed by Louis Walsh, a judge with Simon Cowell and Sharon Osbourne on ITV's The X Factor.

Nadine, 20, said: "I can't watch it. The judges are just so harsh. I told Louis Walsh (http://g.msn.co.uk/1ETGBEN0/124980.4?http://search.msn.co.uk/results.aspx?FORM=SRHBDY&q=Louis Walsh&&HL=keywordInt) that he should give them constructive criticism and not just destroy them.
Abi
02-11-2005, 14:47
They can hardly talk!
Debs
02-11-2005, 14:51
yeah they not that greatthemselves
Siobhan
02-11-2005, 15:32
Nicola Roberts, 20, said: "I don't think the talent is that good this time round.

"I mean, look at Chico - what is that?

"That's what you get when you try and make good TV rather than a talent show," she told OK! magazine.

(http://g.msn.co.uk/1ETGBEN0/124980.4?http://search.msn.co.uk/results.aspx?FORM=SRHBDY&q=Louis%20Walsh&&HL=keywordInt)

Is that not want people want??? good tv....
lollymay
02-11-2005, 16:24
i like them i thnk they do some really good songs
no1abbafan
02-11-2005, 17:37
Pot Kettle Black, if it wasnt for a reality show like Pop Idol etc.., they wouldn't be heard of now, and if my memory serves me correctly Nadine was so desperate for fame, she lied about her age when she entered the Irish version of Pop Idol and was booted out, then she turns up on the British Version. Talk about biting the hand that feeds you.
Abi
02-11-2005, 20:19
Exactly. As i said, how they can talk i dont know. They would know talent if it kicked them up the ar....
tammyy2j
07-11-2005, 12:24
Pot Kettle Black, if it wasnt for a reality show like Pop Idol etc.., they wouldn't be heard of now, and if my memory serves me correctly Nadine was so desperate for fame, she lied about her age when she entered the Irish version of Pop Idol and was booted out, then she turns up on the British Version. Talk about biting the hand that feeds you.

Completely agree and some of the talent on X Factor is better that Girls Aloud
Chloe O'brien
07-11-2005, 12:33
They would not be were they were today if it was not for reality shows. I agree I don't think chico should have got through to the live shows but give the guy some credit he is entertaining and he is commited to being a success. At the end of the day the x factor is good family saturday night viewing and the kids like him
angelblue
07-11-2005, 12:33
Pot Kettle Black, if it wasnt for a reality show like Pop Idol etc.., they wouldn't be heard of now, and if my memory serves me correctly Nadine was so desperate for fame, she lied about her age when she entered the Irish version of Pop Idol and was booted out, then she turns up on the British Version. Talk about biting the hand that feeds you.

I agree they seem like fame has really gone to their heads i think they should be greatful and not to be so quick to comment

I think they need to be brought back down to reality remember were they come from and how they got to were they are now and be thankful :o
Siobhan
07-11-2005, 12:34
They would not be were they were today if it was not for reality shows. I agree I don't think chico should have got through to the live shows but give the guy some credit he is entertaining and he is commited to being a success. At the end of the day the x factor is good family saturday night viewing and the kids like him

Chico has been doing well the last couple of weeks and he is very very entertaining...
no1abbafan
07-11-2005, 16:40
Well Simon threw the gauntlet down on Sat. night, inviting them to come and sing live. Louis face was a picture, "they were mis-quoted, you saw the text from them Simon". If he is supposed to be their manager, he should be better at damage limitations than that.
Katy
07-11-2005, 17:42
HAHAHAHAHA

Girls aloud critiscing other singers. I mean have they heard themselves especially the blond one. Every note they sing is out of tune.