Would You? - Tracy Luv

[Bryan]

The Would You threads in the Eastender General have proved popular so i thought we'd start off a weekly one for the other soaps.

Tracy Luv - Would You Have Lied To Roy That Amy Was His Child To Give Her A Good Upbringing?

[Siobhan]

A child needs to know who its real parents are.. she could have let Roy bring up Amy but not as the birth father.. Roy was will to be there for her from the very beginning

[Chloe O'brien]

I voted no because I believe that a child has the right to know the truth who their real parents are when they are old enough to understand. If Steve did not want to have anything to do with Amy then it would be his loss not hers and I think that Roy would love Amy just the same.

[CrazyLea]

no thats just wrong for both the child and roy

[LUSHLOOKE69]

also it was never about giving Amy a good up bringing it was to do withTracey's greed.

[shannisrules]

i would never had lied about the father a baby always needs to know its father no matter who they are

[hazey]

I answered no, A child needs to know who their real father is,and it is wrong to tell a lie,even if it means a better up bringing.

[Tamzi]

I voted no. I wouldn't lie. A child needs to know who their father is always. It would just come out in the end and everyone would be hurt
xxx

[Jade]

Nope, I dont necesairly think that she would have a better up bringing with Roy, Steve is a great dad to Amy.

[Abi]

Roy is the sort of person who would look after and over any child, even if it wasn't his own (think of what he did with Chesny), she didn't have to lie to him to give her a good upbringing. It was just harsh and cruel

[feelingyellow]

I voted no. it would have driven a big wedge between roy and hayley, and a good marriage like there's doesn't deserve to be broken when a baby can still have a good upbringing - maybe not the best, but still a good one is ok.

[i_luv_dennis]

no

[sean 4 eva]

i would have felt really guilty if i ever lied like that so i voted know i dont see the point in lieing

[Debs]

no i wouldnt have

[littlemo]

Definetely not. Roy's alright, but Steve is going to be a better dad for Amy in the long term. Apart from that though it's the principle of the thing, you shouldn't tell somebody that they are the father of your baby if there not. It's better not to say anything at all, if you can't be truthful.

[melanielovesdennisrickman]

No,because every child needes to know who his parents are,and also you would be ruining someone else's marriage!!