PDA

View Full Version : Who did you vote for?



Layne
28-08-2005, 11:20
Who did you vote for, or want to get the transplant?

Layne
28-08-2005, 11:22
I voted for lucy, well just because she was younger and had the whole of her life, and well that is why really!

xlxstaceyxlx
28-08-2005, 11:23
i also voted for lucy because she had a life in front of her
but they both deserved one

bubblegum_fairy
28-08-2005, 12:10
I voted for Lucy for the same reasons as stated above

Crazy Gal 88
28-08-2005, 13:53
i didnt vote for anyone but i was tempted to vote for tony because it was only a heart transplant on offer wasnt it? and if lucy had sickle cell then she would have been ill with that whereas tony would have been completely cured. plus, most people think younger people should get it because they think theyve got more of a life in front of them but an older person dying will probably affect more people as they have become part of more people's lives.

Tamzi
28-08-2005, 13:56
I voted tony because Lucy had cystic fybrosis as well so she wouldn't have got completley better, and tony would have got better with the transplant.
xxx

Rach33
28-08-2005, 13:58
I voted Tony too I'm not sure why but when I phoned I went with my gut instict and I voted Tony

Tamzi
28-08-2005, 14:12
I had to keep trying as the line was busy
xxx

Emma-Lou
28-08-2005, 15:49
i tried to vote for lucy but i could not get through the line was so busy

Mrs Wilkinson
28-08-2005, 16:39
I voted for Tony but it took me ages to get thro

Jemma
28-08-2005, 17:17
I voted Lucy but it was a really hard decision.

***Virgo***
28-08-2005, 19:20
I was gonna vote for tony but the line was so busy i couldn't get through!

hazey
28-08-2005, 22:35
I voted tony because Lucy had cystic fybrosis as well so she wouldn't have got completley better, and tony would have got better with the transplant.
xxx I voted Tony for the same reasons,everybody says oh she younger etc, but Tony could have got the heart and some other person could have the kidneys,and lungs there by saving three people.

Jessie Wallace
28-08-2005, 22:58
Lucy

eastenders mad
29-08-2005, 13:50
i voted for Lucy cause she has her whole life ahead of her. While Tony he is life is nearly finshed.

Lisa321
29-08-2005, 15:44
I voted Lucy, but Tonys case was just as arguable. I voted beacuse Lucy was younger.
(Just to confirm this, Tony was Brookie's Max Farnham wasnt he...?)
xxx

Bryan
29-08-2005, 16:28
i was on a coach coming back from switzerland so i missed this episode but when i read both of their cases in a tv mag i so would have voted for tony!

cystic fibrosis sufferers dont live very long, i was told my a doctor when my grandad was given a room in a cf ward, it had ensuite rooms and free tv and phone etc, i asked him why and he said that cf sufferes dont last long so they are given luxury for what time that they have on earth

id have therfore voted for tony, as the cf suffer would die in a few years anyway, and so would have wasted the donor, when tony has a whole life ahead of him, just having a new love intrest etc...

CrazyLea
29-08-2005, 16:31
i didnt see the episode till sunday but i wouldnt have known who to vote for.. it was a hard choice. i think i might have been slightly swayed to tony though

hazey
29-08-2005, 18:38
i voted for Lucy cause she has her whole life ahead of her. While Tony he is life is nearly finshed. remind me to book the funeral directors now lol. Tony's life wasn't nearly finished it wasn't as if he was in his seventies or eighties. he was only in his forties early fifties.

$sTaCeY$
29-08-2005, 20:21
I didn't vote anyone because i didn't watch it :crying:

hayley
29-08-2005, 20:57
Lucy but i felt really bad! I think she deserved one beacuse she had her whole life ahead of her but i didnt mind who got it really.

xStephaniex
06-09-2005, 13:57
i voted lucy, i wanted to vote for tony tho, but i didn't dunno why it was tough disission (sp?)

noah_wyle_rokz
08-09-2005, 16:18
i didnt vote for anyone but i was tempted to vote for tony because it was only a heart transplant on offer wasnt it? and if lucy had sickle cell then she would have been ill with that whereas tony would have been completely cured. plus, most people think younger people should get it because they think theyve got more of a life in front of them but an older person dying will probably affect more people as they have become part of more people's lives.

i thought she had cf