X Factor 2007 - General Discussion

[Katy]

I think she will be back. You never now with these things. I hope she comes back.

My favourites is Nicki and Daniel. I think Kimberley deserved to go to be honest it wasnt that gooder performance.

[DaVeyWaVey]

As much as i thought Sharon's remarks to Rhydian were out of order on Saturday, i hope she does come back. For me, the show wouldn't be the same without her.

[Chloe O'brien]

The X-factor wouldn't be the same without the judges throwing a hissy fit. It's all panto stuff and the contestants just need to concentrate on their singing and let the judges throw tantrums to their hearts content, we are only at week 1 there will be a lot more to come.

[tammyy2j]

Hope are bloody hopeless i hope they do go out next.

Yes i agree the show wouldn't be the same without Sharon or any of the Judges.

[Chris_2k11]

This Saturday's songs:

Alisha Aretha Frankling - Say A Little Prayer
Emily Britney Spears - Not A Girl, Not Yet A Woman

Andy Bee Gees - Staying Alive
Leon Michael Buble - Home
Rhydian Phantom Of The Opera

Daniel Foundations - Build Me Up Buttercup
Bev Whitney - I Have Nothing
Niki Celine Dion - My Heart Will Go On

Same Difference High School Musical - Breaking Free
Futureproof Simply Red - If You Don't Know Me By Now
Hope Missy Elliot & Co - Lady Marmalade

[DaVeyWaVey]

Can't wait to see Rhydian do Phantom Of The Opera.

Have to agree with Tammy too that Hope are hopeless! The song choice of Lady Marmalade will give them another chance to show off their flesh opposed to their "vocal talent"

[tammyy2j]

The song choice of Lady Marmalade will give them another chance to show off their flesh opposed to their "vocal talent"

Yes they will probably wear as little as possible

[xXxJessxXx]

Its all just a publicity stunt.

As much as i somewhat like Sharon, if this is how she is goign to behave after only the first week of live shows then i hope she doesnt come back. Her two remaining acts dont need to her their mentor calling everyone's bluff saying she'll leave then actually not going through with it. They need some one who will actually support them and who will be there through out the competition.

I do think its harsh making them vote a contestant off when both of them are your own acts but on saturday night she's there to judge more than mentor so should have made a desicion. Simon even voted his own act off before knowing they were the weaker act, its how it should be. She definatly had the worst group on saturday and should have focused more about trying to make them better and giving advise rather than backing out at the last minute refusing to vote. She should tackle the situation before it got out of control rather than when her two acts were in the bottom 2.

Its only a competition and i think she's just embaressed that she hasnt won yet in three years and she's probably also worried in case newbie Danni beats her this year too lol, and because their are four judges now, she can refuse to vote becuase with 3 judges left they can get a clear answer without having to go to the viewers vote which producers dont want because it doesnt create drama and arguments. Its all to help the rating go up

[megan999]

This Saturday's songs:

Alisha Aretha Frankling - Say A Little Prayer
Emily Britney Spears - Not A Girl, Not Yet A Woman

Andy Bee Gees - Staying Alive
Leon Michael Buble - Home
Rhydian Phantom Of The Opera

Daniel Foundations - Build Me Up Buttercup
Bev Whitney - I Have Nothing
Niki Celine Dion - My Heart Will Go On

Same Difference High School Musical - Breaking Free
Futureproof Simply Red - If You Don't Know Me By Now
Hope Missy Elliot & Co - Lady Marmalade

IMO this song for Emily is quite appropriate
Niki's song should be good - she is able to put alot of emotion into her singing
Rhydian's one should be brill - he is such a show-off
Futureproof's song will send me to sleep. IMO they can't sing together
Hope's one should be good but they are a bit tarty IMO
My cousin said Same Difference should sing HighSchoolMusical - What I've been looking for. I have to say that after listening to it, I agree.

[pookie1968uk]

i think it has all been a fix the way both groups have been put together anyway and on the episodes i have seen hope were very average and still put through. then simon was given the groups and hes a sucker for girls skimpily dressed so they were always going to do well after that!!