harry potter and the Half Blood Prince... post reading anaysis (contains spoilers)

[Luna]

Also i dont think harry has much of a choice whether ron and hermione are going with him or not lol

[Bad Wolf]

i dont think harry will kill any one other than voldemort- and i think that will be a magical and not intentional thing- i dont thinkk we will ever hear harry say the killing curse- it wil involve him destroying all the horcruxes- then something unforseen will happen????

[Luna]

did he not try and use a killing curse in OOTP??

oooohhhh i cant wait 2years +

[Bad Wolf]

it didnt work because he didnt mean it or something- basically harry isnt evil

[Luna]

yes but he still tried it!!

i am also not convinced that harry is a horcux if he was wouldn't there have been some evidence of that already? Would he not have shown signs of having that evil within him?

[Bad Wolf]

i dont think he is either what do we have so far?
the neclace
riddles diary
the ring

nagini???

[Bad Wolf]

possibly something of the other two houses

[Luna]

nagini im not sure of wasnt there something about not being able to put it into a living thing??

God im going to have to read it again

Wasn't there also something about the huffllepuff cup??

[Bad Wolf]

the hufflepuff cup and something unidentified from the other house (total mental blank this morning!!!)

if nagini cant be one - it proves that harry cant be!!

[Luna]

i'll need to look back on this thread im sure someone came up with an explanation as to how harry could have been a horcux